|
Let me add a bit to the explanation. 2 inch square tubing is stronger than 2 inch round tubing. However, for the same weight per foot, you could use 2.5 inch round tubing and it would be considerably stronger than the 2 inch square. 2 inch square tubing rotated 45 degrees to the load will be stiffer/stronger than tubing laid flat. Oriented this way, it will use up 2.8 inches of headroom in the car, and you will lose some of the benefits of ease of welding you would otherwise have gotten from the square tube. Rough guessing, for a load placed perfectly across the diagonal, the square tube will be about as stiff as our hypothetical 2.5 inch round tubing, maybe a little stiffer. (Much stiffer yet would be a 1" x 4" rectangular tube, laid with the 4" dimension vertical -- which is what I was trying to say in the earlier post.) In a roll-over I would expect that the load might be applied off-axis to some degree (the car may be moving forward as it is flipping over, loading the top tube at an angle, not perfectly perpendicular to the roof). For this reason, I consider round tubing generally "better", because it is equally strong in all directions. With a reasonable amount of safety margin in the design of the roll cage, the differences aren't so severe as to make one design OK and the other "not OK", and the fabricator's personal taste may come into play.
|