Welcome! Please use the navigational links to explore our website.
PartsASAP LogoCompany Logo (800) 853-2651

Shop Now

   Allis Chalmers Case Farmall IH Ford 8N,9N,2N Ford
   Ferguson John Deere Massey Ferguson Minn. Moline Oliver

Attention Forum Users: On the 28th of December 2023 at 9:00am Central Time, we will be taking the forums down for maintenance while we prepare the new forums for your use. Please click here for more information.

Discussion Forum
:

Real Sad Story with a happy ending

Welcome Guest, Log in or Register
Author 
It was a very b

03-21-2003 16:30:19




Report to Moderator

I remember back in the early sixties and there had been several floods and Dad didn't have much money so he was forced the buy a J.I. Case rotary mower to pull behind our John Deere 630. Those were hard times but we hung on long enough to get rid of that piece of crap and get a John Deere mower. We have never been forced to lower our standards since.




[Log in to Reply]   [No Email]
I'll be back in about a year to stir you ladies up

03-30-2003 14:45:30




Report to Moderator
 Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to It was a very bad year and we were poor, 03-21-2003 16:30:19  
Give it up, Case was dead and buried years ago. Just check at your local J.I. Case dealer. Ooops forgot, they ain't there no more.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Jim Handke

03-27-2003 11:08:24




Report to Moderator
 Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to It was a very bad year and we were poor, 03-21-2003 16:30:19  
You can always tell a John Deere man, But you can't tell him much.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John H-Wi

03-23-2003 13:17:52




Report to Moderator
 Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to It was a very bad year and we were poor, 03-21-2003 16:30:19  
Its kind of fun to listen to everyones point of view except for the folks who make idiotic statements with nothing to back them up. These aren't as good as I used to listen to at the old country store when the guys would have a few beers in them. Of course many of the farmers had Farmalls and they wouldn't give an inch to the green guys. Remember one Spring we plowed up some ground after taking the early hay off with the old C, fluid, weights maide from the old drive wheels off a steam locomotive and several sacks of sand. Very dry and hard. Neighbor accross the way had a G out in front of his B to do his plowing. Man, did that ever make the red guys happy!

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Jim P

03-24-2003 07:18:21




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to John H-Wi, 03-23-2003 13:17:52  
Around here(western NE) in the 1930-40 era Case tractors sold well and were well liked. the plows were fair and combines in the thirty's were good-- but untell the IH-Case Rotary combine came out, Case combines did not sell well as most people did not like them. I find some of their other implements did not sell as well as other brands.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Jim P

03-24-2003 07:18:09




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to John H-Wi, 03-23-2003 13:17:52  
Around here(western NE) in the 1930-40 era Case tractors sold well and were well liked. the plows were fair and combines in the thirty's were good-- but untell the IH-Case Rotary combine came out, Case combines did not sell well as most people did not like them. I find some of their other implements did not sell as well as other brands.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Its kind of comical to see all the arguements

03-23-2003 13:10:29




Report to Moderator
 Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to It was a very bad year and we were poor, 03-21-2003 16:30:19  
No one is ever going to win these discussions. They been going on for 80 years.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
kennyp

03-22-2003 13:11:13




Report to Moderator
 Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to It was a very bad year and we were poor, 03-21-2003 16:30:19  
Was going to stay out of this, I never have owned one of those thumpers. I think all the good engineers at JD were over in the garden tractor division. Please don't include my old, old, JD 140H3 garden tractor in the bad list. Yes, they later made some bad ones but the first, 110s 140s etc. were great tractors. Kohler engines. Would love to restore a Case garden tractor though.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
mj

03-22-2003 08:00:39




Report to Moderator
 Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to It was a very bad year and we were poor, 03-21-2003 16:30:19  
Ignorance, as they say, is bliss...and comes in a green and yellow box.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
will

03-21-2003 19:21:48




Report to Moderator
 Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to It was a very bad year and we were poor, 03-21-2003 16:30:19  
Just to let you know we are not all butt holes at the JD discussion board. This person may not even be a normal of the JD forum. He may be just wanting to stir up some you know what. I am sorry for this man's actions. Dont hold it against the rest of us at the JD board. Im not sure I agree with all of the comments about the 2cyls, but then again this is the case forum. I enjoy looking at all of the forums on this site, and I consider myself colorblind especially of old tractors.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Will

03-21-2003 19:14:49




Report to Moderator
 Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to It was a very bad year and we were poor, 03-21-2003 16:30:19  
If that rotary mower was his only exposure to Case I can understand his problem. That definitely was not one of Case's best implements. Too bad he did't have a tractor.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Gene Dotson

03-21-2003 20:25:05




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Will, 03-21-2003 19:14:49  
The John Deere probably shook so much that it shook the mower apart. I run threshing machines and sawmills with my Case LA and the operators love that smooth oil bath clutch and smooth operation on the belt. No belt slap here. I love this thread, just like our tractor club get-together. And we still remain friends...Gene



