|
jdemaris
04-13-2005 06:33:43
|
|
Re: Diode trio? in reply to Bob, 04-12-2005 21:01:26
|
|
| |
With the resistor, I guess it depends on your defintion of "need." The reason G.M. installed the resistor in the Delco system, I assume, is to allow the charging system to function even if the idiot light bulb burns out. Anywhere around 75 ohms and 3-5 watts works fine. Can't say I've ever had a trio that tests as good but in actuality is bad. Maybe we differ in the way we test? I check for continuity both ways, and then also check with a 5 amp @ 12 volt load. Trio failure seems to be more common than the bigger diode failing - at least with our forestry equipment. Why forestry? - I don't know, but suspect it has something to do with electricity not being available for electric block heaters, cold weather starting problems, and the resulting boost or jump starting. I used to carry a few sets of "alternator repair kits" with me all the time. Brush assembly, regulator, and a diode-trio. We had a lot of failures with Delcos in Deere tractors. We used to blame it to such things as welding on the machine and using boost-battery chargers for cold weather starting. There seemed to be a correlation. In addition, they are not sealed well, even with the debris screens Deere added. So, they'd often eat up slip rings, brushes, etc. Then, compound that with the cheap replacement parts sometimes used to fix them, and they sometimes get worse. Delcos are cheap and easy to find - perhaps that's why they are so popular? I usually grab them for $15 apiece at the junkyard. You can take the little Hitachi alternators off of Japanese cars e.g. older Subarus, and they are more compact and hold up much better than the Delcos. Hookup is exactly the same for the Hitachis as the Delco 10SI, 12SI, etc. I used to be an AC Delco fan, but no more. As far as I'm concerned, all they are anymore are mass marketers of parts they usually don't even make. It's kind of a shame what has happened to some, what were once, good companies. I've has some recent go-arounds. For example - I was having a high failure rate for Delco glow-plugs in G.M. diesels. After getting nowhere with Delco tech-support, I started using Beru instead. Beru is becoming the world-standard for quality now. And now, after Delco denied any problems with their plugs - go buy some Delcos and they are repackaged Berus. I can mention several components that Delco is marketing right now that are poor quality, some parts not meeting original OEM specs - in fact, some nowhere close.
|
|
|