Welcome! Please use the navigational links to explore our website.
PartsASAP LogoCompany Logo (800) 853-2651

Shop Now

   Allis Chalmers Case Farmall IH Ford 8N,9N,2N Ford
   Ferguson John Deere Massey Ferguson Minn. Moline Oliver

Attention Forum Users: On the 28th of December 2023 at 9:00am Central Time, we will be taking the forums down for maintenance while we prepare the new forums for your use. Please click here for more information.

Discussion Forum
:

John Deere Parts

Welcome Guest, Log in or Register
Author 
jason r

09-27-2002 11:32:49




Report to Moderator

Just a vent for the everyone. My 46 B had a Clutch Dog break on it.. i figured i'll get one from my deere dealer. boy was i surprised when the parts guy told me it was $55 for it. to me that is an outragous price for that part. I can see that for a bearing or some other parts and i have paid a lot for parts from deere that were competitive with salvage yards but that wow! so the man took the part back and i found one a a local yard. so if you have one break don't go to deere!

[Log in to Reply]   [No Email]
Rodney A. Johnson

09-30-2002 07:38:53




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
I've read through all the posts, and amazed at how many are not looking at things in there proper perspective.

Do you really believe that it costs nothing to keep an old forging and assembly line process going that is over 50 years old? Where do you store all that equipment? Do you think the buildings can be put up for nothing? These are real live costs that have increased over the years. Keep in mind that legally, they only need to provide parts for 15 years after they created them if I recall correctly.

Also keep in mind that they have to remain profitable in order to survive. Where do you think most of their revenue comes from. From the large farmers. Yes it is true that many small farmers could purchase more than a large farmer, more farmers creates more jobs, buys more supplies, etc. The problem is government support prices encourage large farms. Most everyone in the country buys from the cheapest high volume discount stores instead of their local family owned business (such as elevators, gas stations, grocery store, butcher, implement dealer, clothing store, etc).

Are you willing to pay $10 for a loaf of bread. How can a small farmer make it when you get less for your crop than you did 30+ years ago? Meanwhile, everything has gone up in price. The answer is you have to get bigger so that the cost of equipment is less per acre. You need higher tech equipment (such as GPS) to get more out of your land per acre (fertilizing based on what the soil needs in a particular spot). Again you need to get the cost of production of crop down per acre. All of these are hard to do when you are small.

I grew up on a dairy farm with only 40 cows (total of 100 head with young stock). Believe me I wish I could go back to that way of life, unfortunately, I could not pencil out on paper how I could make a living (milk prices are no better). That is why I hobby farm instead (and luckily have a good paying job...at least until the next round of layoffs at IBM...whose former CEO is also way overpaid).

I'm just glad that Deere is able to get parts for my equipment...most of which is older than I am. I think for the most part their parts are reasonable. I also know that it depends upon the dealership when it comes to price of parts.

Guess I've said enough and hope I didn't ruffle too many feathers. This has been a good source for solutions to problems I and many others have encountered. I just hate to see people even suggest not buying from Deere due to cost...because in the end we will all lose.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Zack

09-30-2002 14:53:34




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Rodney A. Johnson, 09-30-2002 07:38:53  
"Do you really believe that it costs nothing to keep an old forging and assembly line process going that is over 50 years old?" Do you really think old mother Deere is still casting and forging those parts? If so I have some land in Florida to sell you. Those parts that Deere sells now are left over from years ago or are being produced by other suppliers. Deere makes very few replacement parts for 2 cylinder era equipment. I do agree that most parts should be bought from Deere but $37.00 for a $1.50 bolt or 19.50 for a $2.00 gasket that isn't even original due to coming in 6 pieces that has to be glued together then leaks when installed isn't in my business plans. As long as people like you are willing to pay ridiculous prices for less than quality parts Deere will keep trying to squeeze more out of people..

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Rodney A. Johnson

10-01-2002 06:50:20




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Zack, 09-30-2002 14:53:34  
Maybe today they only sell what is currently left over stock, but about 15 years ago I was told by a John Deere dealership that they made xxx number of flywheels for a B every so often. When the stock got low enough they would schedule a switch over of one of their manufacturing lines to produce some more. This meant many weeks of time spent just produce another 300 (just a guess for arguements sake). You cannot tell me that this is as cheap to produce as it was 60 years ago when they were first putting out the B. In fact it had to cost quite a chunk to do it just 45 years ago. Meanwhile the castings still had to be stored somewhere so they could repro the flywheels. I do know Deere has sold some of their castings. I also know of one company (don't remember the name) that was not able to buy Deere's castings (don't know reason...perhaps Deere wanted too much for them) for the hydraulic pumps for the xx10 and xx20 series tractors. They made their own castings and are making the pumps themselves. Far as I know you can still buy the original pumps from Deere for 1400USD.

As to the outrages cost of that bolt, it wasn't Deere that did that...it was your local dealership...the dealership decides what the markup on parts are.

And, if that was a very specialized bolt...try going to a machine shop and get one made with the same tensile strength and quality. I had a part made for a sickle mower once that had left hand threads. I bought a "blank" myself...all they had to do was cut the threads. Cost me 45USD...and it still wobbles a bit...now if I could have gotten the original part...

