|
Hi Tim, A few months ago I did a side by side comparison of two auto-darkening helmets, one Chicago Electric (Harbor Freight) and one Hornell Speedglas. Those represent just about the extremes in price; variable shade Speedglas helmets sell for over $200 and as much as $350, HF variable shade A/D helmets are always on sale for $50. What you really need for a test like that is some way to make it a blind test (double blind is ideal). That's hard to do by yourself, and it leaves the test results vulnerable to your prejudices. For instance, I'm cheap, so I'd like the results to convince me that a $50 helmet can be as good---or at least more than 1/5 as good---as a $250 one. One conclusion I reached seemed quite objective because of a mistake I made. The Speedglas helmet had a large viewing window and the HF helmet had the standard sized one. At one point I made the mental observation that the visibility was very good, and I was ready to concede that the larger window actually made a difference. When I took off the helmet, however, I found that I had lost track and that I was wearing the HF helmet. The fair conclusion to draw from that, I feel, is that the larger viewing area made no difference to me. A larger window might make a difference if there was some reason to wear the helmet adjusted so that your eyes were the maximum possible distance from the inside of the window---if you needed to wear prescription eyeglasses under your helmet, for instance. With your eyes close enough to the window, however, the additional viewing area is outside your line of sight anyway. From a fixed position with your forehead pressed against the glass, you can see the street just as well out a 12"X12" window as you can through a huge picture window. I think the same thing applies here. All the best, Stan
|