Welcome! Please use the navigational links to explore our website.
PartsASAP LogoCompany Logo (800) 853-2651

Shop Now

   Allis Chalmers Case Farmall IH Ford 8N,9N,2N Ford
   Ferguson John Deere Massey Ferguson Minn. Moline Oliver

Attention Forum Users: On the 28th of December 2023 at 9:00am Central Time, we will be taking the forums down for maintenance while we prepare the new forums for your use. Please click here for more information.

Tool Talk Discussion Forum

Portable generator problem

Welcome Guest, Log in or Register
Author 
Keith Nicholson

11-17-2006 07:05:34




Report to Moderator

Any help with this portable generator much appreciated. A generator (5.2 KVA) was bought to run a domestic house and a changeover switch was installed. When the generator was used the lights in the house went from normal to half brightness - all other electrical equipment was switched off. (the electrical installation at the time was an older fuse-wire fuseboard and separate earth leakage trip. After a few minutes the earth leakage trip tripped-out. The first generator was sent back and another bought (5.2 KVA), exactly the same problem occurred. The change over switch was removed. An electrician fitted a new fuseboard and the house earthing was brought up to modern standards and the electrician refitted the changeover switch. When the generator was connected the same problem of the voltage dropping to half on the generator occurred. Also, soon after the fuseboard was fitted the main mcb on the normal supply tripped-out. It would not reset until all individual mcb's were switched off, the main mcb was switched on, then all individual mcb's were switched on without the main mcb tripping out, but 10 minutes later the main mcb went off again, the main mcb tripping-out only occurred twice. After this some individual mcb's tripped-out but has not reoccurred in the last 3\4 weeks. The generator voltage via the underground cable was checked at the fuseboard and was normal. The generator has been tested independently of the house by connecting the generator to: a fridge freezer, a 25W light and a 2,050W handheld hot air gun, all run at the same time, the generator worked with no voltage drop. Before the new fuseboard was fitted a new light unit was fitted in the upper hallway. When the light switch was in the off position there was still power to the light of 24 V AC. The electrician returned and checked all the circuits and some circuits were showing some loss and suggests that all electrical fittings be individually tested.
Possible causes (?): - the changeover switch (test by bypassing the changeover switch.) - check all individual fittings. If the above are not the problem then it would be something in the house causing the generator to act as if it is grossly overloaded.

