|
Good afternoon Greg, Well to answer your questions: YES, the starter could be showing early signs of failing; and, YES, it could be something else, such as the push switch,,,,, , or the starter solenoid,,,,, ,,or even a bad connection. I will run you through push switch, then solenoid troubleshooting, and if they are okay, you may have a bad connection (carboned or loose) somewhere and finallyyyyy yyy maybe a bad starter after all. The brushes could possibly be worn down low and are near time for replacement or the commutator may have a burned or pitted or bad segment, regardless, time for starter work. From your description, you could well have a starter that needs brushes or a bad cable connection or possibly a bad solenoid, I think its less likely a push switch problem actually, but will still guide you through most checks. PRELIMINARY (A) Make sure each and every battery and ground and starter and solenoid connection is clean, tight, and carbon free. If in doubt, remove, clean and wire brush, and re attach each and every connection on the battery, starter, ground, and solenoid. If any connections get hot or emit a sizzling sound, they may be bad. PRELIMINARY (B) When you have the push switch down but shes not starting, do the lights dim way down if they are on or the battery voltage drop drastically??? If so, the push switch and solenoid are doing their job, BUT the starter is not. If the push switch causes the solenoid to click, but she dont crank and the lights dont dim, the solenoid may be bad. PRELIMINARY (C) Is the battery in good condition and well charged??? Has it been load tested lately??? PUSH SWITCH TESTING (doubt its bad) 1) If she always clicks when you depress the push switch, your push switch is probably okay, but your starter or solenoid may be bad. To check the switch, assuming it has a good voltage supply from the ignition switch: a) Just use a jumper wire and jump around it to energize the solenoid wire that leads down to the starter solenoid. Thas NOT the wire to the ballast resistor, the one down to starter solenoid is what you wanna energize. That by passes the push switches internal contacts and feeds voltage to the wire which is supposed to activate the starter solenoid; or, b) If you can get to the solenoid, jump the lil terminal over to the big lug where the battery cable is. That sends hot battery voltage (from the big cable lug) to the lil solenoid activation terminal, same as if the push switch wire fed it. c) In the event the feed for the push switch from the ignition switch were bad (like a bad internal switch contact) you can do these same push switch checks by usign an alternate source of hot battery voltage to feed the wire leadign down to the starter solenoid. In the unlikely event an alternate hot feed ALWAYS caused her to crank, trace back to see where youre loosing good power to the push switches input terminal. The input is the one NOT to the ballast and nOT to the starter. d) If she always causes the solenoid to click loudly and stay engaged, I doubt its a problem. If when pushed she only yields the click on occasions and the by pass jump tests ALWAYS causes the click, then it likely is bad!!!!! !!!! If the push switch is good; SOLENOID TESTING NOTE: You may not be able to do this at all, dependign on the location of the solenoid and what access you can get to its terminals. DO NOT let the big post (where big battery cable is attached) or anythign connected to it get shorted to frame ground. The solenoid MUST make that loud solid click to be engaging, but the trouble is that could be happening bit its internal contacs still bad. USE EXTREME CAUTION AND DO NOT LET THE HOT LEAD FROM THE BATTERY CABLE TOUCH FRAME GROUND ONLY IF POSSIBLE TO GET TO AND DO SO safely, if you jumper cable around the starter solenoid by having a clamp on the starter motor input post and then attach the other to the hot ungrounded battery post, the starter should spin. HOWEVER, if its not under a load and the starter drive dont engage, that may not really be too indicative of the starters quality. Jumping the starter motor direct may spin the motor but the drive may or may not engage the flywheel. If its a centrifugal bendix gear drive it will, but if the solenoid is what pushes the gear drive out to the flywheel but the solenoid (just the motor) is not engaged it wont. FINALLY STARTER PROBLEMS
Iffff the battery,,,,, all cables and connections,,,,, the push switch,,,,, ,the solenoid are ALL GOOD, the starter may be bad like worn brushes or a commutator problem or other things. I have seen them when the brushes are worn or the commutator is bad or has a bad segment exhibit what you described. If she clicks and the lights dim bad the stater is likely the culprit. If they dont dim, the solenoid MAY be the problem, but unfortunately it could still be in the starter. I apologize for being so long, but Im tryign to cover several possible problem scenarios, even though they are likely not the cause. Always check easy basic thigns first like battery condition and cables and grounds. The starter could also have mechanical drive problems or is sticking. Does it help to rock the flywheel or hammer on the starter or loosen it a tad????? ????? Are the flywheel teeth in good condition all way around????? ?? Are the bendix teeth all good????? Try some of the checks above ad post back or direct e mail me at [email protected] amnd I will try n help you. :et me know what you find. Again YES it coluld be the starter but YES it could be other minor things. Good Luck n God Bless ya John T Nordhoff in Indiana
|