Here's one for the N experts

Welding man

Well-known Member
Location
West Virginia
Customer and a friend, brought me a 1949 8n front mount dist tractor a while back and
and asked me to get it running, said it had been in his family every since new,was a
very low hours tractor that had been sitting a long time but they could not get it
started.He really did't want to spend a lot of money on it, but would like to see it
running again. It had been converted to 12 V. We checked all the usual stuff,got fire,
rebuilt carb. We got it started and it had NO oil pressure. We removed the relief valve
pumped it full of 90 Wt. and started it again. No oil pressure. Finally decided to pull
the pan to see if pick-up tube was broken. Every thing looked good.Pulled oil
pump,disassembled it. Looked new. Pulled main caps. Could tell they had been dry but no
damage. Saw a little rust in a couple of the cylinders. Pulled head, knocked pistons
out, no ring groove. Miced crank. Good condition.Everything in the engine was 100%
original Ford. Ordered a set of rings ,rod and main bearings and oil pump kit. Honed
block, rebuilt the oil pump( remembering I have all the Ford tools to do this little
job),definitely not the first one I ever did either. Plasti-guaged everything and put
her back together. Filled her up with 30 wt and started her up. Guess what NO oil
pressure. Shut it down. Did the old primer trick fired her up and horray 20 Lbs of oil
pressure. A measley 20 pounds. Changed the gauge and still 20 pounds. Changed the relief
valve and spring,18 lbs. Shut her off and let it set for half hour lunch break and fired
her up, No oil pressure. Primed the pump again and 20 pounds again. If the tractor sits
for over 30 minutes it looses it's prime.We have pressure checked the suction tube. The
pan is back off the oil pump is disassembled again and I don't know what the next move
really is other than dig a hole and bury the sucker. I have way more time and parts in
this thing than I ever charge for but I hate to give up. We have rebuilt 4 tractor
engines in the last month and this one has caused more problems than all the rest put
together. Anyone else ever had a similar problem?
 

Pump can not pump if can not suck,,, Check the suction side of the pump Nuttin to it you don't even have to take the oil pan off...
A good pump will draw a vacuum as soon as it starts to turn anywhere from 5" to 15 in , 5 being low and 15 optimal...

Quit putting the cart in front of the horse and think about it.
 
No, I haven't and I'm probably not going to say anything that LB doesn't already know, but..........
It seems to me, that to loose prime, the oil has to drain back, thus allowing air in & in that pump inlet/outlet configuration, those places seem limited to pump gear/housing clearances and the input shaft clearances. Can't leak out thru the outlet (up hill). You have apparently eliminated the inlet tube & connection to pump as sucking air possibilities. I'll certainly be interested to see where this goes.
 
I agree with you HOBO,but why won't it suck? Low hours tractor. Housing is not worn. New
gears, New bushing reamed to the proper size, the pick-up- tube is not leaking, the side
plate that the pick-up tube attaches to is not worn and the gasket is new. The screen on
the drain plug is clean and looks new.You can stick it in a pan of oil and turn it by hand
and and it will pump.The oil pan is off and the pump is disassembled again. If it was
anything but an N I would put a new oil pump on it and be done with it, But that wasn't in
Mr Henry Fords plans.
 

The oil plug screen has nuttin to do with it. You need to bolt it back up on the tractor and check suction while cranking the engine with the starter. If it will draw a good vacuum nuttin is wrong with the pump look else where...I will agree if it will pick up the oil by hand and the pick up tube is good the pump may not be your problem.
If all the specs (ALL OF THEM) check out on the pump its not the pump...

TOH has a test stand for the pump contact him...

I will admit I never check pump gear to oil pick up tube housing its been posted as a problem that was a fix...