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Zack

10-01-2002 16:48:46




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Rodney A. Johnson, 10-01-2002 06:50:20  
Rodney I am not doubting that a Deere dealer told you Deere shut a foundry line down to make B flywheels but I do doubt it is true. I am a common sense type of old farmer and doubt Deere has sold 300 new B flywheels in the last 20 years let alone made any more. Of all the flywheels why the B they don't break they don't wear out and who would stock one. I would imagine Deere would have been selling those flywheels for about $450.00 to $500.00 15 years ago and a good used one would have gone for $25.00 to 40.00 so where is the wisdom of shutting down a producing foundry line to make more hard to store impossible to sell low demand flywheels. It makes a good story though. As for the price of bolts and gaskets they are priced according to Deere guidelines not dealer made up prices. I get a farmers discount a quantity purchase discount and once in a while a good gesture discount and the prices on some parts are still way above the normal and common sense price for what I am buying. I have a good dealer and the parts manager will try to locate a different supplier if the part seems to be outrageously priced for what it is or does. I do buy many parts from Deere most months over $500.00 but to pay more for a part than common sense tells me it is worth is foolish and not business wise.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Rodney A. Johnson

10-02-2002 11:57:23




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Zack, 10-01-2002 16:48:46  
You seem to be getting quite defensive and a bit nasty. It was never my intent to imply that Deere makes the best parts or best equipment in the world nor that you should just buy Deere and definitely would not like to see everyone to stop buying Deere. I'm glad that you do when it fits your budget and practical sense. I was merely trying to provide an alternative view to the discussion that sheds some light on the reasons why part costs can go up...in particular older parts.

As to the B flywheel that is my fault for not explaining that it was an example (perhaps a bad one at that)...I don't recall what part it actually was...maybe the 730 diesel flywheels...the whole point was Deere did produce parts that were in demand that were a much higher cost to produce than when they were first produced (other than the normal rate of inflation and part cost increases) many years after they had to legally (15 year law). To break even, the company would need to charge higher parts than what is normal.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Zack

10-03-2002 18:13:09




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Rodney A. Johnson, 10-02-2002 11:57:23  
So you made up the "shut the foundry down to make B flywheels" I sort of thought so. Now you're guessing that it was 730 flywheels. Maybe it was D front axles or GP wheel hubs. I seriously doubt any major company would shut down a producing foundry line to make obsolete replacement parts including Deere. Even if it were true you are talking about large cast parts. I would expect to pay more for a large cast part and in some cases would welcome the option to even buy an obsolete flywheel. That is a completely different horse than $10.00 to $20.00 for a piece of felt or $6.00 to $10.00 for a paper gasket or even $2.50 a piece for a thin paper shim "11 required". instead of 1 or 2 thick ones for the same $2.50. Let me ask you a question. Would you buy a loaf of bread from Deere if it cost $18.00 or $1.50 a slice "20 required". If not why not after all it is John Deere bread.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Rodney A. Johnson

10-04-2002 08:39:35




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Zack, 10-03-2002 18:13:09  
Zack, You continue to completely miss the point. I am only repeating from a very foggy memory a statement by a John Deere dealer that John Deere at one time supposedly did shut down and switch over to manufacture older parts. If you want to or not want to believe that a company did this really doesn't matter to me. My point was if JD did indeed do this, that it is a reason why a part might be higher priced than what one would think is reasonable. I also did not say that it applied to the particular part you had to buy...just that it might be why your part was higher. And foundary work isn't the only thing that costs money to do...machining parts isn't cheap either...another point I made earlier that you didn't get.

As to what I would purchase what difference does that really make? Is it just for your satisfaction that you can feel justified in calling me stupid? For your age, I'm starting to question your wisdom...I thought it was us young guys who refused to look at all angles and be cautious about making rash statements and or decisions. Sure you probably can take your 2 cylinders apart and put them back together in your sleep. And you can probably do a great job of finding parts for reasonable prices. Good for you. And yes others should consider doing the same. I never said they shouldn't. Again I repeat for the third time (hopefully in words you'll understand this time)...I just don't want everyone to completely abandon going to JD just because they think the part might be more expensive...at least check it out. Which is exactly what others were saying. And so were you.

As to my own preferences in buying parts:

I have a '52 A, a '62 3010D, and a '64 4020D. I've done minor repairs myself so far using JD orginal parts...all of which seemed reasonable to me (but then that is obviously subjective). The only major repair I had done was an overhaul on the 3010 engine. Yes I "stupidly" bought all JD parts for that overhaul (labor was done by cousin for free). I could have bought parts that supposedly would be as good for a lot less. The problem is if I had to get another part, it was a lot easier to just stop at the local dealer rather than shop around and wait for a part to be delivered. The overhaul was on a tight schedule and I had the luxury to be able to spend what was necessary. If I had to do it again and didn't need the tractor right away, yes I would probably have considered buying nonJD parts...especially if the JD parts wouldn't fit my budget and the nonJD part was of equal or better quality.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Zack

10-04-2002 15:25:51




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Rodney A. Johnson, 10-04-2002 08:39:35  
Rodney, I told you before and I'll tell you again I don't doubt what the dealer told you I doubt it was true. Most dealers will tell you anything to sound like they know what they are talking about most don't. They do it day in and day out and get away with it because most people don't know the difference or don't want to make a fuss and call them on it. If you believe Deere shut a producing foundry line down to make old replacement parts that's your business. Just don't expect people with common sense to believe it.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Frank M.

