Welcome! Please use the navigational links to explore our website.
PartsASAP LogoCompany Logo (800) 853-2651

Shop Now

   Allis Chalmers Case Farmall IH Ford 8N,9N,2N Ford
   Ferguson John Deere Massey Ferguson Minn. Moline Oliver

Attention Forum Users: On the 28th of December 2023 at 9:00am Central Time, we will be taking the forums down for maintenance while we prepare the new forums for your use. Please click here for more information.

John Deere Tractors Discussion Forum
:

730 diesel batteries always dead, why?

Welcome Guest, Log in or Register
Author 
JL

07-24-2003 17:34:37




Report to Moderator

My brother has a 730 diesel electric start with 4 6volt batteries. He's had trouble ever since he's owned the tractor with the battery's draining. We've replaced all the battery cables, ran new wires to the lights, and 3 of the 4 batt. have been replaced (had bad cells) . After it sits a day it wont even have enough juice to turn the motor over even with the compression lever pushed. But once it's ran for 20 minutes or so it'll start the rest of the day. He put a battery disconnect on the cable going out to the starter but this hasn't helped. I thought maybe switch to 2 12volt batt., seems simpler and less to go wrong, but that dosn't seem to be an option now that he's already bought 3 new batteries. We're just wondering where to start looking. It seems like by disconnecting the batteries at the cable going to the starter, that there is no where for the power to drain, but I'm no electrician. I'd appreciate any help anyone can give.

[Log in to Reply]   [No Email]
ErnieD

07-25-2003 17:54:39




Report to Moderator
 Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to JL, 07-24-2003 17:34:37  
When the engine is off does the generator stay warm to hot? If so the regulator is not disconnecting the field from the generator, draining the power to the gen field. Rap the regulator to free the coil.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Bob

07-25-2003 08:48:33




Report to Moderator
 Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to JL, 07-24-2003 17:34:37  
The starter frame on these tractors is isolated from both the (+) and the (-) side of the 24V system, but is, of course, connected to the midpoint of the 24V circuit through the jumper wire to the tractor frame of the midpoint of the 6V batteries connected in series. The starter solenoid only disconnects one side of the 24V supply from the starter, (I believe the (-) side, if all is hooked up as to Mother Deere's intentions.) This leaves the whole guts of the starter at a 12 V potential to the frame of the starter. It is quite common on these machines to have a buildup of carbon thrown off the brushes, combined with moisture in the starter, and this will cause a battery drain. If the starter is wired as to the original design, the solenoid disconnects the starter from the (-) side of the battery, and if you disconnect the cable from the (+) side of the battery, this should eliminate the current leakage that is draining the battery.

If this helps, it would be a good idea to have a COMPETANT electrical shop go through the starter and clean and check it out.

The 24 volt generator is wired in much the same mannner. The cutout relay in the voltage regulator disconnects only one side of the 24V system, leaving the guts of the generator at a 12V potential to the case, and any fault in the insulation of the windings, or accumulation of damp dirt and brush debris in the generator will cause the batteries to run down.

Another thing I have seen on these machines is the generator warning light and/or the fuel gauge mis-wired, causing a battery drain with the switch off.

Disconnecting both the (-) and the (+) leads that go to the starter AT THE BATTERY when not using the tractor should be a temporary solution to the problem, but there is always a risk of battery explosion. BE CAREFUL, and wear safety goggles when working with batteries! You only have one pair of eyes!

I will look up the battery wiring when I get to the shop, and post back as to which side of the 24V system is hooked to the solenoid, and which side is hooked the the innards of the starter and is not disconnected by the solenoid.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John T

07-24-2003 19:33:09




Report to Moderator
 Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to JL, 07-24-2003 17:34:37  
JL, Unfortunately, by disconnectign the batterys at the cable going to the starter on that tractor, you can still have a discharge depending upon where the fault is at. Even if you disconnected one of the big starter cables, theres still the other one attached to it, and in the event the starter or solenoid (from that post) is bad and has a path to frame ground (those starters are supposed to be isolated from ground electrically), the 2 batterys on that circuit could still discharge. A shorted to frame ground starter or solenoid etc. could only be eliminated as a source of discharge, if BOTH its big cables were disconnectecd.

Now it gets worse, even if BOTH starter cables are off (that way any solenid or starter shorts are out of circuit), theres still a chance 2 of the batterys (one of the 12 volt sources) has a short circuit to ground somewhere, and if so, it could discharge 2 of the 4 batterys.

Heres how it works: At the mid point of the 4 batterys, theres a smaller cable that ties that center point to frame ground. That makes one of the outermost untied battery posts 12 volts from it to ground in a positive ground (Say Battery Circuit A) while between the tie point ground and the opposite outermost battery terminal its 12 volts negative ground (Say Battery circuit B). The A and B batetry circuits are each 12 volts to ground (1 pos other neg) and power goes to the main switch from each where A and B circuits feed various 12 volt loads like lights etc. to balance the battery loads.

