|
Your first sentence in your response says it all..."not easy to compare." I have looked at multiple sources on these Tests and have also concluded the same thing. I suppose the MBHP tests were the most consistent, but in the last few years of testing on the belt, I question even those results. I am of the opinion that it became very difficult to transmit power efficiently from the belt pulley to the test load with the higher HP tractors in the late 1950s. This was especially true I think with the big bore JDs as their power characteristics under heavy load are not as smooth as a similar HP 4 or 6 cylinder tractor. I have noticed that the 'max pull pounds' quoted in C.H. Wendel's epic work Nebraska Tractor Tests Since 1920 do not agree with Lorry Dunning's figures. I have to say that I haven't drilled down to see what specific test parameters these guys are quoting. I have never figured out (loved to have been there!) how consistent publishable draw bar figures were recorded on the test track. In the early days of the dirt oval track, how can a test conducted in March compare to a test conducted on a sun-baked September track? Or a wet track vs. a dry track? How much ballast did NU know to add? You seem to be quite an authority. Is your last name coincidental with Mr. Lester Larson's?
|