10-03-2002 18:29:07




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Zack, 10-03-2002 18:13:09  
I make it a practice to not eat green bread.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
G-MAN

09-30-2002 17:34:20




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Zack, 09-30-2002 14:53:34  
So enlighten us on where we can get better quality parts at cheaper prices. I'm asssuming the availability is also as good or better than John Deere and that the parts will in most cases be there the next day or at most within two days without prohibitive freight prices. I've seen some parts houses charging 5 or 6 dollars freight on gaskets and other small parts than can be mailed in an envelope. Sure sounds like a good deal to me. BTW, the parts you're buying elsewhere are probably produced at the same facility Deere gets them from. The difference is that they're screwing you on freight, rather than charging a reasonable amount. I would also like you to provide me with a part number for the $37.00 bolt and the six-piece gasket. Caterpillar has used "puzzle" gaskets for years with no problems, what's wrong with Deere doing the same thing? I guess it's all about proper installation procedures.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Zack

09-30-2002 18:47:32




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to G-MAN, 09-30-2002 17:34:20  
I've seen Deere charge over $5.00 to UPS a single gasket. Talk about your basic ripoff. There is no one place that I know of where you can get all the required replacement parts for 2 cylinder Deeres. Most can be found if you shop around. Almost anything that is popular is being reproduced and probably by the same companies that supply Deere. Most good auto parts stores in an agricultural areas carry a good supply of popular replacement parts for the 2 cylinder Deeres or can get them in about a day with no shipping cost. Don't have any part numbers handy that was a while ago. Multi piece gaskets will work if designed properly but when there are small pieces with the joints below the oil level they are destined for failure and leaks. I have been installing gaskets for longer than you have been around and I would imagine have worked on more 2 cylinders than you have so maybe you should enlighten me on how to install a multi piece gasket so it doesn't leak at some future time when it is inconvenient to stop field work and repair it. I guess when I pay high dollar for a Deere gasket I expect it to be as good the original and not inferior to an aftermarket. Deere is just like other big companies they expect to make a huge profit on peoples needs. Bottom line is they aren't supplying those old parts to help people they see big profits in those old parts or they wouldn't even carry them. If you want to pay big money for Deere parts be my guest I work hard for my money and choose to spend it wisely. I do buy many parts from Deere but draw the line when the cost far exceeds the common sense worth of a part especially with some of the junk Deere is selling as genuine replacement now. At least 10 years ago when you bought Deere it was costly but good now it is costly but junk.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
G-MAN

10-01-2002 05:41:30




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Zack, 09-30-2002 18:47:32  
I have no doubt that you have been installing gaskets longer than anyone, however, I do it for a living. I worked for Caterpillar on heavy equipment for a few years. They use a puzzle type gasket on many of their oil pans - pretty much in constant contact with oil. I always had good luck using a little spot of silicone at the joints to fill the gaps and copper-coating the gasket on one side to keep it firmly in place. But then again, I probably only installed two or three dozen pan gaskets that way, so it was probably just luck that none of them leaked. Also, it's not "Deere" that's charging you five bucks to UPS a gasket - it's your dealer. I can't believe how many people out there labor under the assumption that Deere controls the dealership and their policies. Let me lay it out for you - THEY DON'T. That dealership is an independent business. Deere owns the sign out front, someone else owns the building and pays the salaries of the employees. If you have a problem with your dealership, take it up with them - don't complain about JD as a whole. I would also end by saying that I personally install well over $100,000 worth of Deere parts every year, so I might be a little more qualified than you are to discuss the quality of their parts, regardless of how many two-cylinders you've worked on. Especially when you can't or won't supply hard facts to back up your argument. 99% of what I do is on working farm tractors that must get the field work done, not hobby tractors for parades and pulls, and having worked for other color dealerships, I can tell you that Deere's parts system is better than anyone else's by far - except for Caterpillar. Caterpillar parts are expensive, too. I guess that's the price you pay for the quality and service you get.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Zack

10-01-2002 17:30:26




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to G-MAN, 10-01-2002 05:41:30  
Well sonny the gaskets you installed weren't below oil level and after you sent them on their way you have no idea if they ever leaked. After all it left the shop without a leak.
I guess I can't see how my dealer charged me extra for UPS charges on a part that was sent direct UPS from Deere. Maybe they have access to the UPS computer and embezzled some of the money.
If you are trying to impress me by saying you sell over a $100,000 worth of parts you didn't. Way back in the mid 70s when I was working heavy truck I sold 4 times that amount of parts and was only working part time during crop season. You must be the prep man or only do light repairs.
Of that $100,000 parts how much of that was 2 cylinder? How many 2 cylinders have you done in your dealer? I would guess 2 or maybe 3 total with maybe a tune-up thrown in once in a while. That makes you a real knowledgeable person to comment on the quality of Deeres 2 cylinder parts. I own 33 2 cylinders and still farm with 11 so I highly doubt you contact as many 2 cylinder parts as I do. In fact I would bet I still farm with more 2 cylinders than you have worked on in your young life.
In any case I do buy a lot of parts from Deere and am lucky that I have a good conscientious dealer that watches out for their customers. I have a parts manager that will hand deliver parts if he is coming my way. I get a good farm discount. The parts manager will shake his head at a high priced part for what it is and call to verify the price before ordering then if he still feels the price is too high he will try to locate a used or different supplier to furnish the part. In more than a few cases when I have ordered a seal he will say not to go with Deere because he has sold one before and knows their seal is a cheap single lip then will call around to locate a double lipped that is probably cheaper anyhow. You keep staying geeked up on all original Deere parts just don't try to intimidate others into buying them just because they come from Deere. They are not always better in fact in a lot of cases they aren't as good and in a lot of cases they are more expensive than a comparable part. I am not saying not to buy from Deere I am saying to not pay ridiculous prices for a part that is obviously not worth the money charged at any business including Deere.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
G-MAN

