Welcome! Please use the navigational links to explore our website.
PartsASAP LogoCompany Logo (800) 853-2651

Shop Now

   Allis Chalmers Case Farmall IH Ford 8N,9N,2N Ford
   Ferguson John Deere Massey Ferguson Minn. Moline Oliver

Attention Forum Users: On the 28th of December 2023 at 9:00am Central Time, we will be taking the forums down for maintenance while we prepare the new forums for your use. Please click here for more information.

Allis Chalmers Discussion Forum
:

Re-Re-Re-visited 6V vs 12V coils

Welcome Guest, Log in or Register
Author 
Texas Denny

10-16-2005 06:36:29




Report to Moderator

There are a couple of points that I tried to make in the past that I probably said poorly. So, if you�ll indulge me, I�d like to try again.

Since, it had been a while since I studied internal combustion engines, I found my textbook on the subject. It was written by A. R. Rogowski and is titled �Elements of Internal Combustion Engines.�

The initial question was �Would a ballast resistor and a 6 volt coil perform equivalently to a newer 12 volt coil without an external resistor?� My contention was that there would be no difference. Some agreed and some took exception. In my arguments, I stated the plug voltage wrong when I confused plug voltage with insulation resistance for wire. Doug in OR correctly stated that the voltage was 4000 to 5000 volts (after I had incorrectly said it was 20000). I am impressed, Doug. According to the textbook, the voltage required to produce a spark and ignition varies from slightly over 3000 volts up to slightly less than 4500 volts. The variation is related to the fuel-air ratio and it is a non linear relationship. When the fuel-air ration is leanest (less than 0.055), the voltage requirement is highest at approximately 4600 volts. When the fuel air ratio is less than 0.05, no spark of any magnitude will cause an explosion � some burning but no explosion. Without proving it (too complicated for this venue), the ideal ratio is approximately 0.1 which corresponds to the minimum required voltage of approximately 3200. Continued increase in the ratio will cause an increase in the voltage requirement (up to 3450). At slightly less than 0.13 fuel to air, the mixture is too rich to permit an explosion. We usually call this situation flooding.

Compression ratio also affects the voltage requirement and spark. The higher the ratio, the smaller the required spark and voltage.

According to the book, the volume of the spark has an impact on successful spark. The ignition designers avoided simply going to higher voltages because of the problems (and expense) created by the higher voltages. Higher voltages meant that spark plug insulators had to be designed to handle this voltage. Plug life was already bad and higher voltages shortened the life even more. The plug wires had to be improved and the distributor cap would need to be better. I would like to quote the last sentence of the section on �Requirements for Ignition�. It says �Any increase in spark intensity over that required for regular firing will have no effect whatever on engine performance.� The designers did not change the system. They simply reduced cost.

As you raise the voltage in the coil, you will also raise the current that jumps the gap. If you could control the level of current and raise the voltage, this would be beneficial as it would increase the reliability of the spark. However, if you do not hold the level of the current, the impact on the system will be burning the electrode on the end of the plug and eroding the tip causing premature plug failure without an improvement in performance. Think about your Lincoln Welder and the current used to melt the welding rod.

Electronic ignition�s contribution was the increase of the voltage without the current increase. This higher voltage increased reliability of the spark. The increased voltage also permitted the gap to be increased which would proportionately increase the number of molecules of appropriate fuel air mixture that came in contact with the spark. And therefore spark reliability would again be improved.

In 1962 when I first became interested in IC engines, spark plugs had to be replaced every 10,000 miles. Today�s electronic ignitions have increased the effectiveness of the spark while reducing the current and now plugs can be used 100,000 miles or more. In fact, I believe many drivers never change them as long as they own their vehicles.

To be redundant, the two systems are equivalent.

[Log in to Reply]   [No Email]
souNdguy

10-18-2005 08:34:50




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re-Re-Re-visited 6V vs 12V coils in reply to Texas Denny, 10-16-2005 06:36:29  
My point of contention is that if there is wear in the system.. the true 12v coil will continue to provide top performance where the 6v coil may cause a lower voltage spark due to losses and resistance increases on the primary wireing side due to old / dirty connections.. The more votlage dropped there.. the less that is used for making the spark. In effect.. the true 12v coil has a wider margin for error when it comes to this.( more reliable) And if you have a 12v system.. why not take advantage of it. ( probably could expirement with run a wider gap too.).

