|
>>>This is one time where you have it wrong, dead wring! I have labored long and hard to arrive at the conclusions expressed here, in the JD-H Restoration Guide's 2nd Edition, and on my website. Many folks have reviewed my analysis and to the man are in general agreement. Never been dead "wring" (sic) before. "...and to the man are in general agreement". So what did those not in general agreement have to say? Geez. I just asked where you got those numbers, and I'm still asking. Does not sound like a 100% of the "man" agreed, and I was just wondering if you found a long-lost FSB that said one inch travel, Pat. :) I wasn't finding fault in your book, but up to one inch is too much. It just is. It just freskin' is. >>>Yes, I meant the "up to one inch of free play" at the fan blade tip. At first, I went through the same step-by-step analysis as you and arrived at pretty much the same conclusion that for a new gear set, there would be virtually no travel at the fan blade tip. There would be at least 6x the lash adjustment. .007" high limit lash would be .042" tip play, and if it got out of whack due to wear, and if you checked it without freezing the governor shaft, it could be probably 1/4" or maybe 3/8" before you might hear it. >>>And this issue caused much consternation in John Deere repair shops as well. Field Service Bulletin 113-S (9-15-1940) along with others brings the gear backlash specification of from 0.004" to 0.007" into focus. And yes, they did in fact mention to hold the governor shaft rigid while moving the fan. In accord with FSB 113-S, this spec of from 0.004" to 0.007" is translated to fan movement from 1/4" to 3/8" on all models of John Deere tractors. So I DID remember right? 1/4" to 3/8".....Still not one inch, now, is it? >>>Now, you have to go back and re-read the nature of this man's complaint. He was having trouble reinstalling the governor shaft, on the tractor, without having even considered the fan shaft pinion gear. That wasn't his complaint at all. You made it his complaint. He asked if he could get the shaft out and back in out the left hole. He had not even tried it yet. You said that some play would help, and I'm ok on that. Lots of times I loosen the fan shaft and slide it forward and that give you room to manuever. Then you said those shafts could have up to 1 inch of travel, and I disagreed, and you now admit that the FSB says only up to 3/8" was acceptable. I think if you read that FSB again it will allude to servicable, not factory pure settings. It was meant to be a quick check in the field. That was my point. Servicable is no more than 3/8" so why do you say one inch? I'm just asking...in fact I'm still asking. It just sounds like you made it up, and if you did, then I can't be wrong....just different. >>> I have witnessed before where, for some reason, that shaft will not make the entire left-to-right side trip so long as the fan shaft is fully in position. These men have learned that by loosening the fan shaft mount to the governor housing a small amount, the shaft slipped in just fine. My concern -- with this fellow -- is that he was totally oblivious to the relationship, and that he was to go to the full article about the governor-fan shaft relationship and its possible cost impact over at the JD-H Restoration Site, under TECHNICAL ISSUES. You should check it out sometime -- it may have value for you! I've been pretty successful fixing these things over the years, thanks. I still have the e-mail questions you sent me about this exact subject some time back, so it appears that you found some value in my words at least some time ago. Would you like to refresh your memory? >>>At any rate, bottom line, you just have to have at least 3/4" free travel at the fan blade tip on gear pairs which have been "on the job" for 60 years of more. Have you checked your JD-H lately? (PatB) "just have to have" is a sweeping generalization, and so now you change the number to 3/4". One more go round and you'll agree with me inspite of yourself. Yes, I have checked my "H", and my 70D, and a few dozen others. Do you have an engineering degree? I just thought you might have invented some new math. I just asked where you got those numbers and your answer turns out to be that you MADE IT UP. My point was that when you say something is gospel, someone else who is only reading the edge of this stuff will post a question two weeks later asking what he has to do to add shims to get to one inch travel because he heard from a friend on the board that Pat said one inch is required. If your tome is as widely accepted as you say, there are a lot of folks out there asking that right now. Just go back and read his question, and read your response, then answer me where you got one inch. That was all I asked. Remember, you're not the first guy to work on some governor gears. I've been around the block a few times myself. I know you have a tough time with that, but that's the way it is. One inch is too much, 3/4" is too much, and JD said more than 3/8" is too much.
|