[Log in to Reply]   [No Email]
Keith Nicholson

11-20-2006 09:30:50




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
Thanks to everyone for replies, these are some queries that came up: Size of generator: 5KVA, I think this gives about 4.6W. When I bought this size I balanced that the geni would be an emergency one, not one to run the house continuously, so fuel consumption came into it. If we had a long power outage the geni would run the gas central heating, necessary house lights and the fridge freezers in turn. The output at the generator: gauge on geni reads 220V, actual output matches both at the geni and at the end of the cable that goes to the fuseboard(distribution board). In the it fuseboard has a main breaker (Residual Circuit Breaker) and each house circuit has an mcb (miniature circuit breaker). The 2050W hot air gun was just used to test the geni, as was the electric drill (both to put a motor load on the geni) No fluorescent lights were on during tests or would be used if we get geni working and have to use it. During final tests all individual circuits were switched off at the fuseboard except downstairs light circuit and then with only one 100W bulb on - the geni is happy to run only a 25W bulb as a load. Geni internal configuration: using my simple logic after the independent test loads on the geni is that it is OK. I bought the geni new in the UK and the seller says he checks all geni's and has sold hundreds to domestic buyers like me with no problems. Breaker amperage on generator: don't know but geni has never shut itself down or tripped out despite being pulled down to overload and 100V. UK and USA service\utility company supply: I don't think UK is same as USA where there are two 120V supplies, we have two wires coming in, I guess live and neutral. Other work done recently?: no, the last person to do any work was the electrician. Single pole transfer switch: no, the switch is a two pole switching both live and neutral. Grounding: the electrician had to install a new earth system (ground spike) to meet modern standards. With the ongoing problems the electrician suggested the geni needed its own earth ground spike, made no difference to prob. Wiring to connecting plug: the electrician wired up the plug so I assume he got it right. Who should find the problem?: the electrician can't solve the problem and until I can pinpoint the problem I am 'keeping my powder dry' but if I find it would have been reasonable for him to have found it, then ..... I have written to him today, but staying cool, and saying that if he believes our electrical fittings are the problem and that by testing them and renewing where necessary, this solves the problem I will pay. I also said that if he can't solve problem I will call in a consultant electrical engineer and if he says the electrician should have been able to find the fault and\or has made a mistake then I will go from there. Here I am way out of my depth: it seems to me that in the olden days there was just Live\hot, neutral\negative and earth\ground, now it seems that the neutral can somehow be used as an earth. My gut feeling is that the problem lies in the neutrals, or a mismatch of, in combination with the earths but I am guessing. Someone said they would need to be here to crack the problem and I can understand that. I fix laser printers and most probs are just one fault and a check-over. Yet after 10 years at it I still get the occasional fault that I have to walk away from for an hour and rethink everything and I would never have solved the fault at a distance. With the tests I have done, although real with results, I don't have the knowledge to make joined-up sense. I know an electronics and electrical wizard who I have pestered into possible helping me, I keep going into his office with a hangdog look (hope he's not reading this!), he may be coming in this afternoon, so fingers crossed. When the fault is found I'll be back. Thanks everyone. UPDATE The upper light switch was changed and there is now no 24V AC leakage to the light unit - the 40 year old light switch was stripped and was in a very dirty condition inside with a burnt contact. (the lower hallway light switch was also renewed). The geni was started-up with the change over switch (c\o switch) on mains supply, no effect on geni. With geni running the c\o switch was switched to geni and the main Residual Circuit Breaker (RCB) on the fuseboard\distribution board went to 'off', I could not reset RCB. The power switch on geni unit switched 'off', now could reset main RCB, geni switch to 'on', RCB tripped out again. C\o switch to geni, all mcb's (miniature circuit breakers to individual house circuits) 'off', geni running, geni power switch 'off', geni switch to 'on', RCB tripped out. Same test as but with all mcb's 'on', geni switch to 'on', geni went down to 100V. The whole situation has worsened in that before the geni would connect to the house circuit through the c\o switch but with just the lower hall circuit 'on'- all other individual circuit mcb's (miniature circuit breakers were 'off'), now it won't connect at all. (the two main cables going into the fuseboard are the same colour)

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
tech4

11-20-2006 11:18:03




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-20-2006 09:30:50  
Keith, I am sorry you are still having problems. I wonder if you could give me the make and model of the generator. I looked at a lot of schematic wiring diagrams of generators used in USA and every one had the neutral as used in the US connected to the chassis ground or earth connection of the generator. This would effectively short out one/half of the generator output when connected to your home mains that has one side of the 230 volts connected to earth ground. Most of these generators can be quickly modified to let the generator run floating above earth potential. This is usually just removing the chassis ground lug or cutting the connection between the US neutral and chassis ground(earth) connection.

A quick check to see if the generator has an internal connection to chassis is to : With genrator off and no connections to your transfer switch, take an ohm meter and check from each side of the 230 volt line to the metal frame chassis of generator for continuity. If you get a reading that is low such as 0-10 ohms then there is an internal jumper that needs to be removed. If there is no continuity or a very high reading 1 megohm or higher then there is no jumper and you need to look somewhere else. If you give me the make and model of generator, I will try to find wiring diagram on internet. Hope this helps.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
dr.sportster

11-18-2006 13:25:55




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
In the United States the electrician would be responsible for fixing this problem without charging more money as there is a one year unwritten warranty on electrical work.A service upgrade does not cause breaker tripping and its sure not your fault there is a problem now.Its not the fault of your original wiring that worked fine when buying power from public service.I dont feel you as the paying customer should have to troubleshoot anything.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
tech4

