Welcome! Please use the navigational links to explore our website.
PartsASAP LogoCompany Logo (800) 853-2651

Shop Now

   Allis Chalmers Case Farmall IH Ford 8N,9N,2N Ford
   Ferguson John Deere Massey Ferguson Minn. Moline Oliver

Attention Forum Users: On the 28th of December 2023 at 9:00am Central Time, we will be taking the forums down for maintenance while we prepare the new forums for your use. Please click here for more information.

Tool Talk Discussion Forum

Stick or automatic

Welcome Guest, Log in or Register
Author 
Jim801

10-16-2005 17:31:16




Report to Moderator

Please help, This question is not to find out who likes Ford Chevy Dodge but what works the best for this job. I tow a heavy duty 16ft goose neck dump trailer with a bobcat or trackhoe inside.With a f250 diesel 3/4 ton 4x4 automatic. I want to up grade to a f350 but with manual tranny 6 speed,do to the lugging an tugging going on, going up an down missouri hills.Some say oh the 2000 or newer fords have a Allison tranny go with the auto,others say no go manual thats what there made for pulling.I know the torque converter which was just replaced in my ford cost 700.00 an I dont want to repeat it.

[Log in to Reply]   [No Email]
Haas mileage

10-18-2005 14:27:06




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Jim801, 10-16-2005 17:31:16  
Forgot to give the data on mileage. My Duramax six speed stick got 20 MPG not towing, local or cruising. Towing max rated load on a gooseneck, I never got less than 12 mpg. The Duramax with allison gets 19 cruising, 17 local traveling and 11 towing max rated load. I suppose the reason for less mileage on local is that the auto mostly keeps you running at above 2000 rpm, whereas with the stick, you can lug down. Not a direct comparison, as the stick was a regular cab long bed 2500HD and the Allison is an extended cab long bed 2500HD, so the truck weighs more. So you can see there is a pretty good penalty on mileage for the automatic. However, with the stick, with a heavy load, you have to start in 1st and usually use all 6 gears. With no load, you can start in 2nd or 3rd and drive it like a 3 speed manual, skipping gears. With the auto, you just step on the accelerator and if you have a heavy load, push the tow/haul button.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Haas

10-18-2005 13:29:46




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Jim801, 10-16-2005 17:31:16  
It's all economics. The auto is going to be more expensive, but if you want to pay the price, much more convenient to drive, especially when towing. I've had both in a chevy. The allison holds 24 quarts of fluid and if used in towing the manual says to change every 25,000 miles. That is an expensive change. For the 6 speed stick, the manual says to change the synthetic fluid every 150,000 miles. So if you don't mind shifting gears, go with the manual. I now have the auto because the wife refused to drive the manual 6 speed I used to have.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Mike S

10-18-2005 04:53:44




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Jim801, 10-16-2005 17:31:16  
I have a 91 Ford F450 Super Duty with auto and a 460 V8. Have 145k miles on it and it has towed everything from small dozers to large horse trailers that hold 4 horses and a sleeping unit. No problems with the auto. Likes gas but gets about the same as my buddy's Ford diesel.And now diesel is more than regular at the pumps. Have no idea who made the auto, it is a overdrive unit. Truck has 4 wheel disc brakes and they stop most anything. Right now, I put a dump insert in the bed and it still hauls a good load with no problems. I understand tho, that some of the newer Dodge and Chevy diesels put out almost 600lbs of torque which is a heck of alot more than my 460. I guess depends on how deep your pockets are.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Bernoulli

10-17-2005 11:50:19




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Jim801, 10-16-2005 17:31:16  
Many years ago I bought a Dodge crew cab with an automatic and pulled an 18 foot travel trailer behind it hunting. Coming out of our camp was a several mile downgrade. It didn't take long to realize I'd made a mistake. I much prefer the control I have with a manual. I have not pulled anything much over 12000 pounds, but I imagine the principle remains the same.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
chvet73

10-17-2005 09:05:13




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Jim801, 10-16-2005 17:31:16  
Compare the cost of repairs on a stick vs. auto. The auto will send you to the poor house. In most cases, if you drive them right the stick will be far less costly to maintain. As to performance, the stick wins every time. I like being in control of the vehicle. There are no automatics on the 4 vehicles in my house. The wife would not have an auto either. By the way I have 15 metal parts holding my back together and a very bad knee, but still would not consider an auto.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
kidbob

