Welcome! Please use the navigational links to explore our website.
PartsASAP LogoCompany Logo (800) 853-2651

Shop Now

   Allis Chalmers Case Farmall IH Ford 8N,9N,2N Ford
   Ferguson John Deere Massey Ferguson Minn. Moline Oliver

Attention Forum Users: On the 28th of December 2023 at 9:00am Central Time, we will be taking the forums down for maintenance while we prepare the new forums for your use. Please click here for more information.

John Deere Tractors Discussion Forum
:

Wierd encounter!

Welcome Guest, Log in or Register
Author 
Ben/Green

01-10-2005 18:20:38




Report to Moderator

We just got or JD 60 started after not running for about 3 months, when we got it started it only ran on the right cylinder. My dad took the spark plug wire off the left plug while the tractor was running and held it away from the plug and she fired right up on two cylinders. You could see the blue spark jump from the wire to the plug. When you would put the wire back on the plug like it was supposed to be it would go back to running on one cylinder! We replaced the plug and you could know put the wire and rubber boot on the normal way. Have any of you had this problem or any other wierd encounder while working on some of the tractors from the past. I'm curious to know what you guys think. Ben

[Log in to Reply]   [No Email]
gusc

01-11-2005 20:48:04




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to Ben/Green, 01-10-2005 18:20:38  
It has been very interesting reading all these theories so I will give you mine. There is not enough resistance in your secondary system, probably in the plug leads or it could be the gap is too close.

The story on voltage buildup has already been mentioned, and mentioned and mentioned. This is the problem.

If you use new carbon filled high resistance wires the plugs will fire ok. This worked on my '53 60. Increasing the plug gap might work but new wires should be tried first.

Wire leads are not the answer, they are must less resistant and will make the problem worse.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
OhioDeere

01-11-2005 06:40:00




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to Ben/Green, 01-10-2005 18:20:38  
John T is correct. when the plug is fouled it never gives the coil a chance to discharge at a high voltage it just short circuits. increase the resisitance in the circuit (by gaps, etc) and eventually the voltage will go high enough to jump an air gap. the voltage charge into and field collapse to and from the coil is very sinusodal. a correct wiring and gap should fire the plug at approx. 60% of capable design voltage from the coil. when you operate above and below this you reduce the life of the coil. so gap settings are important. also the pregapped plugs will not do the coil any favors. but most life spans on the coil go unregonized anyhow.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Clooney

01-11-2005 09:30:24




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to OhioDeere, 01-11-2005 06:40:00  
OhioDeere, in all things you mentioned above probably the coil�s collapse time is the most important.. Large air gaps in the secondary circuit will improve the short term spark intensity but that is just another place where long term spark erosion will get you.. If those air gaps get larger than the plug gap then spark erosion becomes a very large durability factor..

The faster coil collapse time (faster spark rise time) is the real answer as that allows the spark KV to raise & jump the plug gap before it can bleed off to parricidal losses.

The newer electronic ignition systems are much superior at preventing spark bleed-off as they are designed to use much a higher KV output coil, they also don�t have the current limitation�s of the old point�s type systems.. The higher KV coils also allow the use of larger spark plug gaps for better low RPM ignition but the larger plug gaps then require a better insulated thicker premium plug wire to reduce voltage leaks to each other or ground.. In a lot of cases that also requires a larger diameter distributor cap to reduce arcing between cap tower contacts.
The newer coil designs like the E-Coils are also much better at discharging quicker & the electronic switching transistors in electronic ignitions can trigger quicker therefore promoting a quicker coil collapse & faster spark rise time..

Good subject here..

Clooney

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John T

01-11-2005 12:12:52




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to Clooney, 01-11-2005 09:30:24  
Clooney, its been so long I forget, but at one time you and also I e mailed about this subject (it was an interesting n fun exchnage) and you were gonna check with some ignition type engineers where you work about my thoughts above that if the plug gap were increased, it would cause a corresponding change in EITHER the amount of plug gap current and/or the arc duration time. Thats cuz when the coils primary is conducting DC current the seconday is an OPEN CIRCUIT across the plug gap and when the points open and the primary no longer is drawing current and the coils no longer storing energy, THE ONLY AVAILABLE ENERGY THAT CAN GET EXPENDED (in form of heat n voltsge n current flow over time) across the plug gap (and in wire and heat losses) is that AND NO MORE. THEREFORE, its my belief that changing the gaps and any extra gaps or resistances etc (since we dont create or destroy more energy that that stored) must cause a change in either current or amount of time it flows.