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-21-2003 16:57:59




Report to Moderator
 Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to It was a very bad year and we were poor, 03-21-2003 16:30:19  
I am unsorry to here about your hardship. I can also see the muffler was painted on the deere because you sniffed way to much green paint. When the flywheel falls off and takes out everything in its way it is doubtful there will be a case in the world that will have you. It's just a shame that deere had to buy a tractor company and was not nearly skilled enough to build there own. It is also just a shame that Uncle sam considered John deere way under powered and not nearly tough enough to handle a airdrop from 30,000 feet so they bought Case tractors and turned deere away like a dog turd on the bottom of there shoe. When you can come up with some good hard facts why your all mighty deere can out perform a case come back and let us know. Why your searching for answers you might want to go check to make sure your flywheel is tight and your battery box aint rusted out and you fall in front of your plow or go fix a patch around your poorly engineered exhaust through hood design or maybe you can go weld up your frame rails I am sure there are cracks.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Brandon

03-22-2003 21:06:16




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 16:57:59  
I'm a Deere fan, but I love our Case VAC too. I think it is pretty much pointless to do all this brand arguement, comparing problems. It just depends on what side of the fence you're on, whether certain problems were major or minor.

The VAC has been in the family since new. It has a cracked block (along with nearly every VAC I've seen around here in Ohio). A common problem, yes. Are all case blocks junk? No. It also has a broken cultivator mount (square hole passing below grill). Does this make the VAC a horrible cultivating tractor? No, because my grandpa hit a big rock cultivating corn one year way back when! After all this, I have to admit, the VAC is the most dependable "old" tractor we have. Probably because it is the only one that has had a decent tune up. My JD 80 has been pretty good so far!

My grandpa also used a 1938 D (industrial) for his plowing, etc for about 10 years beginning in the 1960's, plus driving it as a hired man for some years before than. It probably needs totally rebuilt, but I don't know the extent of how bad it is. Being used only 40 years (1938-1978) for hard work, boy it wore out fast! I'm just joking, it did recieve valve grindings, maybe some rings (I don't know all the details), but still, that's not too bad!

If these tractors could survive my grandpa, they had to be tough (believe me!). It just depends on who owns the tractor, and what maintenance they recieve.. JD flywheels won't come loose if you check them every XX hours. Case blocks won't crack if you keep antifreeze in them, correct?

Brandon
Our Tractors
My Industrial John Deere website
My JD model 80 website

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-23-2003 18:48:02




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Brandon, 03-22-2003 21:06:16  
I have yet to see a water cooled engine that would not crack with out some type of antifreeze. Having to maintain a flywheel on a Deere is dead wrong. I am not a engineer but could have came up with something. My flywheel stays nice and tight on my case tractors. To go for 35 years with a reacurring problem without repairing it is not the way to go. All Equipment does not get maintained like they are suppose to and never will. A loose flywheel can easily cause a bad crankshaft. That is a major defect in equipment and should have been repaired long before a taper lock kit had to be made.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Brandon

03-23-2003 21:58:24




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-23-2003 18:48:02  
I realize that any engine block will break if you let water freeze in it. I was trying to make a point that if you don't maintain equipment-change oil, add antifreeze, etc (at least every so often if not by the book) you will have problems--no matter the brand. One of the problems with SOME Deeres (mostly diesels it seems) are loose flywheels. And I don't have any proof, but I think the flywheel problems probably started occuring well after two cylinder production ended. Kinda late for a production change...

I'm sure Cases will have plenty of problems that will occur if you don't maintain them. Flywheels are just one of those things you should check on a Deere. Who cares that the Case flywheels stay tight--different designs have different quirks.

By the way I'd like to see some info on the airdropped Case tractor. What type was it? I'm not saying it was impossible, but I kinda doubt that they were actually parachuted down. And don't try to tell me they were just pushed out without a parachute! C-47s would be the only aircraft to use to airdrop (MAYBE C-46s, but you still have the same problems). Probably dropped from 10,000 feet max or WAY lower to be reasonably accurate. '47s had a service ceiling of only 24,000 feet by the way. '46s were only up to 27,000. AND just because they can go that high, it doesn't mean they will. You will burn alot of fuel getting up there. B-17s (bombers) for example had a service ceiling of 35000, but their missions were from 20-25000.

And there is the unpressurized fuselage-so it is almost certain that they would be below 10000 so the crew pushing something out would be conscious. Have you ever noticed in pictures of the troop or supply drops how low those planes really are?

The C-47s had a side door that would be a big pain to push something that big out the door. The most likely scenario is that the '47s landed, and then unloaded. Or maybe the tractors were hauled in CG-4 gliders. Again--land, then unload!

Brandon

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-24-2003 05:07:01




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Brandon, 03-23-2003 21:58:24  
I have 1944 and 1945 Case factory papers that talk about the clevis hooks for airdrop VAIWs. I have no pictures of them being dropped but I am sure they were test dropped and whether it was ever done in ww 2 I don't know. I do know that many companies submitted tractors to the military to try to win the contracts. The military then and still now test this equipment in harsh conditions for many things. John deere did not make it and the bold face reason case did was that they were built better to handle the harsh conditions. You deere folks need to stand back and take a good look at these two brands. Deere had more flaws and were not nearly engineered as well as case. You must remember that deere was using 1915 technoligy up till the 50s. there were no major leaps for deere till the new gen. after Case had introduced there new gen. version. You guys are on the case board trying to down grade a tractor that most of you know nothing about. The two cyl. is fun to listen to and would do the work needed on a farm, but a Case would do the same work and deere folks just seem to think the deeres were a tractor that was just so much better then any other tractor. The 2 cyl. was out dated by 1928 and how the deere company ever got away with marketing them I will never know. The sales departments at the dealers were 100 times better then the tractors they were selling. I also doubt that there were no problems in the 40s and 50s with loose flywheels.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
But where are you're facts, CASENOPOWER?

