|
At work I got into quite some discussion about torque wrenches, specifically the micrometer type/click type tool. The discussion centered about the fact that I felt the outer housing of the tool was rigid and it really would not matter if you grasp it at the knurled handle or further in on the body of the tool. The effort you would exert would be more if you grasp it further in, but the fastner would see the same torque when it clicked. The click is "the click" right? This seems quite a logical assumption for the click type torque wrench but the discussion was with the man who calibrates our several hundred different torque wrenches. We took a good one, right off the rack and put it in the calibrater. Set the tool to pull at the center point of the knurled handle, the correct grasping point and it was absolutely accurate. Then we set the tester to pull on the body of the tool, further in from the knurled handle portion. Now mind you, I am talking the micrometer type/click type tool, NOT a bending beam type, which I am well aware must be pulled on by the handle, using a floating one on a pivot pin. Anyhow, the further in on the handle of the click type we pulled, the less accurate it was. Basically, it boiled down to the fact that in order to make the tool light in weight, the tube that makes up the tool has to be thin, so thin that it bends when torque is applied. This bending is taken into account in the design of the click type tools and if you pull anywhere other than where you are supposed to, the tool will not bend properly and the clicker will not be clicking at the correct, set torque. I would not have believed it except that I saw it on the tester myself. Dial type torque wrenches, on the other hand are a rigid type tool and most larger ones, 3/4 drive and up, are designed to be used with extension handles or without, being completely rigid with the dial reading the turning of the square drive inside the tool, length doesn't affect it, nor does the point at which you grasp the handle. Old bending beam type torque wrenches are the most accurate (according to the guy who calibrates our tools) but are the pickiest about being handled just so and grasp and pulled just so properly. I had a brand new Utica 1/4 drive click type I had bought govt surplus and it was out of limits and also the errors were non-linear and thus could not be corrected, small pile of junk. Charles
|