Welcome! Please use the navigational links to explore our website.
PartsASAP LogoCompany Logo (800) 853-2651

Shop Now

   Allis Chalmers Case Farmall IH Ford 8N,9N,2N Ford
   Ferguson John Deere Massey Ferguson Minn. Moline Oliver

Attention Forum Users: On the 28th of December 2023 at 9:00am Central Time, we will be taking the forums down for maintenance while we prepare the new forums for your use. Please click here for more information.

Tool Talk Discussion Forum

Square tubing or round?

Welcome Guest, Log in or Register
Author 
Mike706

09-07-2003 13:41:20




Report to Moderator

My friend and i were talking the other day about the roll cage in his racecar and he used squared tubing. I asked him why he used that since i didnt think it was as strong as round since round can support equally from all sides whereas square tubing can flatten much easier. Can someone tell me if i am right on this or if square tubing really is stronger. I know its pry the oddest question asked in here but i figured if anyone knew u guys would.
Mike706

[Log in to Reply]   [No Email]
Dave Wis

09-09-2003 19:38:26




Report to Moderator
 Re: Square tubing or round? in reply to Mike706, 09-07-2003 13:41:20  
The strength of the shape of tubing aside, most sanctioning bodies I'm familiar with prohibit anything but round tubing for the main cage. It is allowed for parts of the structure outside the main cage. ALWAYS put safety first.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
David - OR

09-07-2003 13:58:25




Report to Moderator
 Re: Square tubing or round? in reply to Mike706, 09-07-2003 13:41:20  
For a given weight of material, round tubing is stronger than square tubing, for the reason you give. Beam bending strength and column stiffness are a function of moment of inertia of the shape, and a round, hollow shape gets the material farthest away from the neutral axis.

If the loading is asymmetric, rectangular tubing may be stronger than round tubing, so long as the wider dimension is oriented to resist the higher force (as with floor joists). This is also true for columns which are restrained in one direction but not another. (A stud wall, for example).

There are some secondary considerations. Round tubing requires fishmouth cuts to make joints suitable for welding, whereas square tubing can allow simple butt joints, or various forms of splines can be used. If the weakest part of the roll cage is the welding, then maybe the strength difference on the tubing is not so important.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
glenshoe

09-08-2003 04:36:03




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Square tubing or round? in reply to David - OR, 09-07-2003 13:58:25  
David, that has to be one of the clearest, to-the-point explanations I've seen here. Thanks, Glenn



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
glenshoe

09-08-2003 04:37:48




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Square tubing or round? in reply to glenshoe, 09-08-2003 04:36:03  
Except I forgot to add that T-Bone is usually right on as well.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Mike 706

09-07-2003 14:04:18




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Square tubing or round? in reply to David - OR, 09-07-2003 13:58:25  
Thanks for your help. Both cages that i have seen used a different type and both are welded good. By the asymmetric part do u mean if i like the square tubing is layed so that if the car rolled over the corner of the tubing would hit before the flat side right?



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
David - OR

09-08-2003 07:27:37




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Square tubing or round? in reply to Mike 706, 09-07-2003 14:04:18  
Let me add a bit to the explanation. 2 inch square tubing is stronger than 2 inch round tubing. However, for the same weight per foot, you could use 2.5 inch round tubing and it would be considerably stronger than the 2 inch square.

2 inch square tubing rotated 45 degrees to the load will be stiffer/stronger than tubing laid flat. Oriented this way, it will use up 2.8 inches of headroom in the car, and you will lose some of the benefits of ease of welding you would otherwise have gotten from the square tube.

Rough guessing, for a load placed perfectly across the diagonal, the square tube will be about as stiff as our hypothetical 2.5 inch round tubing, maybe a little stiffer. (Much stiffer yet would be a 1" x 4" rectangular tube, laid with the 4" dimension vertical -- which is what I was trying to say in the earlier post.)

In a roll-over I would expect that the load might be applied off-axis to some degree (the car may be moving forward as it is flipping over, loading the top tube at an angle, not perfectly perpendicular to the roof). For this reason, I consider round tubing generally "better", because it is equally strong in all directions.

With a reasonable amount of safety margin in the design of the roll cage, the differences aren't so severe as to make one design OK and the other "not OK", and the fabricator's personal taste may come into play.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
john

09-08-2003 04:09:37




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Square tubing or round? in reply to Mike 706, 09-07-2003 14:04:18  
yes. say you have 2x4 tubing. you would want the 2 against the roof so in a roll over it would be trying to bend the 4.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
T_Bone

09-08-2003 12:30:58




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Square tubing or round? in reply to john, 09-08-2003 04:09:37  
Hi Mike,

Can't expand on what David said as he eplained it well. A good cheap visual of what was explained would be to make a small model with PVC.

Make one in a quanset hut design and another square with a typical roof truss design.

Hang cinder block weights in the center and see just how much better the 1/2 round shape holds with less bracing than a square design.

The same theory would apply to structual members to make that design.

T_Bone

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
[Options]  [Printer Friendly]  [Posting Help]  [Return to Forum]   [Log in to Reply]

Hop to:


TRACTOR PARTS TRACTOR MANUALS
We sell tractor parts!  We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today. [ About Us ]

Home  |  Forums


Copyright © 1997-2023 Yesterday's Tractor Co.

All Rights Reserved. Reproduction of any part of this website, including design and content, without written permission is strictly prohibited. Trade Marks and Trade Names contained and used in this Website are those of others, and are used in this Website in a descriptive sense to refer to the products of others. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy

TRADEMARK DISCLAIMER: Tradenames and Trademarks referred to within Yesterday's Tractor Co. products and within the Yesterday's Tractor Co. websites are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Yesterday's Tractor Co., our products, or our website nor are we sponsored by them. John Deere and its logos are the registered trademarks of the John Deere Corporation. Agco, Agco Allis, White, Massey Ferguson and their logos are the registered trademarks of AGCO Corporation. Case, Case-IH, Farmall, International Harvester, New Holland and their logos are registered trademarks of CNH Global N.V.

Yesterday's Tractors - Antique Tractor Headquarters

Website Accessibility Policy