As for spark plug life... I don't see that as a huge issue. Most of us with old tractors are replacing them every year during tune up.. or when they oil foul.. Probably more old tractors oil fouling plugs than having the electrodes burnt down beyond use...

Soundguy

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Texas Denny

10-18-2005 14:28:02




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re-Re-Re-visited 6V vs 12V coils in reply to souNdguy, 10-18-2005 08:34:50  
I agree with you that wear or increased resistance has a greater impact on a 6 volt system than it does on a 12 volt system.



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
souNdguy

10-19-2005 04:33:40




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re-Re-Re-visited 6V vs 12V coils in reply to Texas Denny, 10-18-2005 14:28:02  
That's pretty much my whole issue... more 'margin' when it comes to wear and tear. Looking at how many farmers 'maintain' their equipment.. (minimally) the extra margin might come in handy.. Half the tractors I'v bought have had 40-60 year old wire harnesses intact.. some with original coils, and barely any or no spark. Simply a lack of maintenance.

As you and the others pointed out.. a properly maintained 6v system should perform similar to the 12v system, using same plug gaps and all other variables being the same... etc 12v system jumps ahead when age, corrosion, and other impacts on spark come into play.

Soundguy

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John T

10-16-2005 20:51:29




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re-Re-Re-visited 6V vs 12V coils in reply to Texas Denny, 10-16-2005 06:36:29  
Great article Denny, thanks for finding n posting it. Now ya got me curious to dig out the one I have somewhere?? Geeeee e this is almost getting to be work lol but its funnnnn work for me at least. Sorry if we bore others, we can take this good discussion to e mail if need be?

Ive just read it quickly and already agreed with it about the advantages of a solid state switch to provide a faster and more positive current interruption versus the bouncing ringing mechanical contact points. Better switching improves the inductive transfer cuz as we well know ther is NOOOOO O transformer action at DC. (need the di/dt you spoke of) An elec switch would make even the stock coil function more efficient (less heat and more electrical transfer) but couple them with the newer high energy high efficient coils (better magnetic materials etc) and then run that wider plug gap (those coils are capable of ramping to higher voltaes) and performance gets even better.....

I didnt see too much about what I still dont know about some older 12 volt coils having a pure non inductive resistor in the top portion. Im almost positive (I think Duane Larson spoke of that over on JD board a good while back) some older ones had like a ring about an inch down where I been told?? there was an internal ballast, but am quite confident the later ones either used more wire (more turns and/or inductance/henrys) or just wire with higher resistance???

So where are we now lol. I think??? we all agreed on these things:::::::

They still run 4 amps REGARDLESS if a 6 or 12 volt coil,,,,, ,,an autotransformer (the coil) inductor is a "current device" and its the current interrupted NOT the voltage that does the work and matters,,,,, ,,,and the firing voltage remains the same (its a function of the plugs gap n compression),,,,, ,,,,,and the article makes sense too much plug gap curent isnt good (burns plugs),,,,, I AGREED AT LEAST IFFFFF F the 12 had a pure internal ballast INSTEAD OF more windings or inductance,,,,,the the 2 coils are equivalent BUT I DID NOT AND STILL DONT AGREE they are equivalent if the 12 has more windings or inductance, as I think if so there may a more efficient transfer and more energy transferred to the seconday VERSUS wasting the energy as pure heat.

STILL UNKNOWNS What are the inductance in henrys of the primary windings in comparable 6 or 12 volt coils????? ?? Does a 12 volt have more wire or turns or the same as a 6 but higher resistance wire???

I guess my intuition still keeps me believing the 12 volt (if NOT one with a top pure resistor, i.e. more turns and/or inductance) is still more efficient and wastes less energy on heat as oposed to transfering it the seconday VERSUS a 6 volt??? True, the article talks like once theres sufficient spark to ignite the fuel, thers no more needed, but I dont see it saying the 12 volt coil "may not be capable of" providing maybe MORE energy (would be manifested as more arc current since voltage is the same) which might?? better initiate the combustion UNTIL we get to the point of too much and wasted current to prematurely burn up the plugs???