If you have everything off and disconnect 1 at a time the A and B circuits to the switch, if one produces a small spark at dis or re connect, thats the side that has a short and is discharging the 2 batterys on that (A or B) circuit. Or if both produce a spark, the switch itslef may be bad or both circuits (unlikely) have shorts somewhere. Similar, with all off, if you dis or reconnect one of the outermost ungrounded battery terminals and a spark occurs, you know to look for a short on that (A or B) side. You can maybe tell if the short is in the small load circuits (lights or switch) or the starter or solenoid has an internal short, by disconnecting BOTH big starter cables and then dis and re connectign the smaller feed circuits to the A and B terminal on the main switch, and see if she still indicates a current drain. If BOTH starter cables are removed and theres no longer a drain, the starter or solenoid may have an internal short. If with both removed the drian still remains, the short is likely the switch or wires or circuits to or out of it etc (the lil 12 volt loads).

You might take an ohm meter and verify theres no connection/path to frame ground from EITHER of the big starter terminals and that the solenoid isnt shorted. You might also use the ohm meter to insure theres no continuity between any switch terminals and case ground (with the output circuits like to lights removed) and no continuity between the A and B 12 volt circuit switch terminals (with the input feeds removed) and case ground. (DO NOT have voltage present when using an ohm meter)

I would have all 4 batterys load tested while youre at it, but you have to find if the short is in the 2 wire 24 volt circuit (goes to solenoid and starter via the 2 big outermost cables and also to the generator/regulator) or in one of the A or B 12 volt circuit sides or the main switch may be bad and be shorting out the A and B circuit inputs from the batterys. You might also disconnect the 2 wires that are the 24 volt output off the voltage regulator to the batterys (again, look for sparks), cuz there may be a short in the charging system thats draining 2 or 4 of the batterys since both (A and B) circuits get to the generator and regulator.

It would really help if you can determine which 2 or if all 4 batterys are being discharged, then troubleshoot that A or B circuit. (like one of the 12 volt circuits) If its always all 4 discharging, then I suspect the charging system or the solenoid or starter, the 24 volt system.

Sorry so long, this is a tough one over the net.

Good Luck n God Bless

John T Nordhoff in Indiana

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Jake M.

07-25-2003 03:36:07




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to John T, 07-24-2003 19:33:09  
Got a question for you John/ If BOTH starter cables are off per your statment above how can there be any short to ground in either 12 volt side? I have farmed with 2 730 electric starts for over 20 years so am somewhat familier with that 24 volt system. For the life of me I can't understand how there could be a batery discharge if both starter cables are removed at the starter. What am I missing here?

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John T

07-25-2003 05:17:28




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to Jake M., 07-25-2003 03:36:07  
Mornin Jake, Even if both starter cables are off out at the starter or solenoid, there might still be a short somewhere between one of the outermost ungrounded battery ends and ground, which could still discharge that bank of batterys i.e one of the 12 volt sides. Of course, there would still have to remain a connection from that battery end OTHER THAN out there at the big starter or solenoid post to another location, like the charging system or the main switch etc etc or even some after factory jury rigged point (seen plenty of those lol) from which a short could drain current between there and the tie point ground. I was trying to help the poster (but this is a complicated and hard one over the net) diagnose if the problem was more in the 2 wire 24 volt portion between the two outermost ungrounded batterys ends like the starter or solenoid or charging system OR between one of the ends and ground, like lights or switches etc, and do that by disconnecting the starter and solenoid loads. Again, any 12 volt loads that happen to be fed off those posts would have to be removed and connected to the removed terminal (to get battery power), but removign the starter and solenoid loads isolates them from the system which is what I was tryign to accomplish. As youre well aware, its hard if the questioner isnt familiar with electrical to explain all this on the board, however.

Best Wishes n God Bless, I hope this clarifies my answer a bit, its hard for me to understand it even on these complicated systems lol.

John T Nordhoff in Indiana

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
ron in MN

07-25-2003 06:43:49




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, in reply to John T, 07-25-2003 05:17:28  
John, I'm another electrical engineer (retired and tired) that posts here sometimes. I have never worked on the JD 24 volt systems, but think I understand them a "little". My understanding is that the starter is not tied to the ground (chassis or wherever it occurs) that is common to the 12 volt "legs", but that it "floats" ("floats" here means it doesn't connect to the chassis anywhere) across the 24 volt "path". If that's true, then it would be proper to really emphasize that in trying to explain these systems and that may help this gentleman (Jake) understand. Blow me out of the water if I'm wrong! (my reference to "legs" and "paths" is slang terminology for "circuits" to those unfamiliar with electronics!)

