|
Duane, you say.. Quote:--� if you pull a plug wire the sound goes to a "tut tut tut" from a "putt putt putt", so with both plugs firing the sound is different.� --I agree the sound changes but probably due to different cylinder pressures at ex. valve opening.. Even a non firing cylinder has compression pressure to release & that will give a lower subdued noise. Quote;--�For an unstyled A each exhaust valve is open for 230 deg, for 460 deg total exhaust valve open during a cycle. For 50 degrees of that time both exhaust valves are open. So the overlap time is only about 11% of the combined exhaust valve open time. However, this is misleading because I assume the sound coming out is not uniformly distributed over the 230 deg. Does it occur during the early part of the 230 deg (a plot of the sound intensity as a function of piston position, valve opening and engine loading would be interesting)?� --My personal thinking & background in tuning 2-cycle exhaust systems leads me to believe most if not all the pop of exhaust noise is at initial ex. valve opening.. Once open the pressure is gone or at least lowered.. My thinking is the noise is the initial opening pressure wave exiting the end of the pipe.. That initial positive pressure wave is usually followed by a negative wave going back down the pipe. Quote:--�the exhaust path is longer than for #2, so that may delay the #1 exhaust sound, bringing it closer to the end of the 230 deg valve opening, hence closer to the 50 deg overlap and opening of #2 exhaust valve. So, theoretically there is plenty of time to hear two distinct "putts" in a cycle depending on the exhaust harmonics associated with the ignition of the fuel/air mixture in the cylinder - and I assume there is significant variation in this sound pattern depending on whether the tractor is under load, engine rpm, etc.� --I agree with the gas travel time for #1 cylinder placing it�s pressure wave nearer #2 cylinder when it's valve opens.. I still don�t think the length of time the valve is open has much effect on the noise.. It probably modulates the sound but not the intensity. Quote:--�But I believe the 11% overlap is enough to merge the sounds of the two cylinders under many conditions. I think I have to choose the engine operating conditions and listen much harder to hear two distinct putts from a run of the mill Deere - most of the time I just hear the one "putt". I haven't heard a dual exhaust D run so I'll take your word that you can hear the distinct "putts".� --I think we basically agree until the overlap part.. I haven�t been able to convince myself that overlap has much effect.. I guess when the exhaust valve opens I kind of picture it like a tire blow out,, you get the initial bang as the high pressure pops to atmosphere then a whooshing noise as the little remaining air continues to escape.. One tire popping being followed by a second tire would give 2 distinct bangs even though the air escaping from the first would still be taking place. Listen to a multi cylinder aircraft engine with short stacks you can hear every exhaust pop even though there is major valve overlap between the cylinders.. Quote:-- Lots of unanswered questions that could be resolved with some clever lab work. I'll think more about how to do some experimenting. And I look forward to further discussions under a shade tree! --When I go back to work shortly I will ask our exhaust engineers that specialize exhaust tuning & dyno order tracking if I can get a quick education on exhaust harmonics & order position.. Great discussion_____Clooney
|