10-02-2002 05:46:30




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Zack, 10-01-2002 17:30:26  
First of all, don't call me sonny - you aren't my dad, thank God. Second, if you'll recall, you didn't mention two cylinder parts specifically in your post - you only mentioned a $37 bolt and a $19.50 gasket, with no part numbers to back up your statement. Third, it sounds as if you were quite the parts replacer back in your day, I guess I try to diagnose the problems and only install the right part, rather than throwing parts at the machine until something fixes it. I seriously doubt that you were installing several hundred thousand dollars of truck parts a year back in the seventies, as that would be several million dollars in today's money. Were you doing a complete engine overhaul everyday? That's what it would take to install that many dollars worth of parts - but you only mention selling them, not installing them. Next, the gaskets I installed are in constant contact with oil. If you're at all familiar with any Caterpillar engines, you know that they use a steel plate on the bottom of some of the blocks between the block and pan. There is always oil on top of that plate, as it is running off the bottom end. There is even an oil pickup for scavenging on that plate in some engines, for engine operation on unlevel surfaces. And yes, I would have known about any leaks, because the customer would have brought the unit back in were they leaking. In your vast knowledge, I'm also sure you're aware that many diesel engines with deep skirt blocks have oil levels that are higher than the top of the pan. I could also care less how many two-cylinders you own or farm list. You probably have worked on many times the number of two-cylinders I have. Once again, that makes no difference - I am talking about Deere parts in general, you are talking about two-cylinder parts in particular. I believe I mentioned in my last post that I work on working farm tractors. Around here that is row-crop tractors over 150 hp. We mostly work on 8000 tractors, 4555s, 4960s, 4840s and the like. What two-cylinders there still are on the farms are used for auger work, shredding or not at all. 4430s, 4440s and 4640s are commonly used as yard tractors around here. We do work on two-cylinders from time to time, and I another guy do all of them. I don't claim to be a two-cylinder expertm, the way that you do. I just try to learn something every time I work on one. As for me being the prep man or only doing light work, more b.s. Feel free to stop in any day and try to keep up with me, especially now during harvest. 5 to 6 service calls a day are the norm, in addition to keeping up with shop work. I doubt you could handle it. I don't mean to be insulting, but I do get tired of older individuals assuming that anyone younger (I'm 28 by the way) doesn't know anything. I've dealt with it the whole time I've been turning wrenches. I actually find it quite funny when some older guy comes in with a question and walks right past me to ask someone older, who directs the guy to come talk to me. I will make you a deal. You stop by and give me some lessons in working on two cylinders, and I'll teach you some things about electronic engine controls, powershift diagnosis, electronic hitches and anything else you want to know about.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Zack

10-03-2002 19:00:16




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to G-MAN, 10-02-2002 05:46:30  
As well as being arrogant you can't read. What part of "There is no one place that I know of where you can get all the required replacement parts for 2 cylinder Deeres" can't you understand? In no way was I referring to current Deere parts. Deere probably still uses production parts for current Ag products not the junk aftermarket or small job shop parts they pawn off as correct 2 cylinder repair parts. If you actually used any 2 cylinder parts you wouldn't even be spouting off about their good quality. Some are still original NOS and those are pretty good but there is a lot of later junk mixed in and you never know what you will get. You are right about me throwing parts at a repair project. I did heavy engines, Allison transmissions and Roadranger manuals and any part that measured out of spec was replaced no if's an's or but's about it. If they wanted me to overhaul it I replaced anything that was marginal. If they wanted half a-s-s repairs they would have to talk to the young pups working there because I wouldn't do it.
Thanks for the offer on the modern electronic marvels but I am not interested I don't even own a tractor with a cab on it. I must be getting old I did use canvass curtains last winter.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
G-MAN

10-04-2002 08:56:49




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Zack, 10-03-2002 19:00:16  
Get over yourself Zack, if anyone is being arrogant, it's you. All I did in the first place was post my opinion, and you jumped all over it. You do your thing and I'll do mine. Judging by your disagreement with Rodney, you have a problem playing well with others, so go somewhere else. I'm still waiting to hear how you installed several thousand dollars worth of parts per day rebuilding Eaton transmissions. If you were measuring every part, I find it hard to believe that you could complete an entire tranmission in a week, let alone a day. And by the way, I've worked in truck shops and went to tech school for over-the-road trucks and construction equipment, so I've been into Eatons and Allisons - don't think you're going to b.s. me about how exacting you have to be to properly rebuild one.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Zack