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John T

07-25-2003 13:23:24




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: 730 diesel batteries always de in reply to ron in MN, 07-25-2003 06:43:49  
Hi Ron, youre exactly right, the starters case is "electrically" isolated from frame ground (its electrical windings are 2 wire 24 volts), unlike 12 volt units in which the iron frame serves as its ground connection. It has 2 big terminals and the 24 volt load is across them ONLY and NOT one terminal and its case. The 12 volt loads are fed off each outermost battery post (A and B circuits) and the center tie point of the batterys is tied to ground. John T

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
JL- Thanks I'll try it (n

07-24-2003 18:41:08




Report to Moderator
 Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to JL, 07-24-2003 17:34:37  



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Clooney

07-24-2003 18:12:24




Report to Moderator
 Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to JL, 07-24-2003 17:34:37  
JL, have him use that starter cable disconnect switch & also disconnect the little battery ground cable that runs from the center battery cable to ground.

~If the batteries then stay up, he has an accessory drain in one or the other halves of the system.... 1/2 of the lights & some accessories use 2 of the batteries at 12 volts positive ground & the other half of the lights & accessories use the other 2 batteries at 12 volts negative ground using that center cable ground as a return to the chassis.... If, after disconnecting the starter cable disconnect & that center battery cable ground the batteries still go dead, have him temporarily remove the other battery cable going to the starter & see if that helps, if so the starter has an internal short to ground [common problem, could be as simple as brush carbon material piled in the bottom of the starter]....If disconnecting that second battery cable doesn't help, replace that 4th battery as it is probably bad...

~When he opened that starter cable disconnect switch all he did was open the 24 volt starting circuit but didn't effect either independent 12 volt circuit. If either post of that starter has a resisted short to ground it will run the batteries on that half of the system down overnight [common problem].

~If this isn't clear [it's not an easy system to understand], or replacing that 4th battery doesn't get the batteries to stay up, post back we'll get it figured out].

~It wouldn't be a bad ides to pull all 4 batteries & have them ALL load tested just to remove that as a possible cause.....

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Jake M.

07-25-2003 18:35:01




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to Clooney , 07-24-2003 18:12:24  
Clooney whats your take on John T saying there could still be a drain on the 12 volt part of the 730d even when both battery cables are disconnected from the starter? I am just an uneducated farmer but have worked with those 24vlt diesels for years and cant see where that is possible. I know you actualy work on those tractors and he only writes what he reads from others so maybe you can help me understand what I am missing. Or am I right here in that the 12 volt part goes dead when those batery cables are pulled off the starter.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Clooney

07-26-2003 18:17:47




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to Jake M., 07-25-2003 18:35:01  
Jake, I won't comment on anything John or anybody else says or said...

~On your wiring query? You old farmers are really hard to fool. You are correct, when BOTH battery cables are pulled from the starter posts all the 12 volt circuits INCLUDING the charging & both ignition circuits also go dead & therefore can't then have a draw to ground. All loads are taken off those starter posts EXCEPT that little trailer accessory socket on the side of the battery box, so when the cables are pulled from the starter posts there is no power to either of the 12 volt systems or charging circuits. On the electric diesels I haven't ever seen one cobbled with any of those circuits running to the batteries as those starter posts are only a few inches from the voltage regulator & ignition switch feeds & the batteries are way back under the seat.....

~If you want to discuss this in further detail just E-Mail me.....
[email protected]

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John T

07-27-2003 18:52:43




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, in reply to Clooney , 07-26-2003 18:17:47  
AMENNNNN NN lol we agree. If theres no load atatched anywhere, there can be no discharge whatsoever, however, if the solenoid and starter are totally out of the system but any lil load wires are attatched to the cables (as I explained to Jake in my answer to his follow up question, perhaps he missed that??) they can still cause a drain. The cables removed off the starter however, will eliminate that as any possible cause. No one here (Im sure not anyway) is tryign to fool any farmers, we are all here to help and these comlicated ones sure get tough to answer over the net. Thanks for the support and clarification of my points. It looks like an article on 24 volt systems may be one of my next Green Magazine articles where time and detail may help some better understand them darn things. God Bless, your Hoosier Friend, John T

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Clooney

07-28-2003 03:58:35




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: 730 diesel batteries always de in reply to John T, 07-27-2003 18:52:43  
John, I still don't believe we agree on how that 24 volt system works. You clearly stated above that there could still be a 12 volt drain with both battery cables disconnected & I still contend there can't be. [unless there is a short in that little accessory outlet on the battery box]. The charging system & BOTH ignition switch power feeds go dead when those starter battery cables are disconnected. Those power feeds are not permanently connected to either of the battery cables [they use ring connectors] so they don�t remain connected when the cables are pulled�.. Sorry to disagree with you in public.....

