|
John and Brian bring up some very good points about this topic. Al wheels can help reduce both sprung weight and also the GVW but can be somewhat of a concern for other reasons. Steel wheels can split around the lug holes from over tightening just like Al ones can. Most steel wheels have one or more weld joints that can also crack however it is rare. Both have corosion problems but steel is usually the worst for bead corrosion. Al wheels can get bead corrosion but it is less likely than with steel. Most bead corrosion problems on any wheels are caused by tires that do not conform properly to the wheel itself and allow water, salt, ect to get between the tire and rim. Al wheels subjected to rough roads and off road use will usually have a higher failure rate than steel wheels subjected to the same type of abuse. The type of alloy used in the wheel is also a major concern as to the application of the wheel. The fancy type wheels used on SUV's and such are not actually designed for anything much more than looks and open smooth highway running. The Al wheels used on semi-trucks and trailers are quite different animals. These usually have a heavy duty construction that is designed to take the constant pounding of heavy loads and not so smooth roads. They do however have a limit to what they will take. Using these in such applications as mining and other off-road and corrosive duty is not acceptable. These environments are hard enough on steel wheels and seriously reduce the life span of the wheel itself. Fancy wheels are generally made from harder alloys so they can be made thinner and lighter. With Al this is a trade off between long life and durability. The harder the alloy, the more prone it is to sustain stress cracks and the softer the alloy, the more vibration and impact it will absorb without stress damage. A soft alloy will give and flex while a hard alloy will not, it'll crack first. The same story held true for dump bodies being made some years ago pushing the use of a steel alloy known as "T-1". It did not wear or dent as did the standard A-36 alloy but in a short time they were reduced to scrap because of stress cracks. Every box I have seen made from T-1 looked like an egg shell that was stepped on while the plain old A-36 steel bodies were dented up and worn down but still in relatively good shape. Same with Al dump bodies. Those that were welded with 5356 alloy wire usually suffer a high number of failed welds while those welded with the softer 4043 alloy wire did not. All the repairs I do on Al bodies are done with the 4043 and those areas prone to abrasion wear are capped with 5356 that does not touch both sides of the weldment at the same time, if it does, a crack will start and run the weld seam. Those Al rims used on motor homes and medium duty trucks are usually much lighter duty than those used on semi-trucks. These are used primarily to look good and a small secondary fuction is to reduce weight. These rims can last a good number of years but they must have proper installation and upkeep to maintain their structural integrity. Another problem is expansion and contraction. As wheels heat up from running and using brakes, they expand. They more they expand, the more dirt and crud that is allowed to enter into areas such as around the bead and also into the grain of the alloy itself. Expansion also increases the pressure between the lugs and the rim. The Al wheel expands much faster than the steel or cast iron brake drums and hubs. This constant movement between the rim and hub also causes stress to be induced into the wheel. The better the heat transfer from wheel to hub, the less expansion differential is seen between the dissimilar metals. Adding the anti-corrosion compound does help transfer heat better between the wheel and hub, while it is not a perfect medium, it does help more than nothing. Corrosion acts as a heat insulator and causes more problems than just the loss of structural integrity.
|