03-24-2003 16:16:43




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-24-2003 05:07:01  
Seems that our man Brandon has done his home work and thought things through. Your facts are going right down the same place where J.I. Case went years ago. Right down the crapper.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Brandon

03-24-2003 05:54:46




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-24-2003 05:07:01  
That's funny, I never said that Deeres were a better tractor, or that Case tractors were junk. I enjoy both brands, but as I said, I have a preferance for Deeres!

"You guys are on the case board trying to down grade a tractor that most of you know nothing about" Just because I own a Deere doesn't mean I'm allowed on this board? I know I haven't been downgrading Cases! We have a VAC and I don't hate it because it isn't green. I enjoy working with it. I like pretty much all the brands out there, even though every so often I joke about "off brand" tractors with friends. And I haven't even done that on this board.

Deere didn't do too bad with "1915 technology". Set fuel economy records for decades. Easier to work on (the clutch for example). Case tractors had good points too. You could name more than I, because you have more experience with them. Cases weren't perfect though. NO BRAND is perfect. And just because the VAIW was built to be airdropped, doesn't mean you could do it with a stock VA, no better than you could with a stock John Deere B.

Brandon

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-24-2003 08:49:57




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Brandon, 03-24-2003 05:54:46  
First I will guarantee a old D or C or S would hold up from a airdrop long before a B or A or G deere would. And a VA series is in the H JD class not a B class, but we won't get into the cam driven H. If you were not putting Case tractors down then the comment was not directed to you it was the fool that started this. I perfer Case not because of farming, but because I have studied both history and design of both and worked on and owned both and the Case which is well under rated is a tougher built tractor that will handle the abuse that I put on one when I pull. A Willys jeep could handle a airdrop and they were not overbuilt. I live beside Fort Bragg and Pope Airforce base and have been to the museum many times and seen pictures of LAI Case tractors pulling Pans building run ways in WW 2. I never said they airdropped them but they did get over there someway. The gliders you are talking about carried USTRAC crawlers that were 3,400 pounds. The cockpit raised and the crawler came out the front. They were also used for run way work. The clutch is easy to get to on a deere, but a wet clutch can last for the life of a tractor if used right. I know of a 1936 Case CC owned by RoyG that visits this board that has the original clutch. His dad bought the tractor new and worked it. Also Case had a small kit you could buy that was two pins were you could split the tractor and roll it apart with no jacks. They added special bosses in on the castings for the pins. You could also re-ring the engine without pulling the head or the oil pan on the C and D series. I have my reasons and there good ones why I perfer a Case over a Deere. I still have a couple deeres sitting around along with a Yakima tool bar and 3 bottom plow and a 2 bottom dic plow. The fuel records were nice, but if you check the gearing on first/second in the Deeres and the Case tractors of the same error you will see that getting 1 acre of land plowed for 2 cents of fuel in 1 hour with a deere. A case will do the 1 acre for 3 cents in 45 minutes. I know 1/2 mile per hour different is not much, but thats 20 miles more plowing in a 40 hour week. That is just something the Deere testers and engineers didn't share with the people. So I have ruled out the fuel records a long time ago.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Did you ever think of this CASENOPOWER?

03-24-2003 16:22:43




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-24-2003 08:49:57  
Cargo planes of that era had only personnel doors. The ramp doors came with the C-130s of the 50s. Your facts are very selective CASENOPOWER. You howdies will never get over the FACT that the only place your brand made it was in you pin heads.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Brandon

03-24-2003 15:21:54




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-24-2003 08:49:57  
That line about "I will guarantee a old D or C or S would hold up from a airdrop long before a B or A or G deere would" is just bull. Nobody is going to try it, and even if they did, probably every tractor dropped (Case OR Deere) would be in pretty bad condition when it made the sudden stop at the end.

I know about the USTRAC crawlers. They were designed to fit in the gliders and C-47s. But they weren't airdropped, I'd just like to make that clear.

I know the Jeeps were delivered in gliders, but again, I doubt an airdrop. I'll do some checking, you may be right about that one. According to a person I asked about the airdrop subject: "Only large drobable equipment in WWII was the M-8 pack howitzer. It was dropped in 9 bundles."

The fuel economy records for Deere diesels were proved by the Nebraska testing, and not just Deere advertisement. If I remember correctly, it is measured by Horsepower-hours a gallon or something like that. Not gallons burned to plow a field. I can't seem to find where I read the details in the pile of books in my room.