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John T

07-26-2003 08:18:52




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to Jake M., 07-25-2003 18:35:01  
Jake, even if the starter cables are removed, there can still be a load on a 12 volt portion of one of the A or B circuits if one of the outermost battery ends has a drain to ground. The 24 volt 2 wire loads are the starter and charging system and each (12 v loads) are connected to the A and B circuits up on the main switch and the charging system (which could have a short). Therefore, even if the starter and solenoid were out of the circuit by disconnectign them (2 big cables) if there are other loads connected to the outermost battery posts and they have a path to ground (like 12 volt loads or the charging system), they can still discharge the batterys.

By the way, we are all here tryign our best to voluntarily assist each other and all these wonderful people in this great hobby. I have NEVER seen anyone copy my answers nor have I copied any others. The more opnions the better when trying to help someonme learn, and if if 2 or 3 or more posts happen to be correct, they should sound about the same regardless. This is all volunteer help to all the good people on here and we are here to help and get along only. Also by the way, I farmed full time several years, bought sold and worked on JD tractors and others for a living, still collect and work on JD's and farm, am a graduate electrical engineer, I give seminars at Expos (2 cylinder, Iowa, and New York) and Gatherign of the Green both years, plus wite technical articles for Green Magazine, and on these boards I try my best to help and give back to so many of the wonderful warm kind people who helped me through the years. Im here to help only, not offend anyone. Its a free country and if any posts offend one, they have the freedom to simply not read them I figure, but many people have helped me and its a joy, pleasure and honor to give a lil back to this great hobby we all love.

I hope my answer helped explain how there can still be a discharge if the starter cables were removed, but if not, post back or e muil me for a more detaield explanation.

Best Wishes n God Bless

John T Nordhoff in Indiana

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
buickanddeere

07-25-2003 19:58:57




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to Jake M., 07-25-2003 18:35:01  
With both cables disconneted from the starter the current drain can still be through the generator/regulator or other cicuits. Lift each battery connection off one at a time. With all switches off and tractor shut down there should be no current measured with a multimeter set to milli amps scale. Bewteen the battery post and the clamp just removed. That last battery could be a dud and draining the system. All batteries in a system must be the same age,size,model,electrolyte level and temperature or they will self discharge to some degree.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
F-I-T

07-24-2003 17:51:13




Report to Moderator
 Re: 730 diesel batteries always dead, why? in reply to JL, 07-24-2003 17:34:37  
JL:

Someone who knows a whole lot more about those 24V center tapped systems will likely tell you to look, but in the meantime, here's a method I've used with great success on those "battery goes down when the switch is turned off" problems.

Get yourself a 12 volt lamp (or 6 volt if it's a 6 volt system). In fact, I built a little unit and included a lamp and a small buzzer from Radio Shack so I get a visual or audible sugnal.

Start by removing the cable that goes to the switch (this might be a bit more complicated with the split/24V system). With all switched off, connect the bulb in series between the battery terminal and the cable end. If it glow, you have a draw that is occuring regardless if the switch is on or off. With the bulb/buzzer still connected, start unhooking wires, one at a time. if there is no change, re-connect the wire right away, so you don't end up with everything unhooked ! sooner or later you will find the wire that interupts the signal, and that's the source of your draw. Now you just have to fix or replace that component *quite often it be just a frayed wire that is barely toughing the frame).

Again, your 24V system may take some special advice, but this test method is a sure-fire way to find a small draw. BTW if it's a big draw, it'll blow the bulb, in which case you know you're looking for something pretty significant !

Frank-in-Tallahassee
70D // 855

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
[Options]  [Printer Friendly]  [Posting Help]  [Return to Forum]   [Log in to Reply]

Hop to:


TRACTOR PARTS TRACTOR MANUALS
We sell tractor parts!  We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today. [ About Us ]

Home  |  Forums


Copyright © 1997-2023 Yesterday's Tractor Co.

All Rights Reserved. Reproduction of any part of this website, including design and content, without written permission is strictly prohibited. Trade Marks and Trade Names contained and used in this Website are those of others, and are used in this Website in a descriptive sense to refer to the products of others. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy

TRADEMARK DISCLAIMER: Tradenames and Trademarks referred to within Yesterday's Tractor Co. products and within the Yesterday's Tractor Co. websites are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Yesterday's Tractor Co., our products, or our website nor are we sponsored by them. John Deere and its logos are the registered trademarks of the John Deere Corporation. Agco, Agco Allis, White, Massey Ferguson and their logos are the registered trademarks of AGCO Corporation. Case, Case-IH, Farmall, International Harvester, New Holland and their logos are registered trademarks of CNH Global N.V.

Yesterday's Tractors - Antique Tractor Headquarters

Website Accessibility Policy