|
Hello Frank, To expand a bit on what you said, there are two reactions when any acid touches a rusted metal part. The first simple exchange reaction is the one with the rust, and the second oxidation reduction reaction is the one with the base metal. Using phosphoric acid, the first reaction, on the rust, is Fe2O3+2H3PO4 -> 2FePO4+3H2O. This takes place rather quickly. The second reaction, on the base metal, is Fe+H3PO4 -> FePO4+H2. This is not nearly as fast. If you use muriatic acid (diluted HCl approx. 30% by weight), the two reactions are chemically the same when you substitute the Cl in place of the PO4. The big difference is in that BOTH of the reaction rates of the HCl are at a rather fast pace (eating metal almost as fast as rust). So, yes, I agree with you that using a strong acid, such as muriatic acid, on a dimensionally critical part could cause more damage than a weak acid on the same part. The reason that I like to use muriatic anyway, is that I keep an eye on the parts and pull them out the instant they are ready to be removed. I am not a patient person by nature, and am not convinced that there really is that much difference if you pull the part out on time. You got me though, in that the FeCl3 does not stick to, and protect the metal surface like the FePO4. I know, or at least think I know, that you are either a chemical engineer, or a chemist. I am not, nor even close, so I am interested in your electrolysis method. Is it superior to chemical reactions in that it does not dissolve, but rather, it works by forming gasses underneath the corroded areas which causes the rust to flake off, which would leave the base material intact? I hope this made sense, as people have been interrupting me incessantly since I started writing. Greg
|