This guy went the extra mile a very good post with a fix...

http://forums.yesterdaystractors.com/viewtopic.php?t=1225775&highlight=
 
Check the clearance from gears to side plate. Also, the weld where tube attaches might be letting it suck air. Maybe a little pinhole. I have an 8 N that was overhauled before. A major overhaul, but the new rod bolts where just a few threads too long. They hit the pickup tube and knocked it loose from the plate as well.as wore a hole in the tube
 
I guess I should have read it better. Sounds like you checked the tube . But use some plastigauge on the side clearance, that can only be .001 or .002 with the gasket. I had one of them rebuild kits. The old gears were better than the new ones. Those are a dirty sob at times. I like hobo' s suggestion. Put a vacume gauge on the tip of the.pickup tube and check the suck. I will have to remember that trick.
 
Welding man,you might want to check the plate with the tube for flatness where it bolts to the pump,the bolts could have been over tightened bent or warped the plate some causing a small leak between the plate and the pump that the gasket won't quite seal.
 
(quoted from post at 20:55:54 10/05/17) Customer and a friend, brought me a 1949 8n front mount dist tractor a while back and
and asked me to get it running, said it had been in his family every since new,was a
very low hours tractor that had been sitting a long time but they could not get it
started.He really did't want to spend a lot of money on it, but would like to see it
running again. It had been converted to 12 V. We checked all the usual stuff,got fire,
rebuilt carb. We got it started and it had NO oil pressure. We removed the relief valve
pumped it full of 90 Wt. and started it again. No oil pressure. Finally decided to pull
the pan to see if pick-up tube was broken. Every thing looked good.Pulled oil
pump,disassembled it. Looked new. Pulled main caps. Could tell they had been dry but no
damage. Saw a little rust in a couple of the cylinders. Pulled head, knocked pistons
out, no ring groove. Miced crank. Good condition.Everything in the engine was 100%
original Ford. Ordered a set of rings ,rod and main bearings and oil pump kit. Honed
block, rebuilt the oil pump( remembering I have all the Ford tools to do this little
job),definitely not the first one I ever did either. Plasti-guaged everything and put
her back together. Filled her up with 30 wt and started her up. Guess what NO oil
pressure. Shut it down. Did the old primer trick fired her up and horray 20 Lbs of oil
pressure. A measley 20 pounds. Changed the gauge and still 20 pounds. Changed the relief
valve and spring,18 lbs. Shut her off and let it set for half hour lunch break and fired
her up, No oil pressure. Primed the pump again and 20 pounds again. If the tractor sits
for over 30 minutes it looses it's prime.We have pressure checked the suction tube. The
pan is back off the oil pump is disassembled again and I don't know what the next move
really is other than dig a hole and bury the sucker. I have way more time and parts in
this thing than I ever charge for but I hate to give up. We have rebuilt 4 tractor
engines in the last month and this one has caused more problems than all the rest put
together. Anyone else ever had a similar problem?

I have had pumps on my test stand that look and behave identically:
  • [*:5c312955be]Some signs of wear on the housing walls but nothing that looks gross. Clearance seem to be reasonable[*:5c312955be]Known good pickup tube that I can visually monitor during operation[*:5c312955be]Prime the pumps and they pump fine[*:5c312955be]Let them sit for "short" periods of time and they will hold prime and pump again[*:5c312955be]Let them sit longer and they lose prime and won't pump. Some will hold for a few hours, some will hold for half a day or so - even longer - but they eventually lose prime[*:5c312955be]No visible indications of leakage or any other unusual behavior[/list:eek::5c312955be]All I can do based on that is speculate. If you look at how the pump is shaped you can see that the bottom of the pumping section is below the oil pickup tube opening and the shaft/bushing on the driven gear. That means there will be a small puddle of oil trapped there that cannot drain back into the sump. The bushing and/or shaft could be worn to he!! and back and oil would still be trapped in that area. I believe it is that oil that maintains prime across run cycles and as you can see from the picture below there isn't going to be a lot of it. I have also come to the conclusion that pumps that won't hold prime are simply worn to the point that the small volume of oil held in that area is not sufficient to maintain an oil film (suction) long enough to completely refill the pickup tube. At startup the oil is pulled around the gears spreading it along the worn walls, the film is lost because there is not enough volume to fill the voids cused by wear, and the oil in the partially filled pickup tube drains back into the sump leaving you with a running engine and no oil supply.

