|
ts, you are right, basically. First of all, just cuz a heavy duty battery has the ability/capacity to deliver more amperage (as youre correctly thiking) doesnt mean it supplies anymore amperage than a light wimpy battery through a certain resistance (limited by time), per Mr. Ohms Law I = E/R. Youre also right in that the current draw depends upon the starters resistance and PROVIDED THE BATTERY CAN SUPPLY THAT AMPERAGE WITHOUT/BEFORE DROPPING ITS VOLTAGE, then EITHER battery (heavy or light duty) would supply the SAME AMPS and there would be the same resultant heat generated. Sooooo ooo I agree with you and disagree with those who fear a heavy rated battery would "melt your starter" Actually (see below) a heavier rated battery could be less prone to drop its voltage and, therefore, maybe even pump less amps through a load then a weak battery whose voltage drops more!!!!! !!!!! !!!!! !!! Heres the difference: The higher amp rated battery can supply more amps BEFORE DROPPING ITS VOLTAGE LEVEL than say a light rated battery. The problem with a lighter rated battery is that under heavy loads its voltage drops more and therefore, to supply the same amount of power (volts x amps) into a load, its current would have to increase, which further reduces the voltage making things worse. GO WITH THE HIGHEST AMP/HR OR CCA YOU CAN FIT INTO THE COMPARTMENT and since its voltage may drop less, the starter may actually draw less current then if a light battery were used. The starter requires POWER = VOLTS X AMPS, so at lower voltages (say a weak battery) to deliver the same power, current could actually INCREASE over a heavy duty battery. PS the battery ratings of amp hours or CCA has to do with how many amps over how much time a battery can deliver BEFROE ITS VOLTAGE DROPS to a certain level. A higher rated battery can supply more amps over a fixed time before dropping its voltage then a wimpy battery can. YESSSSS SSSSS if that battery has one bad cell, as indicated by the Specific Gravity reading, it needs replaced unless you have a battery shop that could replace the bad cell but that sounds impractical n probably more expensive then a new battery. You test ALLLLL cells of course and in this case, one bad apple does indeed spoil the whole barrell. John T
|