10-04-2002 16:47:51




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to G-MAN, 10-04-2002 08:56:49  
I don't have to BS you about being exact on transmission overhauls. It sounds like you are one of those young pups that doesn't and probably couldn't measure the parts anyway. Obviously you haven't ever worked heavy truck or if you did you were the parts fetcher or you would know enough to do it right the first time so it doesn't come back. You know I got a few e-mails from other readers saying you are a jerk and now I see why.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Jon from Indiana

09-30-2002 02:30:35




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
Its like good quality oats, they come at a fair price. But if you can be satisfied with those that have already been through the horse or mule, they come much cheaper.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Jon from Indiana

09-30-2002 02:03:44




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
Its like good quality oats, they come at a fair price. But if you can be satisfied with those that have already been through the horse or mule, they come much cheaper.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
MIKE HANLEY

09-29-2002 15:47:09




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
A couple of thoughts. I have a buddy who was a J.D. dealer, quit got a Masters degree in AG ENG and went teaching. He told me one time most parts are 50% mark up from the dealer to the farmer and most dealers that was the only thing making any money. The shop with unpaid warranty work included in the bottom line, the shop was break even. My Dad was in charge of dealer accounts for Allis Chalmers in it's hay day. I remember him saying the dealer had so much free time on a piece of equipment, and then after that he had to pay interest to AC, and if it did not sell after so much more time, the dealer had to buy th piece. If the dealer was in to hock to AC, AC told the dealer he would get so many tractors, so many balers, ETC and he was to sell them. Indepentant dealers that were well to do and AC only owned the signs on the building, it was differant. They told AC how much stuff to ship. My buddy the ex dealer pushed the pencil on the cost of a new combine as to the number of days that it can work (weather minor break downs ETC), as to the amount of acres it can cover in a day Bottom line ..., just the owner ship costs (not operating costs included.) has maxed out. Next price rise will not cover costs with out increasing capasity.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Jim in michigan

09-28-2002 19:59:36




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
The price of parts is the only thing keeping me from going completely green...I like John Deere, but they sure are proud of their parts,,,,Jim



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Doc

09-28-2002 07:51:55




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
This all really comes down to perception of value. If you have a dealer that really works with you and helps you out when you need help, then my loyalty goes to that individual and his business. If you are treated right and feel more respected by the salvage yard, then that's who I would go with. Personally, I wish I still had a JD dealer in our area, but agriculture is long gone from my neck of the woods (pine forests of northern Minnesota).
Doc

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Clooney

09-28-2002 05:52:05




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
Jason, you should always ask the price before ordering anything from Deere, some things are quite reasonable & others are extremely high for the part received.
~In some cases you are stuck with the Deere high price if new is the only way you should go, but on other parts where a used will work just as good or in your case probably even better, [by buying used you probably got a closer match to the other 2 worn dogs] a call to a reputable used parts supplier will be your best bet.
~Deere's prices are hard to figure, in some cases they still have plenty of NOS & in others they are having a small machine shops or outside suppliers furnish the part [probably the case with Franks case studs]. Some of their replacement parts are even coming from China or overseas.
~Bearings are also hard to figure, in some cases Deere's bearings are the cheapest around & in others they are the highest. ~I usually just price & check availability on everything before ordering, then order what seems reasonable & shop around for those parts that seem way out of line for the part in question. ~In a few cases I have been happier with "good used" as they are original & not the reproduced that Deere handles.
~All in all most Deere parts are fair, but there are more than a few outliers that are either mis-priced or Deere got ripped off on their price so passes it on to the customer..... ..

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
leon

09-28-2002 05:21:16




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
I've heard some rumblings from folks I know inside the Deere organization that in an effort to keep Wall Street happier, Deere may quit carying a lot of the old two-cylinder parts to
improve their return on assets. I know it sure isn't what Jason wants to hear, but maybe if we want to continue to get parts for our old collectors from Deere, we should patronize our local dealers even more and let them know that what seems like high prices is OK. The issue is just finding them at all.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Terry H

09-27-2002 19:17:01




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
jason r:
I sympathize with you, but I also tend to agree with the others who responded to your post. I've been hanging out here for a couple of years, learning what I can, and a lot of the regulars are collectors who view these wonderful pieces of machinery the same way the Harley-Davidson types see their motorcycles. Money is no object when it comes to keeping these machines going, and if a $1.50 part lists for $60, that's O.K., as long as it comes from Mother Deere, and you'd better like it and never say anything bad about her.

On the other hand, if you're like me, and a lot of others here, and use this old iron on a daily basis out of necessity, it seems outrageous that a little bitty part that can put you out of business, can be so expensive. At the same time, it's amazing that Deere still has so many parts for these machines available, and if your local parts man is on the ball, can have them in a day or two at the most.

My $1.98 worth.

Terry H

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Will P

09-27-2002 18:32:49




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
Well, I would have put down $55 for a new one. Seeing that the junk yard ones are probably wore pretty good. I have been suprised at what Deere still has. At least we can still get new. Try that at Case, IH and all the others.