11-18-2006 09:02:48




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
I did a little research on the internet of the UK electrical system and as I see it your Mains are single phase 230 V AC 50Hz with one side of the 230 tied to ground or Earth as called in the UK. What I am not sure of is your generator and the wiring to the connecting plug. The generator may have jumpers or a configuration for 120 volts but unused in the UK. There maybe a grounded center tap on the generator also that needs to be disconnected. Since you have plugged in direct to power refrigerators and appliances, we know that you do have 230 volts available. I am sure that when you powered the appliances that you had no earth connection made and the generator was "floating" and everything worked. My guess is that either the hot and earth connections are reversed or the generator has an internal or external jumper that splits the 230 to 120 V. The other possibility is that you have a real heavy load that is loading the generator down and you could start turning off circuit breakers to isolate that possibility. As to the 24 volts across the light fixture that is off, I would not be concerned if you were using a high impedance digital voltmeter since it is stray induced voltage that will go to zero with a light load or a low impedance analog voltmeter.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Doug in Illinois

11-17-2006 20:06:19




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
Not going to ramble on, but electrical problems can be tricky. Just got my Hillsboro trailer back from trailer shop after 3 failed attempts at their shop after a half dozen attempts of my own at repairing a fuse blowing/ voltage drop problem. They found it on the 4th try. It was a bad GROUND on the trailer. Hooked to the wiring tester, everything indicated it was working right until it got hooked to the truck at which time it all messed back up. Admittedly, the trailer wiring before repairs started was a mess. Wonder if something similar going on here with common wire/ground? Just a thought.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
buickanddeere

11-17-2006 18:31:19




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
I suspect you need an electrician who is more familar with generators, transfer switches and neutrals. You may have a single pole transfer switch and a generator with a bonded neutral? Two poles would be required. Where all are the connections and bonds between ground/earth and the neutral conductor in the generator, transfer switch, hydro meter base, main service panel and transfer panel. Another thought is that somehow the live line is getting tied to the ground system and the neutral is floating isolated from true earth. I've seen a 120V 15amp breaker curcuit tied to a ground rod in dry weather. The breaker never tripped, not enough current flowing to earth. I assume this transfer switch powers the whole hydro service panel from the generator?

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
dr.sportster

11-17-2006 17:09:20




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
Your home had no wiring problem as in tripping breakers until you got this generator so dont spend too much effort troubleshooting things that werent broke before.[that 24v is interesting though]Also it is normal for a main to retrip if you dont shed other loads by turning off all the branch circuit breakers first.Are you sure this generator is big enough?Its unlikely more than one circuit in the house would cause a problem.Wire does not go bad from point A to point B with out some other influence[chemical,plumber with sawzall,cable tv guy with drill etc].Especially more than one circuit suddenly having tripping problems[except maybe with water].Post more info if you find the cause.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
dr.sportster

11-17-2006 16:54:07




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
I had to read that three times.The generator takes other loads ok when not connected to the panel[just thinking out loud] So the house circuitry loads might be checked with an Amprobe brand type ammeter to see the draw on each.If they are excessive maybe the loads are too inductive causing poor power factor.Is there alot of flourescent lighting?The fact of 24 volts at the light fixture indicates possible voltage on the neutral because the switch normaly feeding the light fixture is open.Is that measured between hot and neutral at the fixture?Is that a multiwire branch circuit where the neutral is lost or loose and the other leg is backfeeding through?How is the circuit being completed for that 24v reading unless the hot from the switch to the light has a nail through maybe from aluminum siding?If the hot is truly deadended at that switch isolate that wire and check for continuity using an extension cord and wiggy or voltmeter[plugging cord into another source].Put an Amprobe on the feed for that fixture with the 24v reading also.Amprobe reading at each leg of the generator will tell if the generator is overloaded to start.Are all three wire circuits phased correctly in the panel so the returning current on the neutral is cancelling and not overloading.Like three wires are say black phase A red phase B?Not B on black and red on phase A or both on B?If a fitting was scewed into a wire[bx connector screw too tight jamming into cable] then only one circuit that had that damage would trip,not several.Does the 24v go away when on power company power?You could feed the loads of each of your circuits temp with extension cords and see what happens to eliminate them individually and sort of eliminate the wiring feeding them each circuit at a time.Fridge first then next largest etc.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Stan in Oly, WA