And I'll bring back the flywheel issue. I'm not an all knowing expert on the Deeres, and I haven't worked on every model there is, but the flywheel issues didn't really occur with the D, GP, A, B, G, etc. They occured mostly with the 70-720-730 diesels. Made from 1954-1960. That wasn't enough time for loose flywheels to show up for the factory to correct it. Maybe in your pulling adventures there were Gs etc with loose flywheels? What kind of overboring, stroking, and or High RPMs did these tractors go through? If they had factory engines, I doubt that loose flywheels would occur.

Here is another discussion board where I asked for opinions/facts on this subject. It is an aircraft modelling board, but full of military historians, etc. My message

Brandon

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Flambeau Red

03-28-2003 19:00:43




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Brandon, 03-24-2003 15:21:54  
If a 1/4 ton jeep can be airdropped, then I am sure a tractor of any color could be as well. My airborne unit used to place equipment on pallets with lots of honeycombed cardboard for the shock when the pallet hit the ground. If the cargo chute didn't open, you could hear it thump the ground! Predessors to the C-130 and the C-141 that had the tailgate, were the C7A Carribou and the C-123. I would bet that the military tractors of WWII vintage would likely have not have been taken by glider or plane. The gliders were used to get airborne forces, their weapons and equipment behind enemy lines. It is unlikely that the airborne units would need a tractor to assault the Germans! The US ARMY has a long history of testing airborne drops. They may have used a JD as a "Wind Dummy" to crash and burn on the drop zone. LOL I couldn't resist the jab as this is a Case discussion board!

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-24-2003 16:02:11




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Brandon, 03-24-2003 15:21:54  
First let me say that I don't know anything about air drops and what altitute anything was dropped from. To say they didn't for sure drop jeeps is dead wrong. They even have one hanging from it's harness from the ceiling of the museum. The first thing to go on the deere would be the pressed steel frame. There weak and are prone for cracks. There was a G on e-bay not long back that someone had attemted to weld the flywheel on. It was not a puller. I have tightend two different JD B flywheels because they started knocking away loose. Just as I said on the deeres you get less done for less gas. Drawbar HP was measured at the selected gear and not the selected speed. Deeres ran slower producing the same HP using less gas. Therefore got less work done in that HP Hour. They set records for running a hour on less fuel, but no one ever mentioned that they got less work done in that hour. Another thing, Did you see the B crawler in that one picture?? Thats only one that the Military refused. Next time I get to Bragg I will get you some pictures of some airdrops from ww-2. I can't say that the pictures was not test drops, but you would be surprized what all they did drop.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Brandon

03-24-2003 17:18:49




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-24-2003 16:02:11  
About airdropped jeeps, let me quote from the modelling discussion board I posted earlier:

"I've seen pics of the loading sequence into a 47. They drove the jeep up a ramp into the side door, then used 2x4s as levers to pry/turn the back end around to get it facing towards the nose so they could drive it in. This process had to be reversed on landing to get it out. There's no way they could have pried it back out the door while in flight - it would have taken WAY too long (you need to be pretty quick and accurate on those drops), not to mention the adverse effects the procedure would have had on the aircraft's balance (while flying!) AND the dangers of the jeep hitting the tail. As was said below, to air drop big stuff you need a tail ramp like on a C-130/C-141/C-5 so it can go straight out without risk of hitting anything."

There is a Jeep in that museum because they WERE used in gliders, lots of times.

If you can send pictures of airdrops, etc, from that museum I would enjoy them. I am a military history nut as well.

Yes, I saw that BO crawler picture. It is from my own website. If you'd like to see the page, go to:
Military Deeres You'll enjoy it. I don't really know why Deere's weren't used, the government had it reasons. You would say because they were obsolete.

I can't really comment about the plowing-acres per hour, etc. Not enough experience to argue.

And finally, Deeres didn't have pressed steel frames until AFTER WWII. They had cast iron frames during the war. Flywheels-if you check and or tighten them every so often, they WON'T come loose. It's called maintenance! Get that through your head!

If you want to post somemore that is fine. I'm enjoying this discussion. Learning is always good.

Enjoy your Cases, I'll enjoy my Deeres and Case. Maybe my Oliver too, if I ever reassemble it.

Brandon

P.S. Does anyone know if I'm using the right plural form of Case? For some reason Cases just doesn't look right to me. I've always hated grammar.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
will