Will P



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
AC190

09-28-2002 15:25:24




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Will P, 09-27-2002 18:32:49  
Was reading post and had to defend my other brand (Allis). I got the needed parts for my 1948 WD that you wouldn't expect such as the Hyd. & throttle quadrant, rollers & ramps for the hand cluch, rebuilt hyd pump, transmission input shaft and every gasket, seal, and bearing needed to do the job. High priced but available.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Will P

09-28-2002 17:55:05




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to AC190, 09-28-2002 15:25:24  
K, try getting parts for there implements. I got parts for my cornbinder from Deere.

Will P



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
AC190

09-29-2002 18:45:07




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Will P, 09-28-2002 17:55:05  
What kind of parts? Unless a bearing or seal or something common I would dought they were no more than old stock that the dealer or JD had lying around or your good dealer went the extra mile and checked with an obsolete parts house. If JD is still actually producing a part for a 1928 cornbinder of which you may be the only buyer then more power to them.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Steven@nd

09-28-2002 05:59:31




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Will P, 09-27-2002 18:32:49  
Just have to put in my 2 cents here on the comment for IH parts. Many new parts are still available and there are quite a few guys that have NOS parts available also. For the letter series Farmalls it is no problem to find new parts at a local CaseIH dealer.

Steven



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Will P

09-28-2002 06:59:37




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Steven@nd, 09-28-2002 05:59:31  
Yes. I can agree with you that there is still parts availible. But I got parts for my 1924 ground drive cornbinder from Deere. Wonder if IH has any parts for there cornbinders?

Will P



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Frank M.

09-27-2002 18:32:44




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
I just recently bought new head studs for my H. 26 bucks apiece. Even the parts man was suprised they were that high. I didn't complain about the price though, because as G-Man said, it's amazing they are still stocking a part that would surely be a slow moving item.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
twopop

09-27-2002 18:15:28




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
well lets see,you have a tractor that is 67 years old,and most likely the clutch dogs are that age also,and a new one cost 55.00 dollars.looks like about 82 cents a year.have you seen a chevy part that beats that



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Steve - IN

09-27-2002 17:25:03




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
Jason,

It's fairly amazing that the JD dealer has parts at all. See how loud they laugh if you walk in to a Ford or Chevy dealer looking for parts for a '46 model.

I've got three JD's and a Farmall. Guess which one I worry about finding parts for at any price?
At the time my popper and my Farmall were built, IH was selling a lot more tractors than JD. Tables have turned now. If you condense your argument into buying new parts versus buying junkyard parts at the same price, I think most people would be surprised JD was selling the new parts so cheaply.

That might be the rest of the story.

Paul Harvey

...no... Steve

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
G-MAN

09-27-2002 13:13:33




Report to Moderator
 Re: John Deere Parts in reply to jason r, 09-27-2002 11:32:49  
As a Deere technician and an old Deere enthusiast, I will take exception with your post. Consider for a minute how much call there is for the part you needed. How many do you suppose Deere sells in a year's time? The number is probably pretty low, yet Deere keeps the part in production and stock, in case the need does arise. Obviously a low production number part like that is going to cost more than you think it should, but imagine liking a brand of old tractor that doesn't have the parts support that Deere offers. If you think Deere is higher on all parts, you're mistaken. There were recently some posts concerning gasket kits for "B"s, if I remember correctly. The Deere kit listed for around $50, and the aftermarket kit was nearly double that price. I have purchased parts from salvage yards when they weren't available from Deere, so I won't fault you for that, but if everyone quits buying from Deere, they will stop supporting the products, and you'll end up buying a lot more used parts. The ability to purchase new parts is what keeps salvage yards honest. If that part wasn't available new from Deere, what do you think the salvage yard guy would have charged you? Prices go up dramatically when they have you over a barrel.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Iowa Farmer

09-28-2002 06:02:03




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to G-MAN, 09-27-2002 13:13:33  
Here's my opinion and I'm not rying to start anything here either. We run all Deere's on our Farm. Yes OEM Deere parts due get pricy, but at least we can still get them, but I have seen some parts get to out of control that they are being reproduced allready. Deere is not the Deere is was 5 years ago. I hope Deere doens't ever go under, but more and more these days, out goes experiance and in goes the college educated idiots. I was in the market for an exhaust manifold for 4455 $164 this spring, now $250, guess Deere needed to show the stockholder that they are being profitable. The bad thing is, what's there to do about it? We know Deere is making less and less tractors and combines each year, to the profits have to come from somewhere.
My $.02
Brad

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
gy3020

09-28-2002 06:55:27




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Iowa Farmer, 09-28-2002 06:02:03  
My thoughts on this matter of getting the profits would be hey if you want to sell more tractors and combines, sell them affordably. New tractor and combine prices are outragous. Does it really take all the bells and whistles to cut wheat or plow a field? This business of GPS systems on tractors, what a joke, if you have to depend on a satellite to plow for you I don't think you have any business being in the business. I run Deeres as well, a 3020,4020, 530 round baler,346 square baler, 1380 hydroswing mo co. Been buying a few parts myself over the past few weeks. Have felt very violated at a few of them. All in all I guess what I'm trying to say is I think people are just getting to live too high on the hog, whats going to happen if we, and I hope we don't, but it we slip into another depression. Lots of people are going to be squealling like a stuck hog.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
G-MAN