I still believe the ballast to be older technology and it gives me "heartburn" lol as I know its by product is pure heat versus the by product of inductance which leads to mutual inductance and energy transfer from primary to secondary and the plug where it can ignite the fuel VERSUS transfer heat to the surroundings.

Im NOT from Missouri but still stibborn lol I guess the only way to ever know the answer is to have sophisticated equipment to accurately measure the energy (volts x amps x time) across a plug gap when using a 6 volt with external ballasted coil versus a 12 volt NON ballasted coil. I stilllll ll would bet the 12 volt causes MORE energy to discharge at the plug gap !!!! We know darn sure the 6 with an external ballast expends considerable heat energy across itself!!

Isnt Bob gonna do that for us????? ?????

Thanks again Denny, loveeeee ee this stuff I apologize to others who dont like it as much and discussing it like we do, if Kim pulls it we will take it to e mail lol

G Night all n God Bless yall n the good ol USA

If I dig out the article on Kettering Ignition I will try n post it too

John T

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Texas Denny

10-17-2005 06:58:06




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re-Re-Re-visited 6V vs 12V coils in reply to John T, 10-16-2005 20:51:29  
Dyno is the answer. Connect a tractor to the dyno and swap out coils. See if it makes a difference. The book is based on laboratory tests with a dyno. I've no reason to doubt their experimental procedure. Anyone who might may feel obliged to prove them right or wrong with similar tests. I think it would have to be a dyno test as no field test can have all the variables controlled. The dyno would have to be proved to be consistant before the actual test were run. The test for accuracy may show that each test must be repaeated 5 or ten times to get consistancy.

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John T

10-17-2005 07:50:12




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re-Re-Re-visited 6V vs 12V coils in reply to Texas Denny, 10-17-2005 06:58:06  
WE agreeeee eee on this at least, lets get Bob or SoundGuy to do it??? We can make side bets !!!

Take care Denny, youre startin to sway me, by the way, I just answered a question over on Farmall board kind of opposite of this, a dealer told a guy he could use a 12 volt coil on a 6 volt tractor cuz it would function that way or something??? Wanna go over there n cornfuse em all lol

John T

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
Nebraska Cowman

10-17-2005 10:39:57




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re-Re-Re-visited 6V vs 12V coils in reply to John T, 10-17-2005 07:50:12  
but the question i have John is, Isn't a 12 v coil realy just a 6 v coil with the resistor already built in?



[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
John T

10-17-2005 11:53:26




Report to Moderator
 Re: Re-Re-Re-visited 6V vs 12V coils in reply to Nebraska Cowman, 10-17-2005 10:39:57  
Hmmmmm mmmmm good question Nebraska. You know actually, a Dyno test as Denny proposed with both a 6 volt coil plus ballast and a 12 sittin there ready to hook up wouldnt be that hard to do at all. And we can all place our side bets on most HP. Then we can have the fresh baked humble pie the loser has to eat. Of course, I want a Pertronix Flame Thrower coil when I run my 12 volt coil test but Denny has to use a 50 year old leaky rusty 6 volt coil and a half shot ballast when he does his????? ?? That sound fair Denny????

Yall buhave now

John T

[Log in to Reply]  [No Email]
[Options]  [Printer Friendly]  [Posting Help]  [Return to Forum]   [Log in to Reply]

Hop to:


TRACTOR PARTS TRACTOR MANUALS
We sell tractor parts!  We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today. [ About Us ]

Home  |  Forums


Copyright © 1997-2023 Yesterday's Tractor Co.

All Rights Reserved. Reproduction of any part of this website, including design and content, without written permission is strictly prohibited. Trade Marks and Trade Names contained and used in this Website are those of others, and are used in this Website in a descriptive sense to refer to the products of others. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy

TRADEMARK DISCLAIMER: Tradenames and Trademarks referred to within Yesterday's Tractor Co. products and within the Yesterday's Tractor Co. websites are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Yesterday's Tractor Co., our products, or our website nor are we sponsored by them. John Deere and its logos are the registered trademarks of the John Deere Corporation. Agco, Agco Allis, White, Massey Ferguson and their logos are the registered trademarks of AGCO Corporation. Case, Case-IH, Farmall, International Harvester, New Holland and their logos are registered trademarks of CNH Global N.V.

Yesterday's Tractors - Antique Tractor Headquarters

Website Accessibility Policy