Glad to have you n Duane aboard on this one (dont go away so long again lol you rascal) as I agree with you its a great subject and a good thread.

Your friend to the South, God Bless ya for the help you provide to so many, hope you join us someday at some of the Seminars.

John T

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Clooney

01-11-2005 16:15:59




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to John T, 01-11-2005 12:12:52  
John, I did kind of follow up but really didn't get very far.. One thing I did determine is that it is impossible to get a group of engineers to agree on anything.. One of the big argument point�s was where we were going to take the measurements at what point we were going to chop the data as the larger the gap the sooner the trailing spark would quit.. There was also a lot of discussion on how much the added loss would be in the wires & other related areas as the KV went up. Also how much loss in the coil due to extra heat. So to answer your (our) question (I still really don�t know)..

I got busy at work & never did get a chance to dig up some old coil data to see if I could track a trend.. I�m busier that a 3 peckered billy goat at the moment so it will probably be a while yet..

I need to find one of our brand new EE�s just out of college but most haven�t ever seen a points type system�

Clooney

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John T

01-11-2005 07:35:53




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to OhioDeere, 01-11-2005 06:40:00  
Ohio, I wholeheartedly agree with your "correct gap settings" being important. When these systems were designed, the coils parameters (rise n fall time n impedance),,,,, ,,,and the plugs gap,,,,, ,and the medium (compression and fuel/air) in which the plug fires, were alllll lllll taken into consideration. As we know, THE ONLY ENERGY THE COIL HAS TO EXPEND (once points open and primary is no longer drawign current and no more energy is being put INTO the coil) is what was stored in it during the (points closed) conduction cycle, and that gets dissipated in the form of heat and volts x amps over time. THEREFOREEEEE EE, when you start doing things like widen a plug gap or add an extra gap or causing the voltage to ramp up higher, EITHER the arcing current or the arc duration time must decrease to satisfy the conservation of energy laws of physics. These may be things the coil wasnt necessarily designed for so the bottom line as I see it is what I think you are saying, WHEN YOU START MESSING WITH PLUG GAPS AND EXTRA GAPS ETC you may gain in one aspect (like make a fouled plug fire) but somethign else has to give.

At a GOG Seminar a couple years myslef and Duane Larson (a physicist) discussed part of this but we never got to finish, hope he weighs in here.

Great thread, I love this stuff, hope we arent boring anyone lol.

God bless yall

John T in Indiana

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Clooney

01-11-2005 04:04:31




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to Ben/Green, 01-10-2005 18:20:38  
Ben/Green, that (your observation) is a common form of �Spark Plug Foiling� as mentioned by others below..

It seems to happen more frequently on older low compression weaker ignition system vehicles.. Not only on old tractors, but also old cars, lawnmowers, chain saws, etc..

The reason it happens is mixed.. But it�s usually a function of using the modern �harder to ignite� emissions friendly gasoline�s (that were developed for modern higher compression automobiles with extremely high power ignition systems) in older low compression engines with �slow rise time� weaker spark, points & coil type ignition systems..

Here�s what usually happens�As you try to start the older engine (your dads 60 in this case), the choke is pulled & the engine is cranked over,, a rich fuel laden mixture is pulled into the cylinders & a spark from the ignition system ties to ignite it.. If it fires & runs clean no problems.. If that cylinder mis-fires, or stays richer, or the spark is weak due to slow cranking & a weak battery, then the spark plug mis-fires & allows the spark plug�s center electrode porcelain to �wet out� with unburnt fuel..

Once that spark plug�s center porcelain becomes saturated with fuel it allows the spark that is supplied to it to kind of bleed down that wet outside of the porcelain instead of jumping the plug�s electrode gap so that cylinder continually mis-fires.. This kind of feeds on itself as the more that cylinder mis-fires the wetter the plug gets.. Once the plug has mis-fired a few (or few hundred) times the plug�s center porcelain either becomes well saturated with unburnt fuel or it becomes carbon tracked because of the spark always traveling the same path down that wet center porcelain..