11-17-2006 15:15:20




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
Hi Keith,

What is the physical arrangement for running appliances on 240 volt power? In the U.S., most houses are supplied with 240 volt power which is furnished by the utility company as 2 separate 120 volt lines and a neutral line to the breaker box (or fuse box.) Small appliances and tools usually run at 120 volts (also called 110 volts and 115 volts.) They do this by drawing current from one of the two "legs" in the breaker box and returning it to the neutral bar. Major appliances and tools often run at 240 volts (also called 220 & 230). They do this by drawing from both incoming lines. These lines are 180 degrees out of phase with each other which makes it possible for them to serve as each others' neutral leg in alternation. When these appliances are grounded, as they ususally are, the ground does not serve as part of the circuit, until or unless there is a short. This is a very oversimplified description of how this part of the electrical system works.

I can think of two ways your 240 volt system could be set up: All of your appliances could run on two alternate phase 120 volt lines as our 240 volt appliances do; or, your power into the main box could be a single 240 volt line (and a neutral.) Then all your appliances would be wired and run as our 120 volt appliances do, except they would be receiving 240 volts.

Another question: What are "main mcb's" and "individual mcb's"?

The light fixture in your upper hall registers 24 V AC when the switch is off because the neutral side is interrupted by the switch rather than the hot side. This is not the installation an experienced electrician would do.

You have demonstrated sufficiently that your generator is not the source of your problem (by overkill if nothing else.) Isolating the generator from the rest of the system and running a heavy load on it successfully is sufficient evidence that the problem is elsewhere. Unfortunately, when you have a problem where breakers trip, but not immediately, you're in territory that's beyond my level of expertise. I could find the problem and correct it if I were there, but I don't know enough to be able to troubleshoot it theoretically. Others on this forum can, though.

All the best, Stan

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
JT

11-17-2006 14:16:17




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
Is this a 5.2KVA generator or a 5.2KW generator. What is your output at the generator? Here in the US all generators are listed in wattage not voltage. If you do actually have a 5.2KW generator, you might not have enough generator to run all you need to run, especially if one dryer you are using is 2kw dryer, that alone would be taking 1/2 of the generator output. Now, again in the US they list them as starting watts and running watts, and if this is a 5.2KW generator, and this is starting watts, you need a lot more genrator to run your stuff, especially if it is all 240V. What amperage does the breakers on the generator have. Just a few thoughts.
Jim

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Bus Driver

11-17-2006 11:45:49




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
Do some testing with a voltmeter.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
tech4

11-17-2006 08:02:55




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
It sounds like you have the generator connected up wrong. You have 120 volts across the 240 volt split bus. The ground on the generator is just a safety ground and not tied to the neutral at the generator.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
tech4

11-17-2006 08:18:45




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to tech4, 11-17-2006 08:02:55  
Yea I re-read and thought you in UK where it is 240 50Hz. I still think the generator is connected wrong and I don't know the standard generator wiring connections for UK standards.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Keith Nicholson

11-17-2006 08:18:42




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to tech4, 11-17-2006 08:02:55  
Hi tech4,
Thanks for reply.
I should have said our mains supply is 240V AC (in England).
As you can tell I am not an electical engineer -give me a car gearbox anyday.
I am wondering if the electrician has wired up something wrong. I posted a reply to Ralph saying the tests I am going to do tomorrow which will take out the change-over switch and\or wrong wiring.
Thanks, Keith



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Ralph - Ohio

11-17-2006 07:40:04




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 07:05:34  
You don't mention supply voltages but from some of your terms and the reference to a 2050 watt hot air gun it sounds as if you may not be in the US but perhaps somewhere where the standard supply voltage is around 240 volts AC. Is that correct? This information and more details on the generator and how it is connected would be helpful in diagnosing the problem.