03-24-2003 22:12:24




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Brandon, 03-24-2003 17:18:49  
Just to clarify some things for both of you. Fuel economy was tesed at Nebraska on the belt pulley, and on the drawbar. They were tested horsepower hour per gallon of fuel. A horsepower is a horsepower. I wont get into which is better, but I do disagree with the same horsepower case will do more than the deere. If anything the Deere will do more, because it has the torque advantage from the long stroke, which was not included in the tractor specs at that time, which I agree is unfair to the other tractor companies. The flywheel situation is sort of like Brandon says. Mostly the only ones that have problems are tractors that are built, and diesels. This is due to the uneveness of the 2cyl. I personally have never had a flywheel problem, or have I ever seen one personally, only heard of them. If you will check most of the time it is due to the fact that the flywheel has been off, and not retightened after a few hours of use. We dont complain about retightening lugnuts after a few miles. We do it because we dont want the wheel to fall off. The same with the flywheels. When people didnt retighten them they fell off. That is what we call operator error. For the press steel frame. Deere only used it from 47-52. They realized their problem, and fixed it. Can we hold that against them. They were good tactors minus the frame. I can say that my B has a pressed steel frame with no cracks or breaks. Again if you will check most of the tractors with cracked frames had a loader attached on them at some point and time. People thought if it would pick it up it was OK to drive accross the ruts with it hung up in the air. I would dare to say that most JD problems are due to neglect or abuse. Most of the Cases you listed were big bulky standard tractors that would never have seen a loader, so It is not really a good comparison. It is like I said below. I have nothing against cases. I know you cant stand that, because it ruins your arguing, but I would like to have a VAC Case. I still fail to see how you can say that product has nothing to do with JD staying in business. If their tractors were junk they could not have sold them, and they sold them for more money than any other product on the market at the time. I gurantee you people questioned why not to buy a case or Farmall. Farmers are among the tightest people I know of. They will get the most for their money. It was because they felt JD was a better tractor. In the late 50s and 60s many people swithed from various brands to JD because they felt it was simply a better tractor even though the cost was quite a bit more. As for why the military didnt use JD. The anwser is simple. They get the cheapest machine that will complete the job. I had the fun of running an army truck. Guess what it had a straight seat with no spings at all in it. The truck had no synchronizers at all in any gear, and a multifuel engine that would not pull steam off a hot fart. It was a blast to shift. The army is not interested in the best machine. They are interested in the cheapest machine that will get the job done. I know that some planes, and tanks have lots of fancy equipment, but I will promise that it is the cheapest that will get the job done. Until recentley all of the small army vechicles had chevrolet diesels in them. I may offend someone here, but Chevrolet diesels are by far not the best when you have names like Cummins, perkins,navistar, mercedes, detroit, etc. They were just the cheapest that would complete the job. There may have been lots of better tractors on the market, but case was the company that gave them the cheapest bid on a piece of equipment that the army thought would complete the job. So the moral to this story is that because the army chose case is not because it is the best, but the cheapest useable equipment that it could find. The army is not interested on long life. after an allotted time everything is replaced anyway. I would never say that one brand of tractors is better than another, but I do disapprove of the arrogance of some owners to admit their favorite brands faults. I am like Brandon I would like to continue the conversation. If I didnt clarify everything for you in this reply.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASENOPOWER

03-22-2003 19:07:00




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 16:57:59  
You really ought to put some of that crap you're spewing to music, It would make great song.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-22-2003 19:18:50




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASENOPOWER, 03-22-2003 19:07:00  
I can see you come with no facts or nothing to go against any of the facts I stated about deere. I know my Case history and quite a bit of Deere history. You come with nothing?? I can sell you some good books if you can read!!!



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
JD-Tractor in NY

03-21-2003 19:24:13




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 16:57:59  
Give me a break !Case wouldn't even be around anymore if they hadn't thrown in with harvester you guys and your chicken roost steering and your 2 head 4 cylinder engines that you couldn't keep a head gsaket on and even then at one time David Brown had to rescue you !! and as far as dropping case tractor,s out of planes the pilots got lost and missed the ocean where they were looking to use them as anchors !!!! There are a lot of dead Cases in this neck of the woods.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John Saeli

03-22-2003 17:27:18




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to JD-Tractor in NY, 03-21-2003 19:24:13  
Hey JD in NY, You don't know what you are talking about. No trouble with head gaskets on this CASE farm. Let me know where all these CASE's in the woods are. I want to buy them.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Gene Dotson

03-21-2003 20:08:25




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to JD-Tractor in NY, 03-21-2003 19:24:13  
In 1955 John Deere almost became a part of J.I. Case Company. The Case board of directors voted whether to accept John Deere as a division of J.I. Case. The vote was 1 vote short of rescuing the poor 2 cylinder tractors... Gene (Gotta put my dog in this fight. Grin)



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Gene Dotson

03-22-2003 02:21:46




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Gene Dotson, 03-21-2003 20:08:25  
I have to apologize for the mistake I made on this post. In my enthusiasn, I mistakenly stated that the Case board voted on buying John Deere, when it was actually International Harvester baord that turned down the purchase. The end result today would be the same...Gene



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-21-2003 19:33:40




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to JD-Tractor in NY, 03-21-2003 19:24:13  
Again a totally non factial post. Taper lock fly wheel kits, repair panels for the hoods. Rusted out battery boxes under the seats, cracked frame rails on the pressed steel 2 cylinders. Unsteady bearing beating belt power. Theres some facts. I am a antique tractor man and can't tell you nothing about the 1955 up case tractors. You give me some design flaws of the early case tractors and I will listen. And don't start the chicken roost crap. That was a fine system that kept the chickens from crapping on the hoods. So give me some facts or you can bolt your trap also..

