Flush or not flush

Ron Sa

Member
From time to time I read posts suggesting that old engines be flushed with a strong oil detergent and then start using high detergent oil. I choose to not do that and here is why.

Generally speaking, flushing only partially flushes. A new detergent added partially dissolves some of the crud but only loosens some of the curd. The loosened crud becomes “cholesterol” in the engine’s blood stream and will likely cause damage to close fitting bearings.

Would the oil filter on my DC Cases quickly filter out all the solid particles of loosened crud? I don’t think so. It is not a “full flow” filter. The tiny oil lines, going to and from the DC oil filter, need a “thousand trips” of the oil thru the oil pump for all the oil to have made one pass thru the filter.

From many years of scrubbing curd off engine internal surfaces, it has become my theory that most curd tends to stay harmlessly in place unless attacked by a new detergent. Therefore, I use oil for my antique tractors that is labeled as heavy duty, non-detergent.
 
I agree however: most tractors of the 40's and 50's that would have started their service life with non-detergent oil would have had oil changes in its life with detergent oil. If you bought a tractor as the second owner maybe not. pulling the pan and valve cover will definately tell you which way to go. The most noticeable result from the change will be LOWER oil pressure. Not generally a good thing when most letter tractors don't have much pressure to start with. I have changed to detergent on all my tractors and have worried about it ever since but have not lost any YET! your results may vary.......
 
Funny you should mention the DC's oil filter system. When I look at the size of the lines to and from the filter, my first reaction, are you kidding me? I do wonder just how many hours of running it takes to "clean/filter" all the oil. But I guess it was agood first step. gobble
 
Your DC has hand holes on the sides of the pan. You can remove a lot of crud thru these you can also clean the screen on the oil pump. Good way to check out the lower half at the same time.
 
I agree those hand holes are handy for cleaning out deep crud at the bottom and also cleaning the oil screens. I have done that on my L, C, and a DC or two. Takes quite a bit of gasoline, a good scrub tool. the air hose, and several flushes to get it clean. This tells me that a detergent oil flush is probably not all that effective.

We know the later DCs have floating oil screens so low oil levels make that crud not so harmless in that area. Also, we know the fixed screens on the earlier tractors are subject to getting plugged.
 

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top