There is an old saying that �Electricity� is lazier than a pet Coon Dog.. That is basically true & is why all this plug fouling stuff happens to begin with.. The spark supplied to the spark plugs would much rather take an easy path to ground like (bleed off down that wet center electrode) than stop at the spark plug gap long enough to build high enough energy to jump that plug�s electrode gap..

OK, now to answer your question on why pulling that plug wire off slightly allowed it to fire that cylinder.. Well basically all you did was create a second spark gap in the spark loop that was wider than the spark plug gap.. That caused the spark current (produced in the coil) to stop at that (your) gap long enough to build to a high enough voltage to jump that artificial gap,, once the spark had built high enough to jump your man made gap it had no problems jumping the spark plug�s gap as by then it was so high & fast it just jumped the plug gap without having time to slowly bleed off down that porcelain..

In the old days (well old to me anyhow) this (plug fouling) problem wasn�t a real big problem like it is today.. Mainly due to�

-The tractor being used daily to farm with..

-Older leaded gasoline had a lower vapor pressure as there were no emission rules yet so it turned into an ignitable gas at lower pressure & ignited easier.

-The spark plugs of old had glazed porcelain centers (a lot of newer plugs don�t have glazed porcelain centers because the new high compression high energy ignition systems of today don�t require that extra step).. The newer plugs with unglazed porcelain�s soak the fuel in easier & do tend to fuel foul easier..

One of the little (field) tricks that was used in years past on tractors & old equipment was to take an ordinary shirt or coat button, then cut the spark plug wire a few inches from the spark plug & strip the insulator back an inch or so, then weave that plug wire through the button�s holes.. The idea was to have one part of the wire threaded through two of the button�s holes & the other part of the wire threaded through the other two holes so there was a space between the wire on the button. That acted just like that gap you made when pulling the wire slightly off the plug.. That allowed the farming to continue until a trip back to the barn or a trip to town to buy new plugs.. (BTW I still have some of those old wire & buttons in my junk drawer)..

OK, now that we know, how & why it happens what can be done about it..

Well the easiest thing is to just use hotter spark plugs as that allows the plugs electrodes to run hotter & burn that pesky fuel off easier.. On that 60 probably use a Champion D-23 for most around the estate use & drop back to a D-21 plug for heavy field usage.. Your tractor probably has a D-16 or equivalent (cold) plug in it now.. I�m not telling you to use Champion plugs so if you like Auto-lite or A/C just cross ref. the Champion numbers above to the plug brand you want to run..

Also make darn sure your dad�s tractor has solid METAL CORE spark plug wires (Copper is best).. If it have modern automotive TVRS (carbon core) resistor wires it will cause you all kinds of plug fouling issues..

Clooney

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Lyle MN

01-11-2005 06:34:26




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to Clooney, 01-11-2005 04:04:31  
CLOONY WRITE THAT BOOK!!!!!



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Duane Larson

01-11-2005 06:10:36




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to Clooney, 01-11-2005 04:04:31  
Nice summary, Clooney. One point - many of the original plugs are still available NOS, even two-piece take apart plugs for easy cleaning, and many had glazed insulators which aided in the cleaning. I have the same Champion 2ComL 2 piece take-aparts (glazed insulators) in my GP for over 10 years now - just an occasional pull, take apart, wipe clean, and replace, occasionally with a new crush washer. Duck soup.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Clooney

01-11-2005 16:31:43




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to Duane Larson, 01-11-2005 06:10:36  
Duane, I know some of the multi piece are still around but haven�t seen many of the original one piece. Maybe as a collector you are exposed to more plug opportunities than I am..

I do use the take-aparts in some of my hit & miss engines but not in my old tractors..

Are those original type one piece plugs of the glazed porcelain construction or are they modern non glazed but built to old specs?

I really haven�t done much plug experimenting on my personal tractors as I have very little plug fouling problems with them & I even use those much hated Champions in most.. I do have a little fouling in some of my ultra slow hit & miss engines but as you say those take-apart plugs do clean easily..

Maybe some time you could do a little write up for us here on spark plugs-- what�s available yet & maybe what will cross to what�s old/new.. I know I would be real interested & I�m sure others would be too.