10-16-2005 20:58:16




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Jim801, 10-16-2005 17:31:16  
My experence is with older light trucks. We had a '79 Chevy with an auto, pulled a 20' gooseneck a lot, sold it at 100,000 no trouble.
Replaced it with an IH 5 speed, rebuilt that two or three times is less miles.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
farmermatt

10-16-2005 20:34:31




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Jim801, 10-16-2005 17:31:16  
I drive a 99 F-350 with the 6 speed and powerstroke. I find it a bit doggy with the 6spd. It probably just my driving style. The RPMs on the 7.3 drop quickly as you shift. I dont like to run the motor fast and I dont like to shift fast and hard. Youve gotta keep the rpms atleast 2000 to have any lug to it. All that said..... Im still happy with it after 2 yrs, Im not out to race it, just wanted something durable its has 155000 on it, and I did have to replace the throughout bearing. The clutch still looked great so put in a $30 through out and $11 pilot bearing. Surprisingly cheap repair.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
jfp

10-16-2005 18:36:34




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Jim801, 10-16-2005 17:31:16  
Get the stick and you won't be sorry. Clutches are cheaper than converters if it does go out.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
old

10-16-2005 17:46:21




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Jim801, 10-16-2005 17:31:16  
Stick is the way to go, ya the have the new autos but they get wrose gas mileage then a stick does. Also a stick will out last an auto hands down. Plus think about this. What does almost all the big rigs on the road have in them. There most be a reason most have sticks instead of the auto



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
White Line Fever?

10-17-2005 06:17:28




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to old, 10-16-2005 17:46:21  
ShepFL here. Started reading this post and that song popped into my head :)

I used to drive logging truck many moons ago in a raggy Gypo rig. Left that and never looked back. One problem I see is the newer driver DO NOT know how to back up!

Thanking all you short haul and long haul drivers out there! I still work in logistics just on the s/w side now.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
E

10-16-2005 20:49:13




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to old, 10-16-2005 17:46:21  
Old....Sticks are starting to go by the wayside in the big trucks. I worked for Cummins for several years and most of the fleets are demanding the auto sticks for economy and so any bozo can get behind the seat and drive.

One thing to think about is how good your left knee is. I've switched jobs and do more city driving now. With all the extra clutching I do, I've noticed my left knee is starting to act up. I'd hate to give up the truck since I am getting great milage with the 5 speed. Oh well:(

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Stickler

10-18-2005 06:39:11




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to E, 10-16-2005 20:49:13  
I think the reason automatics are starting to be used more in highway tractors is that most of the younger generation don't know how to shift gears properly. It's like giving a kid that's grown up with MS Windows a Commodore 64 and telling him to go to it. They don't remember all that Load*.*,8,1 stuff. I can attest to the benefits of the autos though for off-road driving. Used to drive big old Euclid R50 rock wagons in a former life, then long haul.

As for manual transmissions vs autos in smaller vehicles....there are auto trans shops on about every second street corner anymore. Not many manual trans rebuilders left though. That in itself has to tell you something. Most problems like release bearings and clutches are due to the driver riding the clutch, or slipping it, or not downshifting properly.

They fail you here too for not using the clutch on every shift on a driver's test, but after that, some drivers do, some don't. I have the old RoadRanger 10 spd in my '60 KW too. Once you're moving, you never touch the clutch again. I had bosses years ago that would have fired a driver for using the clutch to shift. What a changed world!

Wife's little minivan is our only vehicle of 13 with an auto, and the only one of 13 that's ever given any trans trouble.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
old

10-16-2005 21:12:36




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to E, 10-16-2005 20:49:13  
Guess I also should have told you I'm a retired trucker with more the 1.5 million miles under my belt. LOL



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
old

10-16-2005 21:01:22




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to E, 10-16-2005 20:49:13  
I understand the knee problem. I have a bad back, right shoulder and both my knees are bad but I'm not going to go the an auto till I die no matter what. Ya some of the big rigs are going to autos but the trucks spend more time in the shop then the ones with sticks.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Leland

10-17-2005 20:25:58




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to old, 10-16-2005 21:01:22  
I must be the only one that prefers an auto in a truck some years I was driving a GMC General that had a allison in it and it was heaven doing off road work with bacause you could stop in 2' deep ruts and just barely touch the gas and the truck would just wind up slowly and when the front wheels would lift it would take off and go .they have improved them where they have auto braking and other good things to help but milage will suffer but if off road it will be worth it .

