I guess I agree with Fawteen pretty much down the line, heres an example. I'm a non-union videographer, heres why. If I enter a union it'd be like the Editors guild or something, but if I do heres the deal. I can only do my job description if the thing I want to do could be done by another union worker. So, if I'm an editor and the project I'm working on needs sound design rather than just doing it I need to hire a sound designer, OR I need to join that guild. Ducky, that makes a bunch of sense. So rather than me being a working guild member supporting a guild job the guild gets NOTHING.I spent a summer as a laborer on a bridge. The steel workers and rodbusters were union, we were not. If I got caught retieing a joint that a rodbuster screwed up, or more commonly just got broke from being walked on, I got fined $25. Now, my job was to clean the deck prior to pouring concrete. So I had to cleanup the cigarrete butts and tobacco spittings of the rodbusters who were in general 300 feet in front of me. I walked the whole area of the pour 5 times doing that. If I needed something retied it'd take DAYS before one of the lazy rodbusters would come over and do it. They started later than us, ended earlier than us, took longer breaks than us, and got paid more than us. In general my experience was that the Union guys had NO hustle because they knew their jobs were protected. It was real hard to get a lazy rodbuster fired, while somebody on my crew didn't pull their weight was gone in a day. I've worked a couple summers as a surveyors assistant, one job we did alot of work on was an expansion for National Semiconductor, lots of union people on that job. While we were on that job one of the most frustrating things was that parts of my job were proportely "union" jobs, including sweeping off the points we had set that got covered with dust and construction debris. So if I went to set the instrument and had to clear a point, if I cleared it with a swipe of my boot that was okay, but if I used a little wisk broom that was a union job that I was "stealing" from a union worker and not allowed, again a $25 fine. Thus if we had to shovel or something we'd have to go get a union guy to do it for us. This was very important because if we didn't the union guys would do things like put truckloads of junk on our points to make it harder for us. No, my experience with unions has been very, very bad. I wouldn't join one now for all the money in the world.
|