09-28-2002 08:55:04




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to gy3020, 09-28-2002 06:55:27  
Nothing against you personally, gy3020, but I'll say what I've said time and time again. People think their DVD players, computers, cell phones, microwaves, power windows and locks, cruise control and heaven knows what else are all necessities, which couldn't be farther from the truth. What they are are luxuries, but people coudn't imagine life without all this new technology. However, put some of the same new technology in a tractor or combine, and it's just "electronic garbage". I know how much new tractors cost and it is high, but how much has the price of a new pickup gone up in the last 20 years? Or a new home? Farm equipment does nothing more than keep up with the inflation rate. I'm not a huge fan of the new electronics, but as someone that has to work around it daily, I can see that it does have it's advantages. It DOES increase efficiency and productivity. If you want to farm with older equipment, that's entirely up to you, but the farm equipment market place is customer driven, and as long as these items are sought after by the customer, they will be produced. For Deere to not offer these options while all the other manufacturers do would be suicide, because the fact is that this is the direction farming is going. Fewer and fewer farmers producing more and more. It may not be the way it was 50 years ago, but it's what continues to provide the U.S. and much of the rest of the world with the cheapest and safest food supply there is. I imagine that power steering, synchromesh transmissions and closed-center hydraulics were considered unnecessary at one time also. Do you want to take them off your 20 series tractors?

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
gy3020

09-28-2002 10:22:01




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to G-MAN, 09-28-2002 08:55:04  
I do understand what your saying and no offense is meant by any statement here, we are all just making our views and opinions known, sure progress is good, to a certain extent. I think that all would agree that if equipment prices and parts prices weren't so out of sight that there would still be more people farming and feeding this great land and most of the world. It is the same way with trucks and everything else and maybe this topic is just like farting in the wind to even discuss. I guess my main point is that looks like the equipment manufacturers and dealers are making the killing while us poor people that are lining there pockets with gold are suffering. I personally just don't see the need for all of the stuff they are putting on the newer machines, now maybe if I can get more going and gaining more ground after the divorce and all and could get into something new and actually got to use it I might see the good in it but as long as all I can see is the dealers and manufacturors getting rich its hard to see the fairness in it all.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Steve - IN

09-28-2002 12:09:44




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to gy3020, 09-28-2002 10:22:01  
gy3020,

Farting in the wind may be a very apt term. Deere is projecting a break even, no profit quarter now, and farm equipment sales were terrible in August. They don't seem to be getting rich or seeing a rosy picture right now either. There will be more pressure to cut unprofitable lines. Slow turning inventory for 50 year old tractor parts has to be one of them, so maybe they'll see that as farting in the wind as well. The cost of every part of running a business has jumped a lot. Governments and lawyers have had a fine hand in that. So GM, Ford, JD, and other makers don't make any greater per centage profit to sales than they did 50 years ago, and in many cases, less.

I think 32 counties in my state were declared Ag disaster areas last month. Yet guys who planted drought resistant strains and sprayed in-ground insecticides were making a killing with higher yields at higher grain prices. Those two things, like GPS, weren't around 20 - 40 years ago. In the grand scheme of things, they're a thin margin of difference. But farming is a thin margin business which seems to reward the guys who use every available trick to hedge their bets, and control all the variables.

You mention the rest of the world, that's what bothers me. That "world poverty/hunger" thing that went on in South Africa a month ago is a far greater threat to us than a US maker or dealer making some money. Those 3rd world hypocrites down there were feasting on lobster while blaming us for their problems. They sit on land that generally can be just as productive as ours, yet claim that our success is wrong and we should just fork over money to them. Meantime, just north of there, in what was the richest, most productive country in Africa - Rhodesia/Zimbabwe - 20 to 30 years ago is in chaos and starving because of the kind of people's dictatorships they represent. Don't hear them complaining about that. So I don't begrudge an American who's worked hard to enjoy some success. It's those people who don't work hard or smart and think we've somehow taken their share of what they think is a finite pie because of it -- and we should just hand over the fruits of our labor -- those are the people that bother me.

I think we'd have a lot more to complain about, fewer ways to complain, and far less hope of doing something about our complaints if we weren't living in the USA.

Steve

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
gy3020

09-28-2002 12:39:24




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Steve - IN, 09-28-2002 12:09:44  
Thanks Steve for that very informative reply. Very thought and well constructed. I appreciate the time you took to do that. However my thoughts on the matter of parts prices and those of us trying to make a living running equipment seems to have been lost somewhere. Why should a 5' hydraulic hose cost almost a hundred bucks, why should a hand full of orings to rebuild a hydraulic cylinder costs $53.00. You speak of no profit quarter and terrible equipment sales, primary cause I would say is the dang stuff is just to darn expensive! Maybe to those of you who well off and living the life of Reilly its ok but to us who are not that well off its hurting us. If equipment and parts were more reasonable isn't it fair too say that more would be sold, hence more profits. Thats the point I'm trying to make here and if anyone feels different, thats their business. Parts and equipment, trucks and just about everything else is way out of control.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Steve - IN

09-29-2002 12:21:54




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to gy3020, 09-28-2002 12:39:24  
gy3020,

Life of Riley, I wish! You're right, parts prices for anything that rolls are generally crazy. Farm produce prices haven't moved up in 20 years or so. Like a rock and a hard place.

