|
Hi Goose, This is one of those subjects that really polarizes people. Some people are adamant in their belief that the cheap helmets fall somewhere between inadequate and worthless, some people find them perfectly adequate. I've had experience with several varieties of cheap helmets. Some of them didn't work as well as they should have---but only in non-critical areas like slow recovery time, the return to clear state from dark. That's annoying, but your eyes won't be harmed by it. I have found Harbor Freight's brand, Chicago Electric, to work just fine. The head of the welding program at the community college where I spend a lot of time hates all things Harbor Freight. He claims HF auto-darkening helmets are crap. Recently I decided to test helmets side by side under exactly the same conditions. I switched back and forth between my beat up HF helmet, and the boss's Speedglass (certainly one of the best brands available.) On two other occasions I did the same thing with another instructor's different model Speedglass helmet, and with a student's top rated helmet (don't remember that brand, though.) My conclusion was that the other helmets, at 5 to 6 times the cost of a $50 (on sale) HF helmet, had some features which were better, for sure, but none of them were better across the board. For instance, the instructor's Speedglass had a larger window, which I thought made much less difference than I expected it would. The clear state on that helmet was slightly lighter than the clear state of my helmet, which I felt was valuable, and the helmet's face plate was hinged so that the darkening unit could be swung up out of the way for grinding. I had very mixed feelings about this feature because I know that I would eventually duck under something not far enough and rip it off the helmet. I would consider it a good feature if I did my welding the same way in the same place every day, as in a production setting. But I'm hard on helmets as it is, and something sticking up an additional four inches just wouldn't be safe with me. I thought that the darkening speed, the recovery speed, and the darkening level of the HF helmet were all comparable with the expensive brands. So, for what it's worth, I'll probably stick with HF, maybe buy one helmet of a reputable brand just to wear when royalty visits. All the best, Stan
|