    In other words - these pumps are slap worn out and the only real fix is to replace them with a new or known good one with all that entails. I've seen so many of these I have started telling folks that contact me with oil pump problems to bite the bullet and replace the OEM pump with a NEW late 8N style (3/4" gears) pump whenever the do an overhaul. Replacing the pump is an added $300-$400 overhaul expense but at 65 to nearly 80 years old most of the original pumps are simply at or very near end of life and it's a lot easier and cheaper to do it up front than it is to fix it after the overhaul has been completed. Making the oil pump part of a main bearing cap was a truly bad design but in all fairness the Ford engineers probably never dreamed they would still be in use after that many years. I am afraid that is just one of the realities of owning an N-series tractor.

    TOH

    OilPump.jpg
 
TOH, thank you very much for your input. The only question is. Can the pump be replaced
without having the block and new front bearing cap line bored? I would not think the
tolerances would be close enough to get by without line boring. Your experience and input on this please.
 

Wish I would have said dat :wink:


I have run across many an oil pressure problem on various engines that a new pump did not fix… I have spent a thousand are more on an engine replacing the pump and timing chain parts only to have the same problem. I have had engines that the lifters would rattle on start up till the engine warmed up a pump did not fix the issue. In all cases if I would have checked the pumps ability to suck I would have known the pump was not the issue and could have applied that money toward the final cost of going into the engine and finding the root cause of the issue. On some engines the pick-up tube is not bolted to the pump it’s mounted to the block. On these engines I have ran across the pick-up tube is not bolted to the pump its mounted to the block. On these engines I found the gasket/o-ring blown between the pick-up tube and block it would take 15 sec to produce oil pressure a vacuum check confirmed I had no suction for that time period. As usual about the time you think you have it all figured out you get the same car/engine combination in with the same issue and find you don’t have a suction issue. There is no need to waste time and money on the pump you need to dig deeper into the engine to find were its losing oil pressure.
I have never read are see folks talk about the suction side of the pump I came up with this after my failed attempts to resolve oil pressure issues. As you can see not everything is in a book not every issue is a pattern frailer. We are lucky to have a few that go the extra mile to resolve these issues instead of blowing the same old BS out there arse on every issue.

Thank you THO for your work I now have more ammo to go after these issues...
 
He hasn't spent a dime yet. I have spent the money. He may chose not to even fix it. I may end up with the tractor. This happens more often than you may think. I have another one and a skid steer sitting here now that customers just don't want to spend any more money and they say keep it.
 
(quoted from post at 07:48:13 10/06/17) TOH, thank you very much for your input. The only question is. Can the pump be replaced
without having the block and new front bearing cap line bored? I would not think the
tolerances would be close enough to get by without line boring. Your experience and input on this please.

There are folks that will tell you that you don't have to line hone the block to replace the pump (front cap). I am not one of them and if you search the archives you will find at least one thread where I debated at great length the hows and whys of this with a non-believer. In fact I don't know of any engine where you can replace a main bearing cap without a line hone and the reason is simple. During manufacture the caps and block are bolted together and bored as a mated set. That allows the factory to save considerably on setup costs - they don't have to be perfectly centered and parallel to all of the parting lines for a complete run of 100's of thousands (maybe millions) of engines. As a result there is almost ZERO chance the resulting halves in the block and cap are true semi-circles. It doesn't matter because as long as they stay where they were bored and turned the proper way, the resulting holes are all round and the tunnel is straight. That's why every professional engine builder knows you can't move caps from one block to another, from one position to another on the same block, or reverse them in the block. The new cap could and may even be a perfect (within tolerances) semi-circle but it won't match it's mating half in the factory bored block because that halve is not. Without a line bore after replacement the front main bearing housing is not going to be round (within tolerance) and you are playing Russian Roulette with that bearing/journal. So as Mr. D. Harry famously said - "are you feeling lucky sir (sic)". I counted and I think he only fired 5 shots so I'm not feeling lucky. :roll:

TOH
 

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top