Yet I still have a hard time blaming the guys selling and making parts and equipment. They haven't increased their profit to sales margins - because their costs have also increased dramatically. I know the local JD dealer has seen property taxes triple over the last ten years. I've seen the same increase. Their insurance package, including health, goes up 10 to 15 per cent a year. I'd bet they have other similar cost increases I don't know about; but I do know I'd still count them among the people who are doing something useful in the world.

On the other hand, I don't need to be governed 3 times more than I did 10 years ago - but I'm paying for it at that rate. All I've seen them do with that new money is build schools that can barely teach kids to read. And instead of 1 cop car at the donut / coffee shop, you see them parked there in groups of 3's and 4's now. Insurance has always irked me -- especially the state mandated kinds. Those are some of the people who get my blood up, as they seem to produce very little, yet still increase their prices year after year.

Steve

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
AC190

09-29-2002 18:59:14




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Steve - IN, 09-29-2002 12:21:54  
I personally wouldn,t blame the dealer so much as the head chiefs at Deere (and the others). I read where 25 years ago the average CEO made 40 times more dollars than the average floor worker. Now it is around 300 times more. Sure JD doesn't show much of a profit but then that's not what matters to CEOs and their cronies. It's what's in their pocket that counts. I'm sure the CEOs don't want the company to go under but it's not priority one in their thoughts when when they are sooooo fat.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
tubba_JD420C_ny

09-29-2002 19:54:17




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to AC190, 09-29-2002 18:59:14  
I agree with you there, AC. It is really obscene when you see all those CEO's that get 500 times the pay of a worker for running the company into the ground while at the saem time the worker is busting his hump trying to keep it afloat. Makes me boil.
my 2 cents



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Gary

09-29-2002 12:42:22




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Steve - IN, 09-29-2002 12:21:54  
Hey Steve,
I agree with you, dealers and such have to increase prices to meet demands. Looks like we should be able to do the same though doesn't it.
I have to go back down in the morning and pick up load control seals and some things for my 4020 and hydroswing so I'll be donating a little more to the cause. I run a small custom hay baling business here in north central TX and some of the parts hav really gotten into my back pocket this year. Thanks for the reply and have a super week.
Gary

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Mike

09-27-2002 19:17:52




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to G-MAN, 09-27-2002 13:13:33  
I wonder why a lot of stuff for a 4020 is no
longer available,sheet metal,3pt down link arms,
etc.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
G-MAN

09-28-2002 05:37:50




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to Mike, 09-27-2002 19:17:52  
Probably for the same reasons I mentioned - it costs too much to produce for the limited demand. Those are the kind of items that 99% of guys are going to look at a salvage yard first to find, never even considering that Deere might still have them. It's simply not possible for ANY company to continue to produce every part for every product they ever made.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
RLA

09-27-2002 18:29:08




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to G-MAN, 09-27-2002 13:13:33  
I've been a Ford Parts manager for 28 years? Worked all at the same store. In 1975 a gas gauge for the rear tank of a pickup use to list 22.79 I remember thsi well! Same gause has been replaced about 5 time to a newer number & Now its list for over 90.00. Gauge only no pumps hanging on them back then. Most auto parts are scapped by the manufacturer after 20 years & not reproduced, only to outside supplers. Hats off to Deere, for still having the part available. Yes it cost big bucks!!! But if your gonna play, you gotta PAY.

RLA

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
RLA

09-27-2002 18:28:00




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: John Deere Parts in reply to G-MAN, 09-27-2002 13:13:33  
I've been a Ford Parts manager for 28 years? Worked all at the same store. In 1975 a gas gauge for the rear tank of a pickup use to list 22.79 I remember thsi well! Same gause has been replaced about 5 time to a newer number & Now its list for over 90.00. Gauge only no pumps hanging on them back then. Most auto parts are scapped by the manufacturer after 20 years & not reproduced, only to outside supplers. Hats off to Deere, for still having the part available. Yes it cost big bucks!!! But if your gonna play, you gotta PAY.

RLA

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
[Options]  [Printer Friendly]  [Posting Help]  [Return to Forum]   [Log in to Reply]

Hop to:


TRACTOR PARTS TRACTOR MANUALS
We sell tractor parts!  We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today. [ About Us ]

Home  |  Forums


Copyright © 1997-2023 Yesterday's Tractor Co.

All Rights Reserved. Reproduction of any part of this website, including design and content, without written permission is strictly prohibited. Trade Marks and Trade Names contained and used in this Website are those of others, and are used in this Website in a descriptive sense to refer to the products of others. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy

TRADEMARK DISCLAIMER: Tradenames and Trademarks referred to within Yesterday's Tractor Co. products and within the Yesterday's Tractor Co. websites are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Yesterday's Tractor Co., our products, or our website nor are we sponsored by them. John Deere and its logos are the registered trademarks of the John Deere Corporation. Agco, Agco Allis, White, Massey Ferguson and their logos are the registered trademarks of AGCO Corporation. Case, Case-IH, Farmall, International Harvester, New Holland and their logos are registered trademarks of CNH Global N.V.

Yesterday's Tractors - Antique Tractor Headquarters

Website Accessibility Policy