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
e

10-16-2005 21:13:19




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to old, 10-16-2005 21:01:22  
I would take any old road ranger transmission over those new auto sticks any day. I understand why they are switching to them, but they sure take the fun out of driving!



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
old

10-16-2005 21:38:58




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to e, 10-16-2005 21:13:19  
Oh you mean like the fuller road ranger I have in my 1963 Diamond-T 990 road tractor. I have also drove the good old twin sticks which are a lot of fun to drive but you need 2 right arms to do it well. LOL



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Mike M

10-17-2005 05:10:17




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to old, 10-16-2005 21:38:58  
Did you use your clutch when shifting between gears ? Reason I ask is that a friend of mine went to take the CDL test. I guess they will fail you if you don't use the clutch on every shift.I had a weeks worth of seat time driveing an old Mack dump truck with one of those twin stick trannys once. We used the clutch to start and stop but in between just let off the throttle and shift. If you did it at the right rpms it went right in real easy,if you messed up it seemed like you could never get it back in gear unless you came to a dead stop and started back up through again. Was this how it was for you or was I showed how to do this all wrong ? Just curious.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
George in Biloxi

10-17-2005 14:36:40




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Mike M, 10-17-2005 05:10:17  
The manual for my 1963 Mack 10 speed duplex says to always use the clutch. I know people that don't though. I always do. Not many young people can drive it decently.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
old

10-17-2005 12:12:25




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Mike M, 10-17-2005 05:10:17  
I used the clutch most of the time, didn't at time but most of the time I did. Had to double clutch alot also.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
jfp

10-17-2005 06:50:35




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to Mike M, 10-17-2005 05:10:17  
Back in 80 I did get gigged on the CDL test for not using the clutch but they passed me anyway. Female testor, the toughest kind.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
farmermatt

10-18-2005 12:01:50




Report to Moderator
 Re: Stick or automatic in reply to jfp, 10-17-2005 06:50:35  
Ive never heard of clutching (other than starting movement) with an Eaton road ranger. Im not a truck driver by anymeans but run about 3000 miles a year hauling grain 20 miles a round trip in my frieghtliner. CDL test was with a super 10 and all the tester said was as soon as you get in, leave the clutch engaged and try to pull it into gear..... . "you might as well grind em once and get your 1 point (only counts against you once) out of about 120 deducted" that way you can relax, not worry about perfect shifting, and concentrate on the rest of the driving skills. Guess Ill work the clutch alittle more this afternoon when I head back into town, see how it works.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
[Options]  [Printer Friendly]  [Posting Help]  [Return to Forum]   [Log in to Reply]

Hop to:


TRACTOR PARTS TRACTOR MANUALS
We sell tractor parts!  We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today. [ About Us ]

Home  |  Forums


Copyright © 1997-2023 Yesterday's Tractor Co.

All Rights Reserved. Reproduction of any part of this website, including design and content, without written permission is strictly prohibited. Trade Marks and Trade Names contained and used in this Website are those of others, and are used in this Website in a descriptive sense to refer to the products of others. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy

TRADEMARK DISCLAIMER: Tradenames and Trademarks referred to within Yesterday's Tractor Co. products and within the Yesterday's Tractor Co. websites are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Yesterday's Tractor Co., our products, or our website nor are we sponsored by them. John Deere and its logos are the registered trademarks of the John Deere Corporation. Agco, Agco Allis, White, Massey Ferguson and their logos are the registered trademarks of AGCO Corporation. Case, Case-IH, Farmall, International Harvester, New Holland and their logos are registered trademarks of CNH Global N.V.

Yesterday's Tractors - Antique Tractor Headquarters

Website Accessibility Policy