Clooney

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John T

01-10-2005 19:42:26




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to Ben/Green, 01-10-2005 18:20:38  
Ben, what you describe is somewhat common on those tractors when a plug begins to foul out, but removing the plug wire away from the plug and making the spark jump that extra gap then makes the plug fire. I can give you an electrical engineers opinion of whats going on:

When a plug becomes fouled, the reason it dont fire and ignite the fuel air mixture is because a shorting circuit path of gas or oil or carbon etc. (what fouls the plug) builds up on the plugs insulator (ceramic). Then, when the high voltage begins its ramp up to arc jump the plugs gap, before it can rise to the normal high voltage necessary to arc current across the plugs spark gap, the energy stored in the coil gets prematurely dissipated via the current leaking/flowing through the fouling material (carbon n oil). Therefore, it never rises high enough to arc current across the plugs gap as all the stored coil energy gets wasted by current flowing through the carbon n oil built up on the plugs insulation. (no high voltage caused current arc across the normal plug gaps path)

NOWWWWW WWWWW when you add that extra gap in the plug wire, the premature shorting path of carbon n oil is taken out of the circuit/equation allowing the voltage to ramp up (energys not prematurley dissipated by current in the foulings) and then when it reaches the 10,000 or so volts (which its now allowed to do as normal) it goes ahead and arcs the plug gap and ignites the fuel as normal.

I have seen old tractors (low compression oil burners which foul plugs) with extra plug gaps either by cutting the plugs wires and using insulated tubing to create an extra gap or even havign the wires separated away from the plug terminals etc to make them run with otherwise fouled out plugs. I think Champion manufactures plugs havign that extra internal gap, I believe their designations is somethigbn like U or UD added to the regular plug number.

Anywho, its like the fouling deposits of carbon n oil sort of have the plug shorted out (cuz current can flow through that stuff and expend the coils stored energy) so that extra gap allows the voltage to rise and then it (cuz of its high voltage) can go ahead and arc current flow across the gap instead of it flowing through the oil n carbon.

Thats one opinion of whats going on and it will be fun n interestign to read other opinions n theories of what you described.

Good luck n God Bless

John T in Indiana

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Dave NE IOWA

01-10-2005 18:50:28




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to Ben/Green, 01-10-2005 18:20:38  
Very common solution to plug fouling, you can buy plugs that have a built in extra gap. Some claim that jumping your spark as you did is hard on a coil, but I do it all the time and have yet to notice anything abnormal. Dave NE IOWA



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CPeter

01-11-2005 05:40:58




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to Dave NE IOWA, 01-10-2005 18:50:28  
One thing that forcing the spark to jump the extra distance is hard on is the rotor and cap. It will find weaknesses in the dielectric and go to ground or burn a hole through the rotor to ground.

CPeter



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
4boyz

01-10-2005 19:01:34




Report to Moderator
 Re: Wierd encounter! in reply to Dave NE IOWA, 01-10-2005 18:50:28  
My brother had an old H Farmall,that fouled all 4 plugs.He took mechanics wire and tied all the plug wires,away from the plugs.This trick kept the plugs from fouling.He said it was a real lite show at nite!



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
[Options]  [Printer Friendly]  [Posting Help]  [Return to Forum]   [Log in to Reply]

Hop to:


TRACTOR PARTS TRACTOR MANUALS
We sell tractor parts!  We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today. [ About Us ]

Home  |  Forums


Copyright © 1997-2023 Yesterday's Tractor Co.

All Rights Reserved. Reproduction of any part of this website, including design and content, without written permission is strictly prohibited. Trade Marks and Trade Names contained and used in this Website are those of others, and are used in this Website in a descriptive sense to refer to the products of others. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy

TRADEMARK DISCLAIMER: Tradenames and Trademarks referred to within Yesterday's Tractor Co. products and within the Yesterday's Tractor Co. websites are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Yesterday's Tractor Co., our products, or our website nor are we sponsored by them. John Deere and its logos are the registered trademarks of the John Deere Corporation. Agco, Agco Allis, White, Massey Ferguson and their logos are the registered trademarks of AGCO Corporation. Case, Case-IH, Farmall, International Harvester, New Holland and their logos are registered trademarks of CNH Global N.V.

Yesterday's Tractors - Antique Tractor Headquarters

Website Accessibility Policy