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Jim P

03-22-2003 22:19:18




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 19:33:40  
The closes LA flaw was in the adjustment of tightening the fan belt. I always had trouble because dirt would get in the groves and even pounding on the adjustment bar on the pulley wouldn't budge it. I finally made a idler pulley adjustment for it. The L on the other hand when they came with the conversion to V belt had a adjustment on the fan pully that never gave any trouble and was always easy to adjust.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-23-2003 18:40:49




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Jim P, 03-22-2003 22:19:18  
If thats the only flaw you can come up with then there pretty near perfect are they not?? I know the flaws. I know the engineer changes because of flaws. I won't list any because it would be used against me later, but I will say there were less flaws on the Case tractors that were all repaired eventualy than there were deere flaws that were never fixed.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Be careful Jim. You're dealing With Mr. CASENOPOWER

03-23-2003 06:37:31




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Jim P, 03-22-2003 22:19:18  
And he goes stricly by the facts, where ever he comes up with facts that happens to agree with what he's preachin.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-23-2003 18:35:37




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Be careful Jim. You're dealing With Mr. CASENOPOWER, 03-23-2003 06:37:31  
If you knew any facts you would also use them to your advantage, but theres the problem you have no facts..



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Jim P

03-23-2003 21:32:00




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-23-2003 18:35:37  
My facts a lot of time is from memory and you know what memory is to a 68 yr. old farmer. The facts I know is that my 29 L was in the first run of L's made. My 1966 930 Ck was made in the last yr. six speed, chain drive, oil clutch case tractors made. now my opinion.. I believe the oil clutch, chain drive tractors by case were the best tractors ever made.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-24-2003 05:11:00




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Jim P, 03-23-2003 21:32:00  
Ah, a man listing facts. I also agree. They made them oil clutch and chain drive from 1929 when (in my and most engineers opinions) John deeres were long out dated. How would you compair your 1929 Case L to a 1929 John Deere D ???



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Jim P

03-24-2003 22:03:20




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-24-2003 05:11:00  
My grandpa bought the L new but my dad was the operator. Dad told me this(my) 1929L was the best salesman Case had in our county. Many and I mean many farmers got rid of there JD D's and IH and especialy Twin Cities(M&M). and bought L's, by the time the LA's came along there was a waiting list. And throughout the war years when tractors were impossible to buy from dealers the black market was kept busy selling L's and LA's.They were better then the energizer Bunny. they really just kept going and going. I never seen one with a bad clutch (others all had to replace clutches about ever other year).Dad did put a new clutch in when the tractor was ten years old, but he always said it really didn't need replacing and the trans. has never been worked on. On this L engine it still has the original crank. Dad ,used to re-sleeve it every other year and did it for $36 . This L has never been back to a dealer or dealer shop since new. My Dad did all the work it ever needed himself. It was the easist starting tractor in the world. Dad always bragged(no just fact) Two pulls choke, and it started on the third.rarley flooded it and had to spin it. it still has the orginal Kingston Carb. . My 1966 930CK six speed has 8,000+ hrs and has had the clutch adj. only once. and the Trans. has never been opened. I rung and valved it at 2800 hrs. and cleaned the inj. and ck'ed the pump and have done nothing but change filters since and it still runs like a top.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
JD-Tractor in NY

03-21-2003 19:42:43




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 19:33:40  
Jeeze Casepower !!Are you ever a radical are you sure you wern't dropped from a plane and hit your head? I peacefully come over to the other side to sp I mean to see what is happening and I find you denigating those fine John Deeres that stayed home to feed the masses while case went gallevanting all over the world. Did you like that big word ?



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-21-2003 20:09:40




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to JD-Tractor in NY, 03-21-2003 19:42:43  
I'm use to the Bashing board. We do this every day so it just comes natural. Just because Case built 15,000 tractors for uncle sam don't mean there were not still case tractors here working. Case was farming with gas tractors in 1911. Built there first gas tractor in 1892 and was running steam tractors before that. So were was deere up till 1919 when they bought there tractor?? I heard the Deere engineers are still trying to figure out how to make a steamer and hope to be finished by 2020. Did you know case built a 2 cylinder before waterloo boy did?? I bet they copied it from Case. Case was smart enough to know when to update. and left the deeres with the boat anchor.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
I can see them now Rambo

03-21-2003 17:32:15




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 16:57:59  
We're riding our mighty VAC through the Battle of the Bulge and we come under enemy fire being on a Case, our first reaction is to retreat and crap in our pants but alas, we get word from HQ that Case hase bee aquired by Studebaker and we have to change the the lettering on the Hood. And BTW Eisenhower, I greatly doubt that they dropped advanced weaponry such as Case tractors from 30,000 feet we're talking C-47s here unless, and I can hear it now, Case's Aircraft Division built a high altitude plane and Chuck Yeager was the Chief test pilot. You twerps or so easy.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-21-2003 17:56:16




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to I can see them now Rambo, 03-21-2003 17:32:15  
Like I said. Come up with some facts and we will talk. So far you have given nothing. Impress me!! Lets hear it!! I don't know how far up they dropped them, but I do know they held up when the deeres couldn't. It will always be that way and thats a fact. Lets see you run your 2 misser at 5000 rpms. Case did it with the DE power units for the military. They ran all day long like that. If you can't come up with anything I do understand because you have nothing to come up with. You go get on your parade deere and we will keep our Case tractors were they belong. In the fields and on the pulling track. How about we talk about go old heritage?? Tell us all about deere. They couldn't build a steam engine or a threasher. How can you even call deere a full line company?? Case built everything deere did and more and always built it better. Come on lets hear some facts?? If not bolt up yout trap because it stinks..