If this is a normal US 120/240 volt system and you are connecting 240 volts from the generator to the house, my best guess is that you don't have a good connection from the generator neutral wire to the house neutral.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Keith Nicholson

11-17-2006 08:09:50




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Ralph - Ohio, 11-17-2006 07:40:04  
Hi Ralph,
Thanks for reply.
You are right: 240V AC in England.
Connection: the switchbox is just like a railway points system so the when s\box is switched to generator the mains supply is (should be) isolated.
Not sure on generator details besides diesel, 5KW?
All the cabling from geni to house and from mains supply to s\box and then to fuse board is new. But, as you say, there could still be a poor connection.
As you can tell I am not an electrical engineer but I am going to do a couple of tests tommorrow: 1, power up the generator, leave the s\box to mains and see how the generator reacts; 2, disconnect the mains power from the fuseboard and connect the generator direct to the fuseboard, this would take the box, bad connections, wrong connections out of things.
Many thanks. Hope the weather is better in Ohio, we got a storm with rain drops the size of marbles!

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Keith Nicholson

11-17-2006 23:51:36




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 08:09:50  
Hi all,
Many, many thanks for all the replies.
It's now 07.45 and it's not raining so after I've done the dishes I am going to do the tests. This afternoon I will print-out all your replies and go through each one to give me a program and tests to do. Thank you all again, I don't feel so much on my own now.
(the English always have to mention the weather. We have many dear friends stateside and when two came in May they asked, 'what clothes should they bring?, well, full arctic gear, full storm gear and T shirt and shorts should cover most weather here!)
Kind regards to you all, Keith
Regards, Keith

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Keith Nicholson

12-20-2006 01:03:17




Report to Moderator
 Re: Portable generator problem in reply to Keith Nicholson, 11-17-2006 23:51:36  
Hi everyone,
At last the portable generator works on our house system!
The solution was to put a connection between neutral and earth inside the generator. An easy test to get to the problem would have been to take a volt reading between live and earth and neutral and earth and if the readings are 110\120, and 240 is required, then you have the same problem as I had.(but why, before putting the link in, it showed 240 volt across live and neutral I don't know.)
What fooled me into thinking it was a problem with the house was that on the independent test of running appliances on the generator they worked.
As you can imagine I am not too happy with the company that sold me the generator as suitable to run a house.
Many thanks to all of you.
Happy Christmas.
Regards,
Keith

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
[Options]  [Printer Friendly]  [Posting Help]  [Return to Forum]   [Log in to Reply]

Hop to:


TRACTOR PARTS TRACTOR MANUALS
We sell tractor parts!  We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today. [ About Us ]

Home  |  Forums


Copyright © 1997-2023 Yesterday's Tractor Co.

All Rights Reserved. Reproduction of any part of this website, including design and content, without written permission is strictly prohibited. Trade Marks and Trade Names contained and used in this Website are those of others, and are used in this Website in a descriptive sense to refer to the products of others. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy

TRADEMARK DISCLAIMER: Tradenames and Trademarks referred to within Yesterday's Tractor Co. products and within the Yesterday's Tractor Co. websites are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Yesterday's Tractor Co., our products, or our website nor are we sponsored by them. John Deere and its logos are the registered trademarks of the John Deere Corporation. Agco, Agco Allis, White, Massey Ferguson and their logos are the registered trademarks of AGCO Corporation. Case, Case-IH, Farmall, International Harvester, New Holland and their logos are registered trademarks of CNH Global N.V.

Yesterday's Tractors - Antique Tractor Headquarters

Website Accessibility Policy