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
SAM

03-22-2003 10:31:51




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 17:56:16  
I think both of you must be mistaken, because Allis Chalmers will take either of your Cases or Deeres in the field or on the track at any given time.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
will

03-21-2003 19:38:09




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 17:56:16  
Im not sure what you are trying to prove with the 5000 RPM thing. Deere didnt design their engines to run 5000 RPM. By running at a low RMP they could get the maximum amout of torque while using the least amount of fuel, while minimizing the amount of wear to engine components. Less turns means less wear. I know you most likley dont care, but JD started setting world fuel records in the early fifties. The fuel record set by the 720 JD diesel in 1956 was not surpassed until 1984. I would say this was quite an accomplishment. Not trying to be smart, but I dont think case had any such accomplishments. Like I said above in my reply to the original message; I am color blind especially when it comes to old trctors. I find the VAC Case rather appealing. You stated that you have had bad experiece with JD 2cyl. I would be interested to know what the bad experiences were. I know you were interested to get facts from the original poster of this message, but it appears that he is only interested in causing a problem, so I thought I would reply with some positive info.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-21-2003 19:58:01




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to will, 03-21-2003 19:38:09  
Ah some facts.. do you realise the longer the stroke the faster the piston speed and more piston travel?? The faster the piston speed the more the travel the more heat and wear on the cylinder. I have torn down many deeres and they do wear the walls worse then Case tractors. I have owned and pulled deeres and the only bad experiance I can say I have had is there slow, and are underpowered. You use lower gears to make up for lower torque. Thats what they do gear them down. My point with the 5000 rpm is. "How well built is your tractor??" Will it handle the abuse?? A deere won't. For anyone to say a deere engine will out last a Case engine is totally wrong. The deere engine was out dated in 1928 and should have been updated. If your a 1940 farmer and you need that extra power and you have a D your screwed.. If you have a old L or LA you turn the RPMs up by a couple hundred or more and your ready to weigh up for the extra bottom. You ask a kid who invented the tractor and most will tell you John deere. Why?? Because there over rated and way over priced. Yes the resale is good, but I'm buying so I'm screwed if I'm a deere man. just because Deere is still in buisness means nothing.. You want a well built old tractor that you can work, abuse, and pull you buy a Case or a Moline. I don't like Molines, but I will admit they are built tough like a Case. John deere and Farmall are both known for tranny problems. I have yet to see a bad tranny in a RC, D, DC, S, SC, L, or LA. I have heard of a chain breaking but have yet to see it. I own and operate a tractor salvage and have seen just about all of the screw ups that a tractor can have and they are not on the case tractors. To say a John deere don't wear parts is just plane wrong. And I can re-ring a case D or c faster then you can pull a deere down for the re ring job..

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
will

03-21-2003 21:10:19




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 19:58:01  
Well, I would like to think that my tractor will handle the abuse. I have a late model B and a 730 diesel of your much hated brand. I know the history of the B. The motor has never been touched except for valve adjustment. The head has never been off the tractor. The bearings, rings, etc have never been touched. The only thing that has been replaced internally was the rear axle seals. They were simply rotten from old age allowing oil seepage onto the wheels. The tractor was used for heavy work in its early life, as it was the only tractor for a hundred acres of row crop. My grandfather bought it from our neighbor, the original owner in the late 70s. We plowed 15 acres of tobacco, and raked hay with it every year until 1995 when we got out of the tobacco business. I know that the last years of work were not very strenuous, but it is still rather impressive for a 52 year old tractor to have never been bothered internally. My 730 is maybe not quite as good as my B , but I would still say that it will stand the abuse. I had to put a head gasket on my 730 when I purchased it. It was due to the fact that whomever (some sap) put the replacement on before I got the tractor didnt torque the head bolts at all. I took them off with a short half inch drive ratchet. They were supposed to be torqued to 275 ftlbs. While I had the head off I checked the bore. The amazing thing was that it is still factory. This tractor has been well used. To help you understand the amount of use of this tractor the steering busings in the dash were completley gone, and I had to have the steering shaft built up, and turned back down before the new bushings would work. The clutch handle is going to have to be built up ,and the bushing replaced. I could plant potatoes in the grooves of the clutch pulley. Yes the engine did have some ring groove in it, but it is still factory bore. I cant say if the trans and rear end have been touched. I dont know. I dont know how many hours are on it due to the fact that it has a replacement tac. The 58 horses of this 2cyl will pull as much as my 94 horse 4020. It wont pull it as fast, but it will pull it. I would put it up beside any other 58 horsepower tractor of its time for stock pulling power. The horsepower ratings of these tractors were not fair to all of the other tractor companies due to the large amounts of torque. This torque is due to the long stroke that you say is a downfall of the 2cyls. In my post above I didnt say that Deere doesnt wear parts. That would be a rather silly statement. I said that they minimized the wear by running the engine at a rather low RPM. Less turns means less wear. For statement about the ring job maybe you can do a ring job on you case faster than I can tear down my JD. If it is like I said about my B I wont be doing a ring job, and I sure wont be in the shop while you are putting rod and main bearings in your fast running engines. Rod and main bearing replacement is almost unheard of in 2cyl deeres. I would still be interested to know some of your personal problems with John Deeres that is fault of the tractor itself. Im looking for things that would not be regular maintenance of any other brand of tractors. Last of all I dont quite see how you can say that deere still being in business means nothing. When folks get a bad product they dont go back for more, or so I hope. Deere usually has a pretty good product, but just like everyother company they have made, and still make junk too. Thru all this I never said that Cases were bad tractors. The vintage cases were very competitive, so you dont have to defend your old cases. I like old cases, as I mentioned above I would like a VAC. I just thought that perhaps you didnt give JD the respect it deserved.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-21-2003 22:07:01




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to will, 03-21-2003 21:10:19  
1950 John Deere R straight off the farm it was used on from new. Never worked real hard. Cylinders warn out bad. Head cracked from valve to injector hole. Flywheel cracked for some strange unknown reason. Numerous John deere Bs with bad transmissions from jumping out of gear to gears just plane gone. Late As and Bs with cracked pressed steel frames. Push rod tubes leaking. Early As and Bs with the high/low trannys jumping out. I don't actually have a problem with Deere as a tractor. I know of the Case problems and most were corrected by updates. I have a problem with the arrogance of the owners. Not putting you in that class because I can see that you are not the type I am talking about. The ones that think Deere invented the world and was the first to invent everything that was ever available on a tractor is the ones I have a problem with. Most all of the deere folks that talk trash about Case have never owned one and usually the deere they have was the one that daddy gave them or past along and was always brain washed that deere was the one and only. I have seen as many deeres with bad bearings as case also. Deere was also known for egg shape wearing in the cylinders because of the lay down position. I stretch my case to its limits. I pull super class at 2500 RPM and am very hard on my tractor doing things with it that it was not designed for. A deere will not handle it. I just want Case to get the respect they deserve. You can say that is what you want for deere, but remember your on the Case board and this was not started by me. I respect the deere enough not to go to there board and start crap. If they want bashing they need to come to the bashing board were we are aloud to speak like free americans and I will be sure and let them know what I think. I can guarantee that Case didn't have as many design flaws as Deere. The problem is deere didn't update and fix the little problems. Just like the nose cone on the styled deere were the crack from the bolt hole to the edge or the poor exhaust design or instead of putting in the owners manual to check the flywheel tightness why not fix the problem to start with?? Instead they just kept using it. I will also say again the fact that deere is still in buisness means nothing. I couldn't afford a new tractor if I wanted one. Can you buy a new JD A at the dealer or a new G?? If case were still in buisness could I buy a new DC?? So It just don't matter to me one way or the other..

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
L.Lamp

03-21-2003 18:26:47




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 17:56:16  
Don't be too hard on this guy CASEPOWER those deere guys probably can't read and we all know they couldn't count to more than two till in the 60's. They probably had Maytag engines on their washing machines too because they couldn't stand anything that ran smooth!



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
CASEPOWER

03-21-2003 18:39:14




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to L.Lamp, 03-21-2003 18:26:47  
I do get a little carried away, but I would bet that he has never owned a Case tractor. I have owned a pulled deeres so I do have knowledge of there down falls all 10,000 of them. I won't claim to know about the 1960 up deeres but when it comes to compairing the 2 cylinders to a Case tractor all I can say is he digging a deep hole and it's fixin to cave in on him.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Terry Nelson

03-23-2003 20:39:32




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 18:39:14  
CASEPOWER, I'm impressed with your grit and your knowledge! Don't understand why guys will jump on some other tractor's board and start a fuss. But, there isn't any reason to let that stuff go unchallenged, either. Good on 'ya!



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
You Pixies do it all the time

03-24-2003 17:18:50




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to Terry Nelson, 03-23-2003 20:39:32  
nt



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Joel

03-21-2003 18:19:04




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re: Re: Re: Real Sad Story with a happy ending in reply to CASEPOWER, 03-21-2003 17:56:16  
You tell em' CASEPOWER!!!



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
[Options]  [Printer Friendly]  [Posting Help]  [Return to Forum]   [Log in to Reply]

Hop to:


TRACTOR PARTS TRACTOR MANUALS
We sell tractor parts!  We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today. [ About Us ]

Home  |  Forums


Copyright © 1997-2023 Yesterday's Tractor Co.

All Rights Reserved. Reproduction of any part of this website, including design and content, without written permission is strictly prohibited. Trade Marks and Trade Names contained and used in this Website are those of others, and are used in this Website in a descriptive sense to refer to the products of others. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy

TRADEMARK DISCLAIMER: Tradenames and Trademarks referred to within Yesterday's Tractor Co. products and within the Yesterday's Tractor Co. websites are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Yesterday's Tractor Co., our products, or our website nor are we sponsored by them. John Deere and its logos are the registered trademarks of the John Deere Corporation. Agco, Agco Allis, White, Massey Ferguson and their logos are the registered trademarks of AGCO Corporation. Case, Case-IH, Farmall, International Harvester, New Holland and their logos are registered trademarks of CNH Global N.V.

Yesterday's Tractors - Antique Tractor